Gibbs, Ox, Wilshere

Sanchez

Zelalem out!

Ignoring the new players I said

Alexis (Kamran?), Gibbs isn't a bad shout, but many fans have slated all 3 of those at some point and said they're not good enough for our club.

I'm not Kamran. I'm a beautiful specimen, not the mess that Kamran is.

I have no idea why you're signalling us gooners out, every team's fans will at some point criticise a player.

Alexis I'm a gooner myself, it's just something I was thinking earlier and thought it would be an interesting thing to discuss

The majority? Most of the players.

Gibbs is the only one

Diaby..

I can honestly say I have never wanted out:

Koscielny
Gibbs
Walcott
Giroud
Wilshere
Ramsey
Oxlade Chamberlain
Jenkinson
Ozil

Very conflicted about Mertesackerand Arteta. I've never said I have wanted them to leave but if they left in the summer and we replaced with quality, I wouldn't be heartbroken. In the future I think I ll never say I want Welbeck, Chambers or Sanchez to go at any point

No way is it the majority. It is the loudest, most persistent people rather than the majority.

The majority are more level headed than that.

Recently Gibbs has not been mentioned to be sold as he's been one of our most consistent player but he definitely has when he was very injury prone whilst we had Clichy, Traore, Santos. Back then he was definitely classed as the deadwood that needed to be sold.

Kos had his moment when he first signed and was rash and couldn't form a partnership with Vermaelen

TBF I would say Ox. Yes some said he was not good enough to start, saying he should be an impact sub, or he's been ineffective but never really mentioned to be sold.

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 8 minutes ago
No way is it the majority. It is the loudest, most persistent people rather than the majority.

The majority are more level headed than that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
ok maybe 'wanted out' is a bit strong, but if you interpreted it as 'have at some point wanted to sell and replace', would you still say the same?

What about Kos the Boss?

comment by V - If you eat caviar every day it's diff... (U7971)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 8 minutes ago
No way is it the majority. It is the loudest, most persistent people rather than the majority.

The majority are more level headed than that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
ok maybe 'wanted out' is a bit strong, but if you interpreted it as 'have at some point wanted to sell and replace', would you still say the same?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, it is still the minority.

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by V - If you eat caviar every day it's diff... (U7971)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 8 minutes ago
No way is it the majority. It is the loudest, most persistent people rather than the majority.

The majority are more level headed than that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
ok maybe 'wanted out' is a bit strong, but if you interpreted it as 'have at some point wanted to sell and replace', would you still say the same?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, it is still the minority.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, out of our current batch who would you want to replace right now?

Personally I'd keep our keepers, in defence replace Mertesacker, replace Wilshere, Flamini and Diaby in midfield and Podolski up front. Happy with the rest for now

Martinez

There are plenty of players I'd never wanted sold but want out of the first 11. We have a lot of talented players who have no competition and therefore no real motivation.

Occasionally they have the mentality to push on regardless, Fabregas being the most obvious one but then again he was motivated by proving he was good enough for Barca.

I think it's right to want certain players out of the first 11 and to give them something to fight for. We haven't really done this and I think it's caused a lot of todays problems.

Gervinho

Ox?

comment by 魔法の~Arsène Wenger's Magic Hat~帽子 (U6490)
posted 17 minutes ago
Ox?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ox was maligned from the first minute by some people. It was the year we were about to lose Fabregas and Nasri, and we were crying out for top quality to convince them both we meant business. When another expensive kid turned up, there was... anger. A couple of posters on here at the time were trying to convince people not to resent the player himself for it.

Diaby

Fabregas, nasri, van persie

I seriously wonder why they bother having user names on here at times - it seems whoever shouts loudest is automatically speaking for the 'majority'.

I'm struggling far more to think of a current player that the majority HAVE wanted out - maybe Giroud at times, but even then some people (rightly or wrongly) appreciate what he does bring to the team rather than moan about what he doesn't.

Emma Byrne.

Never wanted gibbs out despite being trash going forward, never wanted ramsey out despite 90% fans turning on him

Recent players I have wanted out - Ox, Debuchy, Welbeck, Cazorla, Wilshere