or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 25 comments are related to an article called:

25M + Fellaini for Schneiderlin?

Page 1 of 1

posted on 20/1/15

First of all, let's unpack this phrase 'I have it on good authority'

posted on 20/1/15

That would be a crazy bid

posted on 20/1/15

The absolute minimum Fellaini is worth is £15 million. Probably a bit more to a side who want to use him behind the main striker.

posted on 20/1/15

comment by Robb - My good man. (U19350)
posted 37 seconds ago
The absolute minimum Fellaini is worth is £15 million. Probably a bit more to a side who want to use him behind the main striker.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah if a side want to use him behind the striker it'll cost them their manager

posted on 20/1/15

comment by Red Russian (U4715)
posted 2 minutes ago
First of all, let's unpack this phrase 'I have it on good authority'
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This.

posted on 20/1/15

Apparently the first day Koeman walked into training at Southampton he saw Schneiderlin and said quite firmly that he wanted to keep him and wouldn't allow him to leave.

I would quite like schneiderlin but can't see Koeman allowing him to leave this window. He would improve us quite a lot and is vastly underrated by fans on here.

comment by Ruiney (U1005)

posted on 20/1/15


comment by Shinjisshin (U1700)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by Robb - My good man. (U19350)
posted 37 seconds ago
The absolute minimum Fellaini is worth is £15 million. Probably a bit more to a side who want to use him behind the main striker.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah if a side want to use him behind the striker it'll cost them their manager
...



comment by Ruiney (U1005)

posted on 20/1/15

This would be a complete rip off, so I wouldn't be surprised if it's true.

posted on 20/1/15

comment by Red Russian (U4715)
posted 10 minutes ago
First of all, let's unpack this phrase 'I have it on good authority'
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Google-translated it for you in the OP.

posted on 20/1/15

comment by Robb - My good man. (U19350)
posted 10 minutes ago
The absolute minimum Fellaini is worth is £15 million. Probably a bit more to a side who want to use him behind the main striker.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

transfermarkt's current valuation is £17.6M, and if anything they tend to be a bit below actual market. I reckoned 20 upwards to anyone interested enough, considering too that he's both a vital part of LvG's team and the quintessential United player.

posted on 20/1/15

Tbh I think in today's market and with his importance to us he's worth at least £72 million. Possibly more when you take the merchandising benefits he also brings.

posted on 20/1/15

comment by Robb - My good man. (U19350)
posted 27 seconds ago
Tbh I think in today's market and with his importance to us he's worth at least £72 million. Possibly more when you take the merchandising benefits he also brings.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

It's not just the novelty wigs.

With a billboard of Fellaini's size you easily double the total advertising area.

posted on 20/1/15

I just made up this rumour that United are preparing the above bid in an effort to beat their competitors to the signing of the much-valued French int'l.

------------------------------------------



On the reliability scale I'd put you above the Sun and Goal.com, but below Guillem Balague

posted on 20/1/15

comment by Red Russian (U4715)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Robb - My good man. (U19350)
posted 27 seconds ago
Tbh I think in today's market and with his importance to us he's worth at least £72 million. Possibly more when you take the merchandising benefits he also brings.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

It's not just the novelty wigs.

With a billboard of Fellaini's size you easily double the total advertising area.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm thinking about creating this year's must have Christmas present - the Fellaini foam elbow.

posted on 20/1/15

25m+ Marouanne for Karim? Then you have a deal.

comment by Busby (U19985)

posted on 20/1/15

Nope, Schniderlin, like many players we sign, is good in a system we don't use.

posted on 20/1/15

comment by Shinjisshin (U1700)
posted 24 minutes ago

On the reliability scale I'd put you above the Sun and Goal.com, but below Guillem Balague
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Ah, good old Guillem, the benchmark of Spanish sports journalism. His reputation in Spain is up there with the Armada's.

Robb, did you use Di María's transfer fee as a reference to reach that £72 million valuation?

If so, I agree.

Red Cog, no need to lower the tone of this article.

posted on 20/1/15

Ah, good old Guillem, the benchmark of Spanish sports journalism. His reputation in Spain is up there with the Armada's.
==============================

Are you insinuating he has conned the behemoths at Sky and co as being a 'Spanish football expert'?

posted on 20/1/15

I wouldn't dare.

posted on 20/1/15

comment by itsonlyagame - Let's go bowling! (U6426)
posted 41 seconds ago
I wouldn't dare.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't mind Balague too much. Sure he peddles a lot of faeces, but he is not the worst of the lot.

I am disappointed in Marcotti - though- whom i consider quite an insightful hack, but he seems to be associated a lot with an inferior hack in Balague.

Tainted by association, company you keep, yada yada.

posted on 20/1/15

Just an observation of this site, for the last few years all I've seen regarding transfers is "let's sign this dortmund player" " let's sign that dortmund player", "let's get Klopp in as manager", we'll all that's died a death this season, so who are we focusing on now?
Schneiderlin, Clyne and no doubt Tadic will be the next buzzword

posted on 20/1/15

The only player I see us going for from Southampton is Clyne. Strootman is the obsession for CM ...

posted on 20/1/15

comment by 🇬🇧 MARK.🇬🇧 (U1449)
posted 7 minutes ago
Just an observation of this site, for the last few years all I've seen regarding transfers is "let's sign this dortmund player" " let's sign that dortmund player", "let's get Klopp in as manager", we'll all that's died a death this season, so who are we focusing on now?
Schneiderlin, Clyne and no doubt Tadic will be the next buzzword
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Interesting observation. It is group-think which we are all susceptible to - some more than others.

Personally, if Reus is available (and Gundogan regains form and fitness), i would snap them up in a heartbeat as i feel those are potentially world class players.

Schneirderlin? Tadic? Meh! I don't view Clyne as an improvement on Rafael - the only thing he has over him is fitness.

posted on 20/1/15

The only thing he has over him is fitness

-------------

Which is the most important thing. Rafael could be the next Maldini or Cafu but if he can't stay fit he may as well be the next Theon Greyjoy!

posted on 20/1/15

Mark, tbh I just picked a name at random based on what I thought I could recall from Robb's waxing lyrical on Soton. Could've equally been Strootman, Wanyama or, if I'd gone by last weekend, Clyne.

RC, I don't really pay attention to any hacks, I prefer to rely on the wisdom of ja606.

Kloop, despite this season, I still rate as one of the best managers out there. I'm as baffled as the next man as to Dortmund's BL form.

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment