Cech-7
Bosingwa-7
Ivan-7
Terry-7
Cole-5
Ram-7
Raul-6
Lamps-5
Studge-6
Torres-7(his miss ruined it)
Mata-7
Lukaku-6
Anelka-7
Mikel-6
Mata+Torres agree with that.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 5.5
Terry - 7
Ivanovic - 6
Cole - 6
Miereles - 6
Ramires - 7.5
Lampard - 4
Sturridge - 5
Torres - 6
Mata - 7
Haha tbk, your ratings never cease to amaze me
Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 6.5
Terry - 6.5
Ivanovic - 6.5
Cole - 5.5
Miereles - 6
Ramires - 7
Lampard - 4
Sturridge - 5
Torres - 7.5
Mata - 7
De Gea - 6
Smalling - 7
Jones - 7
Evans - 7.5
Evra - 7.5
Anderson - 5.5
Fletcher - 5.5
Young - 5
Nani - 9
Rooney - 7.5
Hernandez - 3.5
TBK has a clear bias against Bos and Torres. The only way they would get a good rating from him is if they score a hattrick.
TBK
I agree with you about dropping Lampard
Nani and Rooney made the difference for Man Utd.
We played better without him in the second half
Actually Don Mata is right. Cole was worse than Bosingwa that game. Switch my ratings ruond for those two.
You put Torres on par with cole/bosingwa, ivanovic and meireles
Op, I think your ratings are pretty accurate. However, I would give Cole a 6, and reduce lukaku to a 5/6
Cech-6
Bosingwa-6
Ivan-6
Terry-6
Cole-5
Ram-7
Raul-8 M.o.M. Had Rooney in his back pocket
Lamps-6
Studge-5 Very dissapointing today
Torres-7
Mata-7
Lukaku-4
Anelka-6
Mikel-5
My ratings
Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 7
Ivanovic - 8
Terry - 7
Cole - 4.5 (Abysmal,Nani was killing him on the wings)
Meireles - 8
Ramires - 8 (Had a great game but missed a sitter)
Lampard - 5(Well just poor,definitely needs to take a backseat now,off the pace again)
Sturridge - 5.5 (Average,hitting shots wide and constantly losing the ball)
Mata - 8 (Brilliant performance from Mata again played better when he was behind Torres,Anelka and Lukaku as opposed to being on the left wing)
Torres - 8.5 (The confidence,pace,movement and goal were there today + could have got 2 assists)
Anelka - 7 (Good performance from the subs bench again,got an assist not bad)
Lukaku - 4(Could not get into the game)
Mikel - 3(awful)
Cech 7- no faults for the big man
Bosingwa 4- gave Young so much space
Terry 7- Strong typical JT performance
Ivanovic 6- Nervy at CB would much prefer him at RB
Cole 5- Nani too good for him, nasty tackle near the end.
Ramires 7.5- Set up attacks well, missed a sitter at 1-0
Meireles 7- Good performance but not a DM
Lampard 4- Too old, too slow especially for this counter attacking game
Mata 7- Smart touches and link up play, lazy defending for Nani's goal
Sturridge 5.5- Not his day against the experienced Evra, looked too predictable cutting in onto his left.
Torres 9 (Our man of the match)- Great runs, link up play, unselfish to set up Ramires, tidy finish, could of took a touch for the open goal, looking forward to seeing him against Swansea.
Anelka 7.5- Looks sharp as an inpact sub this season.
Lukaku 6- Longest appearance for him, couldn't get into the game, not a winger.
Mikel 6- Yawn, boring slow why not bring Romeu on?
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Player Ratings?
Page 1 of 1
posted on 18/9/11
Cech-7
Bosingwa-7
Ivan-7
Terry-7
Cole-5
Ram-7
Raul-6
Lamps-5
Studge-6
Torres-7(his miss ruined it)
Mata-7
Lukaku-6
Anelka-7
Mikel-6
posted on 18/9/11
Mata+Torres agree with that.
posted on 18/9/11
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 18/9/11
Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 5.5
Terry - 7
Ivanovic - 6
Cole - 6
Miereles - 6
Ramires - 7.5
Lampard - 4
Sturridge - 5
Torres - 6
Mata - 7
posted on 18/9/11
Haha tbk, your ratings never cease to amaze me
posted on 18/9/11
Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 6.5
Terry - 6.5
Ivanovic - 6.5
Cole - 5.5
Miereles - 6
Ramires - 7
Lampard - 4
Sturridge - 5
Torres - 7.5
Mata - 7
De Gea - 6
Smalling - 7
Jones - 7
Evans - 7.5
Evra - 7.5
Anderson - 5.5
Fletcher - 5.5
Young - 5
Nani - 9
Rooney - 7.5
Hernandez - 3.5
posted on 18/9/11
Linesmen 0 Dowd 0
posted on 18/9/11
TBK has a clear bias against Bos and Torres. The only way they would get a good rating from him is if they score a hattrick.
posted on 18/9/11
posted on 18/9/11
posted on 18/9/11
TBK
I agree with you about dropping Lampard
posted on 18/9/11
Nani and Rooney made the difference for Man Utd.
posted on 18/9/11
We played better without him in the second half
posted on 18/9/11
Actually Don Mata is right. Cole was worse than Bosingwa that game. Switch my ratings ruond for those two.
posted on 18/9/11
You put Torres on par with cole/bosingwa, ivanovic and meireles
posted on 18/9/11
Sorry
posted on 18/9/11
Op, I think your ratings are pretty accurate. However, I would give Cole a 6, and reduce lukaku to a 5/6
posted on 18/9/11
Cech-6
Bosingwa-6
Ivan-6
Terry-6
Cole-5
Ram-7
Raul-8 M.o.M. Had Rooney in his back pocket
Lamps-6
Studge-5 Very dissapointing today
Torres-7
Mata-7
Lukaku-4
Anelka-6
Mikel-5
posted on 19/9/11
My ratings
Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 7
Ivanovic - 8
Terry - 7
Cole - 4.5 (Abysmal,Nani was killing him on the wings)
Meireles - 8
Ramires - 8 (Had a great game but missed a sitter)
Lampard - 5(Well just poor,definitely needs to take a backseat now,off the pace again)
Sturridge - 5.5 (Average,hitting shots wide and constantly losing the ball)
Mata - 8 (Brilliant performance from Mata again played better when he was behind Torres,Anelka and Lukaku as opposed to being on the left wing)
Torres - 8.5 (The confidence,pace,movement and goal were there today + could have got 2 assists)
Anelka - 7 (Good performance from the subs bench again,got an assist not bad)
Lukaku - 4(Could not get into the game)
Mikel - 3(awful)
posted on 19/9/11
Cech 7- no faults for the big man
Bosingwa 4- gave Young so much space
Terry 7- Strong typical JT performance
Ivanovic 6- Nervy at CB would much prefer him at RB
Cole 5- Nani too good for him, nasty tackle near the end.
Ramires 7.5- Set up attacks well, missed a sitter at 1-0
Meireles 7- Good performance but not a DM
Lampard 4- Too old, too slow especially for this counter attacking game
Mata 7- Smart touches and link up play, lazy defending for Nani's goal
Sturridge 5.5- Not his day against the experienced Evra, looked too predictable cutting in onto his left.
Torres 9 (Our man of the match)- Great runs, link up play, unselfish to set up Ramires, tidy finish, could of took a touch for the open goal, looking forward to seeing him against Swansea.
Anelka 7.5- Looks sharp as an inpact sub this season.
Lukaku 6- Longest appearance for him, couldn't get into the game, not a winger.
Mikel 6- Yawn, boring slow why not bring Romeu on?
Page 1 of 1