comment by Redastomatoes- Feels very Moyesian...cleverson forever!If he is good enough he is ready! (U12026)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - 2017 joy squids (U2958)
posted 2 minutes ago
I've only seen mbappe 3 times... But he looked a complete beast, could be very, very good....
Love rashy though... Wouldn't swap him for any player in the world. To see an academy player that could go on to be top class is one of the pinnacles of being a football fan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This says it all really and if it was a reasonable crowd here should end this discussion... how reasonable we though? We will see.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
With Rashford being a local lad and through the academy it does make it much more sweeter when he is showing so much potential. What makes it even more sweet is he's come through our club that isn't shy to spend big bucks on 'ready made quality' players. Even though we've had a great tradition of giving youth a chance.
I wouldn't swap them
Mbappe's performances in last seasons CL are what got him his big money move. 6 goals he scored.
Be interesting to see how rashford gets on in this seasons competition
Another robb wum special. I'll bite, from what I've seen mbappe can do everything rashford can better, especially finishing. That's taking nothing away from rashford. Neville is a Man Utd legend who is paid by sky to promote their product, of course he'd say that.
Who's better? Who cares. I'm glad we have Marcus for many reasons, but most of all, he's one of ours, and as long as we keep him happy and keep him in matches, he'll probably have a great career here.Foreign players can come and go, but a home-grown lad is priceless for me.
Mbappe does look very good. He's looked to be pretty clinical too, from what I've seen. But there's the intangible of Rashford being homegrown, playing for the team he supports, and the level of progression he's shown over the last couple of years. There's no telling how high his ceiling is
Those are good arguments for not wanting to swap, which I agree with, but I don't see many good arguments for why Rashford is a better footballer.
I think going forward Rashford will have bigger challenges in achieving his potential as Lukaku is likely to be with us for a long time, and I think Rashford looks like his best position in the future will be up front.
Mbappe shouldn't have many problems here with Neymar putting Cavani on the transfer market.
I doubt if the prospect of a swap would even enter the thoughts of utd fans
comment by Roy's Keen (U11635)
posted 4 minutes ago
I doubt if the prospect of a swap would even enter the thoughts of utd fans
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I doubt either clubs would ever even consider it.
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 minute ago
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they would.
Not yet they wouldn't, I think they might be by the end of this season depending on how he does.
comment by Got Robb 🎬⚽️⭐️ (U21234)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 minute ago
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they would.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think he has alot to do to prove he is a 100 million player. He's still quite raw
If Rashford wasn't a Man United player he'd be rated alongside Mbappe.
Look at the teams Rashford has scored against. City, Arsenal, Chelsea. Scored in the Champions League. Scored in the Europa League. Double digit goal scoring season at 18.
If some kid in Germany or Spain was doing what Rashford does week in week out then fans of every clubs in England would be hoping their club would sign him.
Interesting question, personality wouldn't swap him because nothing beats seeing a local lad looking totally at home playing along side the most expensive United team ever.
Little bit of split opinion on here so I think it's worth asking if the PSG fans were asked the same question in reverse, they would laugh at the suggestion.
There wouldn't be a place for him in their teams so it's highly unlikely.
Anyone who scores twice against Burton Albion should automatically receive the Balon D'Or.
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by Got Robb 🎬⚽️⭐️ (U21234)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 minute ago
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they would.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think he has alot to do to prove he is a 100 million player. He's still quite raw
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No more raw than Dembele. More accomplished actually.
No more raw than Dembele. More accomplished actually.
--
Not sure on that, both are raw but technically dembele is better of what I've seen.
comment by Baz tardo (U19119)
posted 2 minutes ago
No more raw than Dembele. More accomplished actually.
--
Not sure on that, both are raw but technically dembele is better of what I've seen.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Gonna have to disagree. Dembele is so hot and cold.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
I don't think he's miles ahead in terms of movement, Rashford's is very good, but agreed on the rest.
Hopefully we get a coach that excels in developing an attackers game in the future as that could really help Rashford in the future.
Possibly Pochettino at some stage.
comment by Zlatan The King Ibrahimovic (U10026)
posted 36 minutes ago
I don't think he's miles ahead in terms of movement, Rashford's is very good, but agreed on the rest.
Hopefully we get a coach that excels in developing an attackers game in the future as that could really help Rashford in the future.
Possibly Pochettino at some stage.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's gotta prove he's a winner first before he joins a big club
comment by Got Robb 🎬⚽️⭐️ (U21234)
posted 18 minutes ago
comment by Zlatan The King Ibrahimovic (U10026)
posted 36 minutes ago
I don't think he's miles ahead in terms of movement, Rashford's is very good, but agreed on the rest.
Hopefully we get a coach that excels in developing an attackers game in the future as that could really help Rashford in the future.
Possibly Pochettino at some stage.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's gotta prove he's a winner first before he joins a big club
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This. Plus I'm hopeful of a long Jose stay
I think Rashford has far more potential then Mbappe, Some of the stuff Rashford can do reminds me of Ronaldo.
Ive heard it all now Rashford better than Mbappe? This is like when you lot tried to tell the world Januzaj was better than Hazard
Sign in if you want to comment
Rashford vs Mbappe
Page 3 of 5
posted on 21/9/17
comment by Redastomatoes- Feels very Moyesian...cleverson forever!If he is good enough he is ready! (U12026)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - 2017 joy squids (U2958)
posted 2 minutes ago
I've only seen mbappe 3 times... But he looked a complete beast, could be very, very good....
Love rashy though... Wouldn't swap him for any player in the world. To see an academy player that could go on to be top class is one of the pinnacles of being a football fan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This says it all really and if it was a reasonable crowd here should end this discussion... how reasonable we though? We will see.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
With Rashford being a local lad and through the academy it does make it much more sweeter when he is showing so much potential. What makes it even more sweet is he's come through our club that isn't shy to spend big bucks on 'ready made quality' players. Even though we've had a great tradition of giving youth a chance.
posted on 21/9/17
I wouldn't swap them
Mbappe's performances in last seasons CL are what got him his big money move. 6 goals he scored.
Be interesting to see how rashford gets on in this seasons competition
posted on 21/9/17
Another robb wum special. I'll bite, from what I've seen mbappe can do everything rashford can better, especially finishing. That's taking nothing away from rashford. Neville is a Man Utd legend who is paid by sky to promote their product, of course he'd say that.
posted on 21/9/17
Who's better? Who cares. I'm glad we have Marcus for many reasons, but most of all, he's one of ours, and as long as we keep him happy and keep him in matches, he'll probably have a great career here.Foreign players can come and go, but a home-grown lad is priceless for me.
posted on 21/9/17
Mbappe does look very good. He's looked to be pretty clinical too, from what I've seen. But there's the intangible of Rashford being homegrown, playing for the team he supports, and the level of progression he's shown over the last couple of years. There's no telling how high his ceiling is
posted on 21/9/17
Those are good arguments for not wanting to swap, which I agree with, but I don't see many good arguments for why Rashford is a better footballer.
I think going forward Rashford will have bigger challenges in achieving his potential as Lukaku is likely to be with us for a long time, and I think Rashford looks like his best position in the future will be up front.
Mbappe shouldn't have many problems here with Neymar putting Cavani on the transfer market.
posted on 21/9/17
I doubt if the prospect of a swap would even enter the thoughts of utd fans
posted on 21/9/17
comment by Roy's Keen (U11635)
posted 4 minutes ago
I doubt if the prospect of a swap would even enter the thoughts of utd fans
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I doubt either clubs would ever even consider it.
posted on 21/9/17
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
posted on 21/9/17
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 minute ago
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they would.
posted on 21/9/17
Not yet they wouldn't, I think they might be by the end of this season depending on how he does.
posted on 21/9/17
comment by Got Robb 🎬⚽️⭐️ (U21234)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 minute ago
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they would.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think he has alot to do to prove he is a 100 million player. He's still quite raw
posted on 21/9/17
If Rashford wasn't a Man United player he'd be rated alongside Mbappe.
Look at the teams Rashford has scored against. City, Arsenal, Chelsea. Scored in the Champions League. Scored in the Europa League. Double digit goal scoring season at 18.
If some kid in Germany or Spain was doing what Rashford does week in week out then fans of every clubs in England would be hoping their club would sign him.
posted on 21/9/17
Interesting question, personality wouldn't swap him because nothing beats seeing a local lad looking totally at home playing along side the most expensive United team ever.
Little bit of split opinion on here so I think it's worth asking if the PSG fans were asked the same question in reverse, they would laugh at the suggestion.
posted on 21/9/17
There wouldn't be a place for him in their teams so it's highly unlikely.
posted on 21/9/17
Anyone who scores twice against Burton Albion should automatically receive the Balon D'Or.
posted on 21/9/17
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by Got Robb 🎬⚽️⭐️ (U21234)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 minute ago
Mbappe is a better player imo and that's not taking anything away from Rashford.
Mbappe took the CL by storm last year.
If Rashford was made available for €100 million I'm not sure the likes of PSG and Barca would be interested.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they would.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think he has alot to do to prove he is a 100 million player. He's still quite raw
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No more raw than Dembele. More accomplished actually.
posted on 21/9/17
No more raw than Dembele. More accomplished actually.
--
Not sure on that, both are raw but technically dembele is better of what I've seen.
posted on 21/9/17
comment by Baz tardo (U19119)
posted 2 minutes ago
No more raw than Dembele. More accomplished actually.
--
Not sure on that, both are raw but technically dembele is better of what I've seen.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Gonna have to disagree. Dembele is so hot and cold.
posted on 21/9/17
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 21/9/17
I don't think he's miles ahead in terms of movement, Rashford's is very good, but agreed on the rest.
Hopefully we get a coach that excels in developing an attackers game in the future as that could really help Rashford in the future.
Possibly Pochettino at some stage.
posted on 21/9/17
comment by Zlatan The King Ibrahimovic (U10026)
posted 36 minutes ago
I don't think he's miles ahead in terms of movement, Rashford's is very good, but agreed on the rest.
Hopefully we get a coach that excels in developing an attackers game in the future as that could really help Rashford in the future.
Possibly Pochettino at some stage.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's gotta prove he's a winner first before he joins a big club
posted on 21/9/17
comment by Got Robb 🎬⚽️⭐️ (U21234)
posted 18 minutes ago
comment by Zlatan The King Ibrahimovic (U10026)
posted 36 minutes ago
I don't think he's miles ahead in terms of movement, Rashford's is very good, but agreed on the rest.
Hopefully we get a coach that excels in developing an attackers game in the future as that could really help Rashford in the future.
Possibly Pochettino at some stage.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's gotta prove he's a winner first before he joins a big club
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This. Plus I'm hopeful of a long Jose stay
posted on 21/9/17
I think Rashford has far more potential then Mbappe, Some of the stuff Rashford can do reminds me of Ronaldo.
posted on 21/9/17
Ive heard it all now Rashford better than Mbappe? This is like when you lot tried to tell the world Januzaj was better than Hazard
Page 3 of 5