Rooney

Watch my username. All of them

5 is that it then W and R

Evra? - if a replacement is found
Rio? - yes
Giggs - yes
Anderson - not unless someone is signed
Young - yes
Cleverley? - why would you get rid of him?
Welbeck? - as above
Bebe - yes
Macheda - yes
Valencia? - if a replacement is signed

comment by Dunc _ im macca's grandson (U11713)
posted 45 seconds ago

Cleverley? - why would you get rid of him?
Welbeck? - as above
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thats what the ? was for, dont think many mind either way

Agree with Dunk on them all.

i feel we are having a moment here maestro

Giggs Anderson Young & Fletcher need to be moved on. I would look to replace Evra in Jan and Rio should only be used as 4th choice behind Vidic, Evans & Jones.

Cleverley is a good squad player that can do the job asked of him. Let him go and you need to spend money on another back up CM who is going to accept being a bit part behind Carrick, Fellaini and whichever CM Moyes manages to get in the next 2 windows.

At the moment, Cleverley would be my choice to partner Carrick at the weekend. If he's fit.

I also think Kagawa might leave in the summer, the

Clevs still has the potential to keep improving.... Fletcher is a good example of good player who pushed on and had two very good seasons before being hit by illness.

Clevs could easily surpass the level Fletch showed in 2009... So I would certainly keep him.

Kagawa will almost certainly leave next summer. He's just not suited to our style of football and he's not good enough to warrant dropping either RVP or Rooney quite frankly.

Hopefully we get a good amount for him though and use the funds wisely to get a player more suited to our team.

And Anderson should have gone 3 years ago.

SE,

totally disagree.

he is good enough, the problem is we are too rigid in our play.

you stick Kagawa in the barcelona or bayern teams, or back at dortmund and he will show how good he is.

Evra - if a replacement is found of better quality
Rio - time to retire
Giggs - Should have retired 8 years ago
Anderson - nobody would buy him so it's pointless
Young - squad player, can be sold if a replacement is bought
Cleverley - nope, he's good to have in the team
Welbeck - as above
Bebe - No, play him in the league cup as a striker, if he's crap, then sell him
Macheda - yes, should have been sold ages ago
Valencia - no way

Evra? - yes but needs to be replaced with someone like baines or coentrao
Rio? - yes
Giggs - yes
Anderson - yes and promote powell
Young - yes
Cleverley? - why would you get rid of him?
Welbeck? - as above
Bebe - yes
Macheda - yes
Valencia? - if a replacement is signed
fletcher yes
fabio- want him to stay but for the sake of his career needs to go
kagawa- same as fabio