or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 2956 comments are related to an article called:

LSTD - Portsmouth (Rooney)

Page 46 of 119

posted on 22/1/17

No worries. And you having a laugh? Madrid fans booing means absolutely nothing. They've booed him plenty before. They booed Zidane as well. Booed Modric, Bale, pretty much everyone!

Felipe Anderson + Vidal + Giroud
for
D.Costa + Khedira + Morata

Enq

posted on 22/1/17

Ronaldo's scored a few in open play since early November... But I think its simply silly if you're trying to play down his ability

That weakens my first team far too much. Would be losing two world class players for one, and would much rather have world class outfield players than a gk.

posted on 22/1/17

comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 21 hours, 59 minutes ago
Alves, Morata, Barkley, Lingard
For
Cancelo. Icardi, Gylfi, Redmond

Enq
----------------------------------------------------------------------
?

posted on 22/1/17

Not losing Icardi for Perisic no

posted on 23/1/17

He's scored at least a few, sure there's a free kick or two you can add to that as well but sure you can check if you really wanted. He's still the best player in the world with Messi.

No worries I definitely wouldn't do anything like that, would be crazy to lose him in a deal like that.

posted on 24/1/17

I already made you an offer

If Khedira was Fernandinho in that enquiry

posted on 24/1/17

No ta

posted on 24/1/17

I had a look and thinking about it i don't see that being enough for me to lose Ronnie. He's my striker backup as well.

Ronaldo + Handanovic + Can + Giroud + Jesé
For
Costa + Neuer + Morata + Fernandinho + Martial/Dembele

Enq

Without asking for any of your big players bar Neuer that's possibly best I could do. Would only see you lose two starters for Ronnie

Otherwise I'd be after your big players in a deal

posted on 24/1/17

I see it as an improvement to my goalkeeper and one mammoth loss on the wing. Only xi players that matter end of the day. And goalkeeper is position I care least about.

And you don't have any players I'd start other than Neuer and Carvajal.

It's silly losing Ronaldo for backup losses. So if I was to, would have to be a good backup improvement.

In any case Girouds goal record is far better than Moratas. He's also in far better form. Can is quality youngster, and Handanovic a quality keeper all the same.

posted on 24/1/17

You asked for him.....

I gave 3 first team improvements, including Benzema without a replacement to get him. I don't see you offering Lewandowski and Costa for him without a striker replacement. So I guess you're calling me brain dead. But if you ask me I'd be brain dead to lose him for a goalkeeper improvement to my xi. When you write tactics, you only write about xi players.

He's not in his prime, but still going to be between him and Messi as to who is the best in the world for the next couple years.

I already have a squad I'm happy with anyway, just looking to mix it up as I'm bored. I've always given away my best backup to improve my xi, why I've gone from having the worst side in the league to one of the best. But I guess I'm brain dead....

posted on 24/1/17

Jury isn't out on James. Proved more than Doug Costa has if you look at. Benz and Barzagli are two of the best in the world in their positions.

I don't see what you think you could've offered me to get him then to be honest.

I have young players that will make their mark as well, but I don't use them in tactics just now....

posted on 24/1/17

Talking down about Ronaldo is just mental He'll be one of the best in the world for a few years yet. And going on his physique and ability, touch, vision etc will carry on at least as well as Zlatan.

No worries, I've obviously focused on my first team. But Rico is one of the best young keepers in the world. Anderson has been one of the best players in Italy this season. Correa has the ability to be one of the best in the world, ahead of Icardi and Argies, rated as much as Dybala there. Would have them 3 alongside your best youngsters and the ones you mentioned.

posted on 24/1/17

for Argies even

posted on 24/1/17

Except they obviously are.

Anderson has been one of the best players in Italy but not ready for first team? Rico has been nothing short of top class for Sevilla who are having a great season. Correa having a more productive season than Morata. And I'd rather have Kurzawa than Guerreiro anyway.

I don't get why you asked for Ronaldo only to have a go at other folks, mine and others without negotiating or making an offer.

Wasn't long ago you were saying Payet was rubbish, then he was as good as Silva but now he's behind Martial/Dembele apparently... Also I didn't laugh enough at your nonsense about Ronaldo lol.

posted on 24/1/17

a go at other folks players*

posted on 24/1/17

kdb 'may' leave if lewa comes this way somehow

comment by Welshy (U1348)

posted on 24/1/17

Oliver Torres + Leon Bailey
For
Ousmane Dembele

posted on 24/1/17

I get defensive because you put down my players when ever we negotiate. Like with Payet, Silva and now Ronnie.... Except there was no negotiating just you putting down others players.

I'm not always right obviously. Happy to admit i get some wrong. Get far more right than wrong though, why my teams improved.

posted on 24/1/17

You compared the players saying 4 big losses, I only responded to that... and bigged up Ronnie.

And then obviously I didn't like my offer being called brain dead The offer only benefited one of our xis.

You wont get anyone else weaken their xi and lose their best player for a squad improvement.

posted on 24/1/17

You say that. I say you improved your xi. And that it wouldn't make much difference at all to your squad.

You weaken backup on the wing. Where you would still have had Coman, Payet, Martial/Dembele, Guedes to choose from. In other words no you'd still be loaded on the wings.

At cm you were weaker. But Can still a quality young midfielder that was being praised until just over a month ago. Still have Rabiot and Carrick there anyway, so not like he's your only backup cm.

Up front Morata has never scored that many goals, Giroud will always score more. Not much difference there. I like that Morata's style would be direct replacement for Costa. Although could've negotiated this part but obv not to happen.

So overall I think you're brain dead to not snap my hand off.

posted on 24/1/17

No worries, no hard feelings, we just obviously look at things differently As that's the kind of deal I'd be jumping all over with your squad and have done plenty of.

Like giving away 3 even bigger losses to get an out of form Hazard. Giving Higuain for Origi. Cazorla for Cancelo, and Alex Sandro for Coentrao. As well as James for Hazard.

And I only say that about Morata as he's never scored more than 8 league goals in a season.

posted on 24/1/17

alright the week is up

rudiger + hojbjerg
for
tah + nkoudou

comment by Welshy (U1348)

posted on 25/1/17

Guerreiro + Dembele
For
Süle + Forsberg

Enq!

comment by Welshy (U1348)

posted on 25/1/17

Thought I may have tempted you!

Nothing between Tah and Süle, but will stick with Süle

posted on 25/1/17

Oxford, Bender, Andre Silva for Morata

Page 46 of 119

Sign in if you want to comment