Mbop just got sold for 150 million, but I did not read about any interest for Rashy, hence, Mbop is the better player.

Look at Falcao record with Monaco and then with Man Utd and Chelsea and then compare it to Mbappe last season together. Rashford was miles better for us under LVG then Falcao yet Falcao scores for fun with Monaco.

Which Neville said this?

Hans

Which other players in the pl would you say are at the same level as these two?

Iheanacho

I think Rashford would score 40 in the French league as it is like league 1 standard Get it Ligue 1.

comment by Blue_mooning (U12093)
posted 1 minute ago
Which other players in the pl would you say are at the same level as these two?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Easy.

Sanchez
De bruyne
Silva
Silva
Hazard
Aguero
Continho

Yes Mbappe and rashford are a lot younger than the list above and have huge potential, but neither is CURRENTLY any better than the list above.

The difference in my opinion is one is just a more clinical goalscorer in a free flowing football team. However, even that is flawed considering the leagues.

Mbappe would do well for PSG, because let's be honest, PSG will just outscore teams. Already averaged 3.5 goals per game this season. Mbappe will play a big part in that if he's given first choice opportunities.

Mbappe > Jesus > Rashford

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

I would say currently rashford is below the players on that list, some by quite alot.
Wouldnt compare him to bernardo because I haven't seen enough and thats why i wont compare him to mbappe.
Obviously people have got excited by mbappe cl record, which is fair enough. But i think mario outscored him in the league.

Comment deleted by Article Creator

In the 18-19 category Rashford, Mbappe and Dembele are the best and there’s really not much between them

Wtf Got _Bobb ?

comment by Conte'nt (U20893)
posted 1 minute ago
Wtf Got _Bobb ?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Your comment was as useless as your clubs attempts to buy Lukaku this summer

There's a nice Youtube video comparison between the two.

I'm just happy we have Rashford.

But the bigger question is, who is the faster player?

I've only seen mbappe 3 times... But he looked a complete beast, could be very, very good....

Love rashy though... Wouldn't swap him for any player in the world. To see an academy player that could go on to be top class is one of the pinnacles of being a football fan.

I was agreeing with you m8

I've hardly seen Mbappe. I'll be honest and say I'm not totally convinced with Rashford as a future great. Then again I wasn't overly keen on Ronaldo when he first turned up.

Rashford is clearly the better player. Mbappe plays in a rubbish league.

I'd rather have a Rashford and a Martial over a Mbappe.

comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - 2017 joy squids (U2958)
posted 2 minutes ago
I've only seen mbappe 3 times... But he looked a complete beast, could be very, very good....

Love rashy though... Wouldn't swap him for any player in the world. To see an academy player that could go on to be top class is one of the pinnacles of being a football fan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

This says it all really and if it was a reasonable crowd here should end this discussion... how reasonable we though? We will see.

Mbappe makes the Martial fee look like a bargain

Mbappe probably has the edge but not enough in it to rhibk about swapping them