or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 16 comments are related to an article called:

Who's actually good enough ??

Page 1 of 1

comment by Dewalts (U2131)

posted on 2/9/11

No one we are all dooooommmeeeeeeeeed!!!!!!

blah blah blah blah everythings shiote,
blah blah blah blah hate megson,
blah blah blah blah why didn't we sign mellor,
blah blah blahdy bloody blah!!!

posted on 2/9/11

Simple.

Everyone apart from JOC & Uchechi.

posted on 2/9/11

Ha Ha Monster - i think there are a few more we can add to that list !

Reynolds
Reda
Morrison
Sedge
O'Grady

posted on 2/9/11

Yes, it's about time Uchechi found his shooting boots! His goal average is a disgrace!

posted on 2/9/11

I'd go with that I can see Oochie getting released early to be fair! Pity JOC cant follow him

posted on 2/9/11

But I WOULD consider COG to be good enough to be fair, he'll be effective for us once fit again

posted on 2/9/11

JoC

Semi looks good when fit but his injury record is appalling.

JJ is now too injury prone.

Jury is out on Reynolds although he's looked far better this season.

I think Reda (wait for it) has tonnes of potential if only he can cut out the silly mistakes. He's still very young for a cb.

Everyone else is more than good enough but we really need another decent winger.

posted on 2/9/11

I agree with that Chup.

I don't know what the big issue is with Reda. He does, at times, look like a disaster waiting to happen & sure he makes mistakes like everyone but all the ingredients are there for him to be a very good centre half, Championship standard easily. I rate him as a defender higher than Rob Jones but obviously Jones has the leadership qualities.

posted on 2/9/11

@Mellors_Moobs How can you say O'Grady isn't good enough when he has played around 20 minutes?

posted on 2/9/11

tbf, 20 minutes is quite generous where Wednesday fans are concerned!

posted on 2/9/11

He's a Jeffers in waiting....

posted on 2/9/11

Sedge also has his good days! Just needs to find a bit of consistency!

comment by Dewalts (U2131)

posted on 2/9/11

I bet O'Grady gutted his ears are going to grow so big!

posted on 2/9/11

Unfortunately they all have their moments at this level and the days of bringing in a 'Terry Curran' from the top flight are over, the wages are too stupid. In all seriousness I think JOC is the only one who is not good enough. But I have a strange feeling that if we got rid of him, we'd be relegated.

posted on 2/9/11

Whats wrong with O Grady is that he isn't MM's love interest Neil Mellor.

posted on 2/9/11

Somedays I think the vast majority are good enough then other days they wouldnt get a game for Barnsley Park Avenue, but to be fair if they moved to other clubs they would probably do ok ie Potter and soon to be Coke and Beevers

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment