or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 72 comments are related to an article called:

Under-rated players/ over-rated players?

Page 3 of 3

posted on 19/8/11

How is rooney not on the overrated list????

posted on 19/8/11

Rafa Joke
Rooney is not over-rated

posted on 19/8/11

Or its opinion. Messi is overrated because many people consider him the best Player EVER. And in my earlier post i explained my reasons.

posted on 19/8/11

umm yes he is. massively overrated for someone who couldnt score for the best part of last season

posted on 19/8/11


If someone is truly a great player he may be over-rated if he is described as the "best ever" without just cause.
This does not mean he is not a great player, but simply not quite of the stature claimed, thus would be "over-rated".

In Messi's case, it is a valid point that he has not shown that class for his country as the likes of Garrincha, Pele and Maradona have.

posted on 19/8/11

umm yes he is. massively overrated for someone who couldnt score for the best part of last season

...................

Like Torres at Anfield then.

posted on 19/8/11

vidicschin


i forgot to say vidic is overrated too, for a defender who just stonewall blocks attackers and gets away with dubious fouls

posted on 19/8/11

Rafa
Are all Liverpool players under rated?

posted on 19/8/11

no, just at their right level of rate i think

posted on 19/8/11

i forgot to say vidic is overrated too

................

That's ok son, you are a cretin, so I forgive you.

posted on 19/8/11

no, just at their right level of rate i think

..........................

Below average?

posted on 19/8/11

vidic is a cretin too, and he looks like a gimp

posted on 19/8/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 19/8/11

nope vidic, not its not. its vidic in real life

posted on 19/8/11

nope vidic, not its not.

.................

What kind of nonsensical jibberish is this?

..................

its vidic in real life

....................

Yes, but you have not told me what a gimp is, so I have nothing to compare it too.

posted on 19/8/11

Come on Rafa Jack. You have called someone a gimp. Surely you must know what a gimp is.

Or is it a new word you learnt in the playground today?

posted on 19/8/11

Rafa Jack you are a

posted on 19/8/11

http://forthesakeofscience.files.wordpress.com/2011/05/seriously-meme.jpg

comment by MBL. (U6305)

posted on 19/8/11

A gimp is a se. X slave that is chained up and regularily humiliated, they force him to where a Glen Johnson Liverpool shirt!

comment by MBL. (U6305)

posted on 19/8/11

Fecking I phone, regulary is what i meant to say!

posted on 20/8/11

Rafa-jack-off (U8014) "(Vidic)...gets away with dubious fouls"


If a foul is dubious, it means it is doubtful; if there is doubt whether or not it was a foul, then there can be no question of penalising someone for it; thus it is not a case of "getting away with" anything!

By the way, the topic is "players who are over (or under)-rated", not players who you envy from teams who you envy hence someone you wish to denigrate.

posted on 20/8/11

adam, i do not envy vidic at all, such a ratbag its unreal

Page 3 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment