i dont think the loss of Jack would effect the outcome too much, still think Aberdeen will win fairy easily

would love to see him going abroad though, its the only way they'll develop

Ghod, I think tactically he's crucial to them.

When you consider the fact they virtually play 5 forwards in their starting XI (Goodwillie, Pawlett, Rooney, Hayes, McGinn) they need him sitting and protecting that defence. If he goes who comes in? Flood? He's nowhere near as good or as tactically astute to cover.

If Jack goes then the wheels could easily come off for them.

I have seen alot of hype about him , but if im being honest ive yet to assess him myself .

Lets be honest ....does he look like a furture Roma or Napoli midfielder?

CT

I quite like Pawlett but again, I don't think he's exceptional.

Armstrong is the best of the lot for me

I thought he was brilliant last Friday against St Johnstone.

I don't see why not.

He's physically strong, he reads the game well, he is tactically astute and has good technique.

Obviously I don't see him every week but when I do I think he looks a very good player, and he would obviously develop further playing with better players.

id rather have Jack than any other player in the SPL

everytime we play them hes the best player on the park

he ran the midfield when we beat them 2-1 the last time we played and also he was the standout player at CP when we won 2-1

I don't think there's any doubt he'd be a first choice at Celtic if he were to be signed by you.

hes probably unlucky midfields the most settled and strongest part of the Scottish set up

Ghod I'd still have him in the squad, certainly ahead of the likes of McArthur and probably Darren Fletcher at this moment in time, and I'd like to see him gradually easing himself into the first XI in this campaign.

agreed mate

comment by Ghodfather Donati #1 (U9390)
posted 10 minutes ago
id rather have Jack than any other player in the SPL

everytime we play them hes the best player on the park
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I trust your judgement , will keep an eye out for him

Do you not trust my judgement ya kant?

Roma and Napoli? Fair play to him.

Haven't really noticed him that much tbh. Watched the game on friday and he did nothing. Don't get the hype on here about him

see im the same with Armstrong i dont see the big attraction

weird how people see things different.

be interesting to know how Toiler rates him

comment by IvanGolacIsMagic (U5291)
posted 37 minutes ago
Do you not trust my judgement ya kant?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I do , but i dont value it much

Fair doos Ghod. I did look at Jack on friday. Decent player aye but didn't see much. Strange why players like McGregor and MacLeaod are getting call ups instead.

There's a centre mid berth up for grabs I think, Mulgrew is only temporary in there.

Jack is one of our best players, does all the dirty work in midfield, would be a huge loss..

Graeme Shinnie on his way to Pittodrie in the Summer, great signing, best LB in the league imo

Aberdeen 2 v 1 Utd my prediction

Donervon Daniels looks a decent signing too, mon the Dons!