Anonymous so far

i was joking when i did the article..................

but did he go to Wigan to play football or to be with his Corrie missus?

Wilkins said he doesn't want the ball enough, and on the basis of this game I would have to agree

Is Wigan his level long term do you think?

Biggish

I think Wilkins said that on Goals on Sunday.

I think he was better placed than myself to make that judgement, but i think this clamour for him to play every week (slight exaggeration) was based on the Newcastle match.

Personally, I don't think the club have failed Josh.

Think it's unfair to judge how big an impact he has on games against City with the tactics they're playing

I think he bought into his own hype around the training grounds when he was 17. No doubt he was very talented for his age at that time, he just doesn't seemed to have progressed much.

McCrapron

I live a couple of blocks away from that bitch

TBK....of course it is, but nonetheless when Wigan have the ball he does seem to show for it nor do the Wigan players appear to look for him............

does not seem to show for it

He looked shot ..never even once asked for ball, snailing...over all not a PL player

Good victory for Wigan, although I was hoping they'd gone through so they could rack up even more games...

As for Josh, he looked lost and really slow on and off the ball. Wigan did well to win given a few of their players were just jogging about.

Their Spanish striker seems to be a decent players though, could be a Premier League players I think.

By they, I mean Man City.