I thought Cisse's +1 ban was for something else
Don't know for certain but heard someone else say it
Thats the rules, nothing to do with nationality. If you have already been sent off you get an extra game ban.
Trying to turn it into a racial thing
Cisse got an extra ban for receiving a second red card this season, this is nothing to do with race.
What an idiot.
Learn about the rules before spewing your bile.
Personally I think the FA should show a bit more common sense to the situation and ban Cisse for less seeing as first he's clearly admitted to it and stated he reacted to the spit from Evans in the first place. Yes it was wrong but on one hand you have a player completely denying it when the evidence clearly shows otherwise and the other has come forward and apologised - should show slight leniency to him.
Although yeah as mentioned his extra match ban comes into play because he's already been banned once before this season.
How will Evans pay his mortgage now
What a stupid caant the OP is
Trying to create a racial issue out of nothing is equally as disgusting as racism itself.
comment by Kav H (U19426)
posted 3 minutes ago
Personally I think the FA should show a bit more common sense to the situation and ban Cisse for less seeing as first he's clearly admitted to it and stated he reacted to the spit from Evans in the first place. Yes it was wrong but on one hand you have a player completely denying it when the evidence clearly shows otherwise and the other has come forward and apologised - should show slight leniency to him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair comment, I agree with that. Players must be encouraged to show remorse and accept their mistakes rather than waste everybody's time with stupid appeals like Evans did. Unfortunately the rules are very rigid atm.
Absolutely nothing to do with who's a foreigner and who's not. Utterly ludicrous suggestion.
So
Is the thread going as you imagined it op?
what a nob
I'd try and get this deleted before more people see this.
The OP is wrong about the extra match ban because those are the rules, and about the racial issue because it's got nothing to do with that. But he is right about the rules failing to acknowledge that Cisse has shown remorse and contrition whilst Evans ridiculously appealed in the face of clear, damning evidence.
Players must be encouraged to show remorse and accept their mistakes rather than waste everybody's time with stupid appeals like Evans did.
------------------------
He might be innocent though. It is that simple.
If I hadn't intentionally spat, nothing in this world would make me say I had.. Even if it meant a more lenient ban.
and before anyone says.... Yes, the FA have found him guilty, but that is not proof that he meant to do it.
If only life had an 'undo' button
but alas it doesn't
you're fecked mate
Ji
"He might be innocent though. It is that simple."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
But the evidence clearly shows that he was guilty, anybody can see that. It was a stupid appeal.
There's a thread right underneath this one talking about Evan's and the spitting incident.
Cisse got off lightly he kicked out attempted a headbutt then did a full blown spit to Evans neck. Honestly shocked if Evans gets a 6 game ban same as Cisse for the offence he did but Cisse gets another 1 for previous offence.
But the evidence clearly shows that he was guilty, anybody can see that.
------------------------------
It shows he spat on the floor.
Nothing can "prove" he was guilty. Nothing.
The point remains, players should never be encouraged to admit something they didn't do, just because it might get them a match less ban.
comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - Long Ball is Long (U2958)
posted 58 seconds ago
But the evidence clearly shows that he was guilty, anybody can see that.
------------------------------
It shows he spat on the floor.
Nothing can "prove" he was guilty. Nothing.
The point remains, players should never be encouraged to admit something they didn't do, just because it might get them a match less ban.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You are entitled to your opinions. The opinion that matters is that he is guilty and most people on these boards and even on Man U fan forums agree that he was guilty.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
The whole thing is a farce and has been blown out of proportion. Spitting is disgusting and should be punished.
However, it's ridiculous that spitting gets a 6 game ban, yet slapping someone round the face or a potential leg breaker should get a 3 game ban. Half the punishment! Shocking FA yet again.
And any suggestion that Cisse is some kind of Saint for admitting it, is BS. He made a pretty bad tackle, then tried to kick Evans, then spat at him. Should be a 10 game ban given the crazy FA, pull a number out of a hat, rules.
And still people insist Evans 'spat on the floor'...
Are you nuts? He spat downwards towards where Cisse was, right in front of him. For him to miss Cisse and hit the floor he'd have had to tilt his head left or right and spit to the side of Cisse, as opposed to, ya know, what he clearly did in every video clip of the incident available: looked directly at Cisse and spat in his direction.
Genuinely baffled as to how anyone is seeing anything different. Time to take off the United-tinted specs guys.
That said, it's a very harsh ban for both players
Sign in if you want to comment
How's this fair
Page 1 of 2
posted on 7/3/15
I thought Cisse's +1 ban was for something else
Don't know for certain but heard someone else say it
posted on 7/3/15
Thats the rules, nothing to do with nationality. If you have already been sent off you get an extra game ban.
Trying to turn it into a racial thing
posted on 7/3/15
Cisse got an extra ban for receiving a second red card this season, this is nothing to do with race.
posted on 7/3/15
What an idiot.
Learn about the rules before spewing your bile.
posted on 7/3/15
Personally I think the FA should show a bit more common sense to the situation and ban Cisse for less seeing as first he's clearly admitted to it and stated he reacted to the spit from Evans in the first place. Yes it was wrong but on one hand you have a player completely denying it when the evidence clearly shows otherwise and the other has come forward and apologised - should show slight leniency to him.
posted on 7/3/15
posted on 7/3/15
Although yeah as mentioned his extra match ban comes into play because he's already been banned once before this season.
posted on 7/3/15
How will Evans pay his mortgage now
posted on 7/3/15
What a stupid caant the OP is
posted on 7/3/15
Trying to create a racial issue out of nothing is equally as disgusting as racism itself.
posted on 7/3/15
comment by Kav H (U19426)
posted 3 minutes ago
Personally I think the FA should show a bit more common sense to the situation and ban Cisse for less seeing as first he's clearly admitted to it and stated he reacted to the spit from Evans in the first place. Yes it was wrong but on one hand you have a player completely denying it when the evidence clearly shows otherwise and the other has come forward and apologised - should show slight leniency to him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair comment, I agree with that. Players must be encouraged to show remorse and accept their mistakes rather than waste everybody's time with stupid appeals like Evans did. Unfortunately the rules are very rigid atm.
posted on 7/3/15
Absolutely nothing to do with who's a foreigner and who's not. Utterly ludicrous suggestion.
posted on 7/3/15
So
Is the thread going as you imagined it op?
what a nob
posted on 7/3/15
I'd try and get this deleted before more people see this.
posted on 7/3/15
The OP is wrong about the extra match ban because those are the rules, and about the racial issue because it's got nothing to do with that. But he is right about the rules failing to acknowledge that Cisse has shown remorse and contrition whilst Evans ridiculously appealed in the face of clear, damning evidence.
posted on 7/3/15
Players must be encouraged to show remorse and accept their mistakes rather than waste everybody's time with stupid appeals like Evans did.
------------------------
He might be innocent though. It is that simple.
If I hadn't intentionally spat, nothing in this world would make me say I had.. Even if it meant a more lenient ban.
and before anyone says.... Yes, the FA have found him guilty, but that is not proof that he meant to do it.
posted on 7/3/15
If only life had an 'undo' button
but alas it doesn't
you're fecked mate
posted on 7/3/15
Ji
"He might be innocent though. It is that simple."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
But the evidence clearly shows that he was guilty, anybody can see that. It was a stupid appeal.
posted on 7/3/15
There's a thread right underneath this one talking about Evan's and the spitting incident.
posted on 7/3/15
Cisse got off lightly he kicked out attempted a headbutt then did a full blown spit to Evans neck. Honestly shocked if Evans gets a 6 game ban same as Cisse for the offence he did but Cisse gets another 1 for previous offence.
posted on 7/3/15
But the evidence clearly shows that he was guilty, anybody can see that.
------------------------------
It shows he spat on the floor.
Nothing can "prove" he was guilty. Nothing.
The point remains, players should never be encouraged to admit something they didn't do, just because it might get them a match less ban.
posted on 7/3/15
comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - Long Ball is Long (U2958)
posted 58 seconds ago
But the evidence clearly shows that he was guilty, anybody can see that.
------------------------------
It shows he spat on the floor.
Nothing can "prove" he was guilty. Nothing.
The point remains, players should never be encouraged to admit something they didn't do, just because it might get them a match less ban.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You are entitled to your opinions. The opinion that matters is that he is guilty and most people on these boards and even on Man U fan forums agree that he was guilty.
posted on 7/3/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 7/3/15
The whole thing is a farce and has been blown out of proportion. Spitting is disgusting and should be punished.
However, it's ridiculous that spitting gets a 6 game ban, yet slapping someone round the face or a potential leg breaker should get a 3 game ban. Half the punishment! Shocking FA yet again.
And any suggestion that Cisse is some kind of Saint for admitting it, is BS. He made a pretty bad tackle, then tried to kick Evans, then spat at him. Should be a 10 game ban given the crazy FA, pull a number out of a hat, rules.
posted on 7/3/15
And still people insist Evans 'spat on the floor'...
Are you nuts? He spat downwards towards where Cisse was, right in front of him. For him to miss Cisse and hit the floor he'd have had to tilt his head left or right and spit to the side of Cisse, as opposed to, ya know, what he clearly did in every video clip of the incident available: looked directly at Cisse and spat in his direction.
Genuinely baffled as to how anyone is seeing anything different. Time to take off the United-tinted specs guys.
That said, it's a very harsh ban for both players
Page 1 of 2