Can you answer the Bergwijn one please

Judging by how much playing time Semedo played, he only played about 500 minutes less than Sergi Roberto at RB. Now judging by whoscored Semedo made 26 starts as a RB compared to Roberto who made 24. I think he is a first teamer for Barca atm with him and Roberto fighting for that RB spot. If he were to leave he'd need first choice and CL. I think it depends on if the other teams like Pool and Spurs are interested in him or not for it to be an auction or not tbh.

*500 minutes less than Sergi Roberto.

I don’t know on Bergwijn.

I can only think of three swaps Kroos/Thiago, Griezzman/Bale, Casemiro/Isco, and there all quite comparable and can see why first is more valuable. With Bergwijn linked with move not so easy?

Think Brum would need to be higher up

I am still in Europe so I don't think I should be higher up imo.

Soler also being linked with Spurs aswell and he can play on the wings aswell. Think it's a fair deal imo.

In that case Arsenal interested as well as City

I don't mind Arsenal and City being interested. Your have to offer a good player in exchange tho for Bergwijn that falls in the category that rof has stated.

Malcom for Arsenal or Under/Ziyech for City would be needed.

I’ll offer Lemar from City then

This is why swaps aren’t good

None of those are easily comparable

I mean Ziyech is but still

Realistically PSV couldn’t sign any of Malcom/Lemar offer wages etc. Why swaps only really happened with the very best

I guess Kluivert would be the most realistic one then

couldn't imagine they could afford Kluivert's wages either

seem Bruno Fernandes is gonna leave for £70m ish

Man City

Probably couldn’t no. Why swaps should continue to not be ok. Too many arguments. With the very top players it’s at least quite clear

Bruno should be an auction he’s been asked for loads in last year

He would most likely need CL so only Chelsea would be able to go for him. Rof?

What rof said.

Don’t think Bruno should be limited to CL.

And don’t get why only Chelsea then?

That was a typo from me about Chelsea. I don't mind him being open to teams outside CL.

So including the teams that get relegated we potentially have about 20 auctions

that was a long typo Nadz lol

comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 4 minutes ago
So including the teams that get relegated we potentially have about 20 auctions
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Can only be a good thing

My thoughts,

Semedo - on the basis Rafinha was an auction then he probably should be, unless with the new changes you want be more relaxed on auctions and only restrict them to the top tier players. I don't really mind either way.

Bruno Fernandes - Should be an auction as loads have enquired.

Player swaps - I think they're fine however I don't think they should be available for youngsters, particularly under 21's. The swaps that have taken place were all experienced players who had reached their peak and were therefore easy to evaluate whether it was a fair swap. With youngsters its almost impossible to tell whether they're going to go on to be a worldie or just flavour of the month, therefore its hard to judge whether its ultimately a fair swap. Also don't agree on swapping older players for youngsters (Hazard for Bergwijn for instance)

TAB Agree with that.

I don’t think a lot of auctions is a bad thing. Especially with less activity and smaller league. Only issue is the timing, and whether there is any way to get new managers in/back before.