or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 20 comments are related to an article called:

Player Ratings?

Page 1 of 1

posted on 18/9/11

Cech-7
Bosingwa-7
Ivan-7
Terry-7
Cole-5
Ram-7
Raul-6
Lamps-5
Studge-6
Torres-7(his miss ruined it)
Mata-7

Lukaku-6
Anelka-7
Mikel-6

comment by jomo™ (U8836)

posted on 18/9/11

Mata+Torres agree with that.

posted on 18/9/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/9/11

Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 5.5
Terry - 7
Ivanovic - 6
Cole - 6
Miereles - 6
Ramires - 7.5
Lampard - 4
Sturridge - 5
Torres - 6
Mata - 7

posted on 18/9/11

Haha tbk, your ratings never cease to amaze me

posted on 18/9/11

Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 6.5
Terry - 6.5
Ivanovic - 6.5
Cole - 5.5
Miereles - 6
Ramires - 7
Lampard - 4
Sturridge - 5
Torres - 7.5
Mata - 7


De Gea - 6
Smalling - 7
Jones - 7
Evans - 7.5
Evra - 7.5

Anderson - 5.5
Fletcher - 5.5
Young - 5
Nani - 9

Rooney - 7.5
Hernandez - 3.5

posted on 18/9/11

Linesmen 0 Dowd 0

comment by jomo™ (U8836)

posted on 18/9/11

TBK has a clear bias against Bos and Torres. The only way they would get a good rating from him is if they score a hattrick.

posted on 18/9/11

posted on 18/9/11

posted on 18/9/11

TBK

I agree with you about dropping Lampard

posted on 18/9/11

Nani and Rooney made the difference for Man Utd.

posted on 18/9/11

We played better without him in the second half

posted on 18/9/11

Actually Don Mata is right. Cole was worse than Bosingwa that game. Switch my ratings ruond for those two.

posted on 18/9/11

You put Torres on par with cole/bosingwa, ivanovic and meireles

posted on 18/9/11

Sorry

posted on 18/9/11

Op, I think your ratings are pretty accurate. However, I would give Cole a 6, and reduce lukaku to a 5/6

posted on 18/9/11

Cech-6
Bosingwa-6
Ivan-6
Terry-6
Cole-5
Ram-7
Raul-8 M.o.M. Had Rooney in his back pocket
Lamps-6
Studge-5 Very dissapointing today
Torres-7
Mata-7

Lukaku-4
Anelka-6
Mikel-5

posted on 19/9/11

My ratings

Cech - 6
Bosingwa - 7
Ivanovic - 8
Terry - 7
Cole - 4.5 (Abysmal,Nani was killing him on the wings)
Meireles - 8
Ramires - 8 (Had a great game but missed a sitter)
Lampard - 5(Well just poor,definitely needs to take a backseat now,off the pace again)
Sturridge - 5.5 (Average,hitting shots wide and constantly losing the ball)
Mata - 8 (Brilliant performance from Mata again played better when he was behind Torres,Anelka and Lukaku as opposed to being on the left wing)
Torres - 8.5 (The confidence,pace,movement and goal were there today + could have got 2 assists)

Anelka - 7 (Good performance from the subs bench again,got an assist not bad)
Lukaku - 4(Could not get into the game)
Mikel - 3(awful)

posted on 19/9/11

Cech 7- no faults for the big man
Bosingwa 4- gave Young so much space
Terry 7- Strong typical JT performance
Ivanovic 6- Nervy at CB would much prefer him at RB
Cole 5- Nani too good for him, nasty tackle near the end.
Ramires 7.5- Set up attacks well, missed a sitter at 1-0
Meireles 7- Good performance but not a DM
Lampard 4- Too old, too slow especially for this counter attacking game
Mata 7- Smart touches and link up play, lazy defending for Nani's goal
Sturridge 5.5- Not his day against the experienced Evra, looked too predictable cutting in onto his left.
Torres 9 (Our man of the match)- Great runs, link up play, unselfish to set up Ramires, tidy finish, could of took a touch for the open goal, looking forward to seeing him against Swansea.

Anelka 7.5- Looks sharp as an inpact sub this season.
Lukaku 6- Longest appearance for him, couldn't get into the game, not a winger.
Mikel 6- Yawn, boring slow why not bring Romeu on?

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment