or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 148 comments are related to an article called:

How did you score The Maidana vs Mayweather

Page 6 of 6

posted on 5/5/14

I'm not gonna research it.

Oscar picked the gloves vs floyd, and I dont remember any bitching afterward.

Morales regularly selected the gloves if I remember correctly.

Floyd has done more than once.

Wlad chose the gloves in the Haye match didn't he?

My point is the NAME fighter selecting the gloves is not exactly unheard of, and any talk about it after the result is sour grapes.

posted on 5/5/14

"Oscar picked the gloves vs floyd, and I dont remember any bitching afterward."
===

lmfao what?! Floyd moans about how he couldn't pick his own gloves against Oscar whenever people talk about that fight. Further exposing his hypocrisy.

posted on 5/5/14

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 5/5/14

That was in the contract given Floyd to train with the gloves. Not the case with Maidana as you well know. And this was longer than 5 years ago.

And Wlad did not pick the gloves against Haye.

So the only one you can come with was Morales, but even that one I eluded to.

SLS you don't have a clue do you?

posted on 5/5/14

Boxing Media Scores

Tim Starks (The Queensberry Rules : 114-114 DRAW **

Scott Christ (Bad Leftt Hook) : 115-113 Mayweather

Barry Jones (Boxnation TV) : 117-111 Mayweather

Steve Lillis (Boxnation TV) : 116-113 Mayweather

John Wharton (KCC Boxing Show) : 114-114 DRAW **

Ron Lewis (The Times) : 116-114 Mayweather

Kevin Iole (Yahoo) : 115-113 Mayweather

Adam Abramowitz (Saturday Night Boxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Chris Mannix (Sports Illustrated) : 116-112 Mayweather

Dan Rafael (ESPN) : 115-113 Mayweather

Mike Coppinger (USA Today) : 115-113 Mayweather

Alex Morris (KTC Boxing) : 114-114 DRAW **

Ramon Aranda (3 More Rounds) : 115-113 Mayweather

Paul Webb (First Class Boxing) : 116-112 Mayweather

Cliff Rold (BoxingScene) : 114-114 DRAW **

Shaun Brown (Boxingscene) : 115-113 Mayweather

Steve Zemach (Queensberry Rules) : 114-114 DRAW **

Brian Campbell (ESPN) : 115-113 Mayweather

Michael Woods (The Sweet Science) : 117-113 Mayweather

All About Boxing : 114-114 DRAW **

Victor M Salazar (Tha Boxing Voice) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Steve Kim (Maxboxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Corey Quincy (FightersXchange) : 115-113 Mayweather

Asian Boxing : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Al Bernstein (Showtime TV) : 115-114 Mayweather

Steve Farhood (Showtime TV) : 115-113 Mayweather

Paulie Malignaggi (Showtime TV) : 115-114 Mayweather

Boxing Socialist : 115-113 Mayweather

The Heavy Bag : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Danny Winterbottom (Boxing News) : 117-113 Mayweather

Wolfgang Shiffbauer (Sturm Promotions) : 115-113 Mayweather

Paddy Cronan (OnTheGrindBoxing) : 117-111 Mayweather

Danny Flexen (Boxing News) : 116-112 Mayweather

Matt Mojica (The Fight Source) : 115-113 Mayweather

Tris Dixon (Boxing News ED) : 117-112 Mayweather

Phil D Jay (World Boxing News) : 115-113 Mayweather

Steve Bunce (Boxnation TV) : 116-112 Mayweather

Pro Boxing Fans : 116-112 Mayweather

James Tonks (Ringnews 24) : 115-113 Mayweather

Boxing Mad Magazine : 115-113 Mayweather

Stevie J Adams (Boxing Mad Magazine) : 117-112 Mayweather

Nathan Fogg (Boxing News Online): 116-112 Mayweather

The Boxing Advocaat : 116-112 Mayweather

Iconic Boxing : 115-113 Mayweather

Fight Insight : 115-113 Mayweather

Lou Dibella (Promoter) : 116-113 Mayweather

V2 Boxing : 116-113 Mayweather

Daniel Vano (Checkhookboxing) : 115-114 MAIDANA***

The Boxing Channel : 115-113 Mayweather

Check Left : 116-112 MAIDANA***

The Title Fight : 114-114 DRAW **

New Legend Boxing : 115-113 Mayweather

Ray Markarian (The Sweet Science) : 116-113 Mayweather

William Holmes (Boxing Insider) : 116-112 Mayweather

Danny Gonzalez (Tha Boxing Voice) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Joel Sebastianelli (KO Digest) : 116-112 Mayweather

Ryan Bivins (SweetBoxing) : 116-112 Mayweather

Onthebeak Boxing : 115-114 Mayweather

Ring Magazine TV : 118-110 Mayweather

Max Kellerman (HBO TV) : 116-112 Mayweather

Jake Donovan (Boxingscene) : 115-113 Mayweather

Nacion Boxeo : 115-113 Mayweather

Josh McDaniel (Leave It The Ring Radio) : 116-113 Mayweather

Write On The Button : 115-113 Mayweather

Kevin McRae (Bleacher Report) : 115-113 Mayweather

Fight Ghost : 115-113 Mayweather

The Cruelest Sport : 116-113 Mayweather

Gareth A Davies (The Telegraph) : 116-113 Mayweather

Tommy Allan (Boxing Asylum) : 115-113 Mayweather

Nigel Collins (ESPM FNFs) : 114-114 DRAW **

Ron Borges ( Boston Herald) : 115-114 Mayweather

NY Post : 115-113 Mayweather

The Sweet Science : 116-113 Mayweather

Leave It In The Ring Radio : 115-113 Mayweather

Associated Press : 115-113 Mayweather

ESPN.com : 115-113 Mayweather

Jeff Powell (The Mail) : 117-113 Mayweather

John Hoolan (Freelance) : 114-114 DRAW **

Liam Hoppe (Eurosport) : 115-113 Mayweather

Ben Thompson (Fighthype) : 118-110 Mayweather

UK Fighthype : 117-111 Mayweather

TKO Radio : 115-115 DRAW **

Steve Carp (Las Vegas Review-Journal) : 116-112 Mayweather

S.I.com : 116-112 Mayweather

Ernest Gabion (BoxingScene) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

3 More Rounds : 115-113 Mayweather

Mike Sloan (Secondsout) : 117-111 Mayweather

John J Raspanti (Doghouseboxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Anthony Larger (Bad Left Hook) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Kevin Mitchell (The Guardian) : 116-114 Mayweather

Andy Paterson (BoxingAsylum) : 115-113 Mayweather

Ed Robinson (Sky Sports TV) : 115-113 Mayweather

John Evans (Live Fight) : 116-112 Mayweather

Aaron Richardson (BoxingAsylum) : 115-113 Mayweather

Kasim Aslam (Global Boxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Ciaran Shanks (Irvine Times) : 115-113 Mayweather

Tom Gray (Ring Magazine) : 115-113 Mayweather

Marcos Villegas (The Boxing Channel) : 116-113 Mayweather

Ciaran Gibbons (Freelance) : 117-114 Mayweather

Lee John Wyle (The Sweet Science) : 115-113 Mayweather

Mathew McEvoy (Forever Sports) : 116-113 Mayweather

John A MacDonald (Livefight) : 115-113 Mayweather

Agent One Sports : 115-113 Mayweather

Chris Davies (LCD Boxing) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Paul Daley (TopClassBoxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Boxing.com : 114-114 Draw **

Sam Sheppard (Queensberry Rules) : 116-112 Mayweather

Billy Ferguson (UK Fighthype) : 116-112 Mayweather

Ben Weisman (BoxingAsylum) : 116-112 Mayweather

Kieran Mulvaney (ESPN) : 116-112 Mayweather

Andrew McKart (FirstClassBoxing) : 114-114 DRAW **

posted on 5/5/14

Round 1 Maidana
Round 2 Even
Round 3 Maidana
Round 4 Maidana
Round 5 Maidana
Round 6 Fraud
Round 7 Fraud
Round 8 Maidana
Round 9 Fraud
Round 10 Fraud
Round 11 Fraud
Round 12 Maidana

115-114 Maidana

posted on 5/5/14

Fraud

I think most of the media outlets had the scores right to be honest. Most called it in favour of Floyd. Few had maidana and few had a draw. Dont think Maidana did enough in the 2nd half of the fight.

Check out Ben Thomspon's scores from Fighthype

posted on 5/5/14

Wow Mr C, some of those scores are shocking. Scoring the fight slightly in favour of either fighter is fine, could've gone either way.

118-110 I bet he lives in Floyd's ass

posted on 5/5/14

FightHype

It just a Fraud propaganda machine, satirically know as Floydhype

posted on 5/5/14

comment by Kamran. (U1204)
posted 44 seconds ago
Wow Mr C, some of those scores are shocking. Scoring the fight slightly in favour of either fighter is fine, could've gone either way.

118-110I bet he lives in Floyd's ass
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If it is Ben Thompson they, it is true.

When Floyd was in hiding from Pacquiao it was the only person Floyd would let interview him.

Floyd invited Ben to his house to spend some time with him.

posted on 5/5/14

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 5/5/14

It is gospel, and I'm going to preach it!

posted on 5/5/14

I dislike Mayweather, but i agree he won, but if you had mayweather winning by more than 3 rounds you need to eyes and head checking

posted on 6/5/14

So, D4, you admit that Morales, Oscar and Floyd all picked gloves, but I don't have a clue for suggesting this wasn't the first time?

Get out man.

posted on 6/5/14

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bmv7Ds3CUAEGcMH.jpg:large

posted on 6/5/14

http://www.gigapan.com/gigapans/154424

comment by Faither (U3393)

posted on 7/5/14

Mayweather wins 8 rounds to 4.

Maidana did cause problems but a lot of his work was untidy and his overhand right's were catching Floyd on top/back of the head.

Floyd was putting his head down to evade these but got caught with a few.

Maidana did look dangerous but from round 6 onward apart from 8 Floyd was in full command and was too quick against a heavily tiring Maidana who I think

Floyd could have stopped him imo if he took a bit more of a chance but why would you when you are racking up the rounds.

posted on 7/5/14

"Floyd could have stopped him imo"
===

And asked him the date?

comment by Faither (U3393)

posted on 8/5/14

So you agree with all the rest of my post then Kamran?

Maidana's conditioning was his downfall and Floyd took full advantage by picking him off at will in the later rounds.

posted on 8/5/14

Cristobal, I agree that Maidana gassed out. I had him 5-1 up after the first half of the fight, he started slowing down after that point and Floyd took advantage of that, so I dunno why people keep saying 'Floyd adjusted' or 'Floyd figured Maidana out'...no, he didn't, he simply took advantage of Maidana punching himself out.

And even then, I scored the fight 6-6. I'm yet to watch it a second time...

posted on 11/5/14

D4 cant score fights.

posted on 11/5/14


For me definitely the better fighter on the night. I just had Maidana winning 7 rounds to 5.

posted on 11/5/14

Having just read your article Gunner i wouldnt laugh at other peoples inability to score fights. Although i disagree with D4 and agree with you that Mayweather won, Mayweather barely got into the fight before the 5th/6th round, Maidana was swarming FMJ quite comfortably and Floyd was always looking to the ref to help him out.

Page 6 of 6

Sign in if you want to comment