Harry Kane only started playing in November didn't he? Hazard should get both awards
Honestly I think if you're entered into one you should be excluded from the other. If you're young but can hold your own in the category above then you get bumped up.
That way being nominated for POTY > winning YPOTY.
Kane will definitely win YPOTY.
Hazard should definitely win POTY. Whether he does remains to be seen. This isn't an award that Chelsea players get awarded much at all.
comment by TCW (U6489)
posted 1 minute ago
Honestly I think if you're entered into one you should be excluded from the other. If you're young but can hold your own in the category above then you get bumped up.
That way being nominated for POTY > winning YPOTY.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This!
He should definitely win POTY. Not even a debate IMO.
Give Kane YPOTY.
comment by TCW (U6489)
posted 7 minutes ago
Honestly I think if you're entered into one you should be excluded from the other. If you're young but can hold your own in the category above then you get bumped up.
That way being nominated for POTY > winning YPOTY.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The only issue is that if a young player gets nominated for player of the year, and doesn't win it, he ends up with neither awards, which isn't particularly fair.
Reducing the age makes it simpler in my opinion.
It doesn't matter in that case as the prestige of competing with the big boys outstrips what would become somewhat of a second tier award. As it should be.
I think you should be abled to be nominated for both categories but if you win the main one your votes for the young one should become void.
The Droog has spoken , I concur !
Maybe instead of YPOTY have a breakout season award. Or just lower the age to 21....
He should win the actual POTY award, but not the Young player award. I think you should only be allowed to win that award once, and after that you can't be eligible for it.
off course it is possible, but didn't Hazard get YPOTY last year ?
He definitely should get the PFA this year
They should have a Most Improved Player award.
I think Charlie Austin and he should have been nominated for the player of the year at least.He has been as good as Kane this season and he has been playing from the start of this season.
Anyway best player this season overall should be Aguero and then Hazard!
I think Giroud should win MIPOTY.
What confuses me is how Coutinho is even there. He's a great player, but there has been many players this season who have played far better - Austin, Matic, Courtios, Rooney, Fabregas, Erikson!
Coutinho's performances have probably been on par with someone like Fellaini. Brilliant on their day, but not consistently great throughout the season.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Joaquín are you serious?You think that Courtois has been as good as Coutinho?No.I think that Courtois has been poor this season at many times and has made more mistakes this season.Also I agree that Coutinho has been not as good but some of his goals this season were world class.I agree about other players you mentioned.
comment by Murder on Zidanes floor, Butt you better not G... (U7958)
posted 2 minutes ago
How can you be the best player in the league but not the best young player (if nominated)?
If Hazard wins POTY and not YPOTY the ill be very confused
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think it will be strange because players have done it in the past, for example Bale. I think if Hazard doesn't win it will show some British bias.
comment by tgi fry ★ (U9236)
posted 17 minutes ago
They should have a Most Improved Player award.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Otherwise known as the "You Used to be Shlt" Award
comment by ZahraIhsanphile (U20361)
posted 3 seconds ago
Joaquín are you serious?You think that Courtois has been as good as Coutinho?No.I think that Courtois has been poor this season at many times and has made more mistakes this season.Also I agree that Coutinho has been not as good but some of his goals this season were world class.I agree about other players you mentioned.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think Courtios has had a reasonably good season. He's been at fault for goals, but he's also made plenty of great saves at vital moments. The QPR game this weekend was evidence of this.
As for Coutinho. Well I love watching him playing, I don't think his season has been particularly amazing thats all. I don't like rating players through statistics but 4 goals and 4 assists is incredibly low. On top of that he's given a lot of mixed performances, especially early in the year, when he was playing terribly. I'm excited by the prospect of the player, and I think he has the potential to be great one day, but this season hasn't showcased all his best. He's a candidate for young player of the year though
I do think that if Chelsea make a move for any current Liverpool player we should sign Coutinho instead of overrated Sterling.
I think Hazard should get POTY and De Gea YPOTY. Terry OPOTY and Courtois Goalie of The Year
comment by ZahraIhsanphile (U20361)
posted 20 hours, 49 minutes ago
Joaquín are you serious?You think that Courtois has been as good as Coutinho?No.I think that Courtois has been poor this season at many times and has made more mistakes this season.Also I agree that Coutinho has been not as good but some of his goals this season were world class.I agree about other players you mentioned.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
what are you talking about angelina? Cortious has been fantastic this year for a debut season.
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Should Hazard win both
Page 1 of 1
posted on 17/4/15
Harry Kane only started playing in November didn't he? Hazard should get both awards
posted on 17/4/15
Honestly I think if you're entered into one you should be excluded from the other. If you're young but can hold your own in the category above then you get bumped up.
That way being nominated for POTY > winning YPOTY.
posted on 17/4/15
Kane will definitely win YPOTY.
Hazard should definitely win POTY. Whether he does remains to be seen. This isn't an award that Chelsea players get awarded much at all.
posted on 17/4/15
comment by TCW (U6489)
posted 1 minute ago
Honestly I think if you're entered into one you should be excluded from the other. If you're young but can hold your own in the category above then you get bumped up.
That way being nominated for POTY > winning YPOTY.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This!
posted on 17/4/15
He should definitely win POTY. Not even a debate IMO.
Give Kane YPOTY.
posted on 17/4/15
comment by TCW (U6489)
posted 7 minutes ago
Honestly I think if you're entered into one you should be excluded from the other. If you're young but can hold your own in the category above then you get bumped up.
That way being nominated for POTY > winning YPOTY.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The only issue is that if a young player gets nominated for player of the year, and doesn't win it, he ends up with neither awards, which isn't particularly fair.
Reducing the age makes it simpler in my opinion.
posted on 17/4/15
It doesn't matter in that case as the prestige of competing with the big boys outstrips what would become somewhat of a second tier award. As it should be.
posted on 17/4/15
I think you should be abled to be nominated for both categories but if you win the main one your votes for the young one should become void.
posted on 17/4/15
The Droog has spoken , I concur !
posted on 17/4/15
Maybe instead of YPOTY have a breakout season award. Or just lower the age to 21....
posted on 17/4/15
He should win the actual POTY award, but not the Young player award. I think you should only be allowed to win that award once, and after that you can't be eligible for it.
posted on 17/4/15
off course it is possible, but didn't Hazard get YPOTY last year ?
He definitely should get the PFA this year
posted on 17/4/15
They should have a Most Improved Player award.
posted on 17/4/15
I think Charlie Austin and he should have been nominated for the player of the year at least.He has been as good as Kane this season and he has been playing from the start of this season.
Anyway best player this season overall should be Aguero and then Hazard!
posted on 17/4/15
I think Giroud should win MIPOTY.
posted on 17/4/15
What confuses me is how Coutinho is even there. He's a great player, but there has been many players this season who have played far better - Austin, Matic, Courtios, Rooney, Fabregas, Erikson!
Coutinho's performances have probably been on par with someone like Fellaini. Brilliant on their day, but not consistently great throughout the season.
posted on 17/4/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 17/4/15
Joaquín are you serious?You think that Courtois has been as good as Coutinho?No.I think that Courtois has been poor this season at many times and has made more mistakes this season.Also I agree that Coutinho has been not as good but some of his goals this season were world class.I agree about other players you mentioned.
posted on 17/4/15
comment by Murder on Zidanes floor, Butt you better not G... (U7958)
posted 2 minutes ago
How can you be the best player in the league but not the best young player (if nominated)?
If Hazard wins POTY and not YPOTY the ill be very confused
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think it will be strange because players have done it in the past, for example Bale. I think if Hazard doesn't win it will show some British bias.
posted on 17/4/15
comment by tgi fry ★ (U9236)
posted 17 minutes ago
They should have a Most Improved Player award.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Otherwise known as the "You Used to be Shlt" Award
posted on 17/4/15
comment by ZahraIhsanphile (U20361)
posted 3 seconds ago
Joaquín are you serious?You think that Courtois has been as good as Coutinho?No.I think that Courtois has been poor this season at many times and has made more mistakes this season.Also I agree that Coutinho has been not as good but some of his goals this season were world class.I agree about other players you mentioned.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think Courtios has had a reasonably good season. He's been at fault for goals, but he's also made plenty of great saves at vital moments. The QPR game this weekend was evidence of this.
As for Coutinho. Well I love watching him playing, I don't think his season has been particularly amazing thats all. I don't like rating players through statistics but 4 goals and 4 assists is incredibly low. On top of that he's given a lot of mixed performances, especially early in the year, when he was playing terribly. I'm excited by the prospect of the player, and I think he has the potential to be great one day, but this season hasn't showcased all his best. He's a candidate for young player of the year though
posted on 17/4/15
I do think that if Chelsea make a move for any current Liverpool player we should sign Coutinho instead of overrated Sterling.
posted on 17/4/15
I think Hazard should get POTY and De Gea YPOTY. Terry OPOTY and Courtois Goalie of The Year
posted on 18/4/15
comment by ZahraIhsanphile (U20361)
posted 20 hours, 49 minutes ago
Joaquín are you serious?You think that Courtois has been as good as Coutinho?No.I think that Courtois has been poor this season at many times and has made more mistakes this season.Also I agree that Coutinho has been not as good but some of his goals this season were world class.I agree about other players you mentioned.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
what are you talking about angelina? Cortious has been fantastic this year for a debut season.
Page 1 of 1