or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 71 comments are related to an article called:

Koscielny On Par With Vidic If Not Close

Page 3 of 3

posted on 4/9/11

I think Phil Jones right now is better than Tony Adams in his peak and in two season Phil Jones will develop into a better player than Bergkamp. Type in 'Phil Jones' on YouTube and you will also see the light and realise this. Also Chris Smalling is better than Patrick Viera and Thierry Henry. This is true

posted on 4/9/11

It takes more than a 3 minute video to be convinced of class.

Koscielny isn't bad, but he has a long way to go before he can claim the ability, experience or the consistency of Nemanja Vidic.

posted on 4/9/11

Grab somebody seksy tell them hey

posted on 4/9/11

United have four central defenders better than Koscielny, we have been missing three of our first choice back four all season and have hardly noticed. Anyone who has see De Gea knows he is a natural tallent, he needs bulking up and intensive coaching but he will be class.

posted on 4/9/11

posted on 4/9/11

laurent koscielny isn't even 'on a par' with titus bramble.

posted on 4/9/11

This Koscielny thing really needs to stop now

Its giving most normal Arsenal members a bad name

posted on 4/9/11

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DSBAG0_MzFU


Yep he oozes class in this video

posted on 4/9/11

Dear me, it's getting worse.

posted on 4/9/11

I don't know what this thing is with Koscielny, he is honestly no better than Squillaci who gets a lot of stick. Djourou, Vermaelen and now Mertesacker are all better.

comment by Ocelots (U3893)

posted on 4/9/11

Koscielny is good and has the potential to be fantastic, but I'd be careful about comparing him to the likes of Vidic, if only because it invites all the manc WUMs onto our board.

posted on 4/9/11

Can someone tell me why Vidic is the one hailed as the archetype for top centre halves?

His "skill" is a mixture of cynical fouls and handballs which naturally goes unpunished by refs and is glossed over and even praised by pundits

Makes me mad that players like Koscielny and Luiz are lambasted as error prone and accidents waiting to happen for doing what gets Vidic hailed as the bets in the world

posted on 4/9/11

looking at some of the comments in this thread i really don't think that football is for some of these people.

comment by Sanj (U1142)

posted on 4/9/11

Vidic is far better. End of article.

posted on 4/9/11

Koscielny is good and has the potential to be fantastic, but I'd be careful about comparing him to the likes of Vidic, if only because it invites all the manc WUMs onto our board

Why would we bother, plenty of Arsenal fans on our board, mainly the muppets though.

posted on 4/9/11

WUM

posted on 4/9/11

Darko**Wenger Is My Long Lost Father**And Wenger's Father Is My Son Eboue** (U10337)

Why is there no footage of him heading a ball?

posted on 4/9/11

Ledley King

posted on 5/9/11

Mata(U3630)
I think your description of Vidic is a very acurate description...











of Terry

posted on 5/9/11

It's clear that the fans of Arsenal Football Club believe they're players are better than everyone elses.

I've got a couple of question though;

1) If your players are the best in the world as you claim, why have you failed in every single competition you've been involved in, in the last 6 years? Why no league titles in 7 years?

2) If your players are so great and fail time and time again. What does that say about your manager?

Answers please

posted on 29/11/11

http://www.ja606.co.uk/articles/viewArticle/34681

Page 3 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment