For this season, Robertson may not be the big name but I'd say he's been better than Mendy and its a toss of the coin between him and Alonso. Alonso has more end product than them all so far so I'd give it to Alonso but I'd then have Robertson and last but not least, Mendy.
All my opinion.
Mendy had a bit of a nightmare against Wolves.
Alonso had a bit of a nightmare against Arsenal at times.
Alonso is not great defensively, but he is good. Very rarely do we concede goals from his side anymore (until the formation change which we are gettng use to).
It's hard to judge mendy yet anyways. How many PL games has he actually played?
Gotta say alonso for consistency over the last 2 years.
Well both have only played a handful of games at left back in the PL so Robertson wins by default
Not much difference between Robertson or Alonsos play tbh.
Roberton bombs forward like a winger a lot of the time, as does alonso.
LB/LWB both interchangeable.
Young had ‘the best player in the league’ in his pocket last season so currently you’d have to say he’s the reigning best left back
Don't remember young having a good game against hazard?
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
Don't remember young having a good game against hazard?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah 12 goals 4 assists, he was great
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
posted 20 minutes ago
Young had ‘the best player in the league’ in his pocket last season so currently you’d have to say he’s the reigning best left back
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Young and 2 others
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 minutes ago
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doesn’t make him the best player in the league though does it...
Think Mendy edges it plus he doesn't run people over so would rather have him in my dressing room
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 minutes ago
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doesn’t make him the best player in the league though does it...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
either does one season .
Either way it was most evidently a comment to not be taken serious on a seperate article.
Alonso for points definitely
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 seconds ago
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 minutes ago
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doesn’t make him the best player in the league though does it...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
either does one season.
Either way it was most evidently a comment to not be taken serious on a seperate article.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yet the original comment was about last season
Not sure you’ll find many who think hazard was better than Salah last season, good luck trying though
Even I don't. Don't see what your point is really. And the original comment was an article about left backs
Mendy
Alonso
After that don’t care
comment by LQ (U6305)
posted 3 minutes ago
Mendy
Alonso
After that don’t care
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Reckon you've seen enough from 8 league games?
What do you think he offers more than alonso or robertson?
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before where he was rated the best in Europe in that position at Monaco.
The reason we signed him.
I have never seen a full back hit the 6 yard box so consistently with powerful first time crosses.
He suits our style of play to a T.
You could say not 100% there defensively but his strength is the way he gets forward, our team is based on width.
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before where he was rated the best in Europe in that position at Monaco.
--------------------------------------------------------------
On what poll was that?
He wasn't in the CL team of the season. And marcelo was.
Wasn't in the CL squad of the season either.
Bakayoko was rated highly at Monaco, i'd rather judge mendy after a season. 8 PL games is not enough to call him the best in the league.
He also wasn't in the UEFA team of the year.
comment by LQ (U6305)
posted 49 seconds ago
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ah so you didn’t win the league then?
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
comment by LQ (U6305)
posted 49 seconds ago
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ah so you didn’t win the league then?
=======
No I’m talking about the form he showed that got city interested
Sign in if you want to comment
Alonso or Mendy
Page 1 of 6
6
posted on 10/9/18
For this season, Robertson may not be the big name but I'd say he's been better than Mendy and its a toss of the coin between him and Alonso. Alonso has more end product than them all so far so I'd give it to Alonso but I'd then have Robertson and last but not least, Mendy.
All my opinion.
posted on 10/9/18
Mendy had a bit of a nightmare against Wolves.
Alonso had a bit of a nightmare against Arsenal at times.
Alonso is not great defensively, but he is good. Very rarely do we concede goals from his side anymore (until the formation change which we are gettng use to).
It's hard to judge mendy yet anyways. How many PL games has he actually played?
Gotta say alonso for consistency over the last 2 years.
posted on 10/9/18
Well both have only played a handful of games at left back in the PL so Robertson wins by default
posted on 10/9/18
Not much difference between Robertson or Alonsos play tbh.
Roberton bombs forward like a winger a lot of the time, as does alonso.
LB/LWB both interchangeable.
posted on 10/9/18
Young had ‘the best player in the league’ in his pocket last season so currently you’d have to say he’s the reigning best left back
posted on 10/9/18
Don't remember young having a good game against hazard?
posted on 10/9/18
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
Don't remember young having a good game against hazard?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah 12 goals 4 assists, he was great
posted on 10/9/18
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
posted on 10/9/18
1 Alonso
2 Robbo
3 Mendy
posted on 10/9/18
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
posted 20 minutes ago
Young had ‘the best player in the league’ in his pocket last season so currently you’d have to say he’s the reigning best left back
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Young and 2 others
posted on 10/9/18
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 minutes ago
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doesn’t make him the best player in the league though does it...
posted on 10/9/18
Think Mendy edges it plus he doesn't run people over so would rather have him in my dressing room
posted on 10/9/18
Bag went there
posted on 10/9/18
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 minutes ago
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doesn’t make him the best player in the league though does it...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
either does one season .
Either way it was most evidently a comment to not be taken serious on a seperate article.
posted on 10/9/18
Alonso for points definitely
posted on 10/9/18
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 seconds ago
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 23 minutes ago
Yeah he was. But if you think zidane, figo, zola, bergkamp etc weren't great than ok my guy
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doesn’t make him the best player in the league though does it...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
either does one season.
Either way it was most evidently a comment to not be taken serious on a seperate article.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yet the original comment was about last season
Not sure you’ll find many who think hazard was better than Salah last season, good luck trying though
posted on 10/9/18
Even I don't. Don't see what your point is really. And the original comment was an article about left backs
posted on 10/9/18
Mendy
Alonso
After that don’t care
posted on 10/9/18
comment by LQ (U6305)
posted 3 minutes ago
Mendy
Alonso
After that don’t care
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Reckon you've seen enough from 8 league games?
What do you think he offers more than alonso or robertson?
posted on 10/9/18
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before where he was rated the best in Europe in that position at Monaco.
The reason we signed him.
I have never seen a full back hit the 6 yard box so consistently with powerful first time crosses.
He suits our style of play to a T.
You could say not 100% there defensively but his strength is the way he gets forward, our team is based on width.
posted on 10/9/18
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before where he was rated the best in Europe in that position at Monaco.
--------------------------------------------------------------
On what poll was that?
He wasn't in the CL team of the season. And marcelo was.
Wasn't in the CL squad of the season either.
Bakayoko was rated highly at Monaco, i'd rather judge mendy after a season. 8 PL games is not enough to call him the best in the league.
posted on 10/9/18
He also wasn't in the UEFA team of the year.
posted on 10/9/18
comment by LQ (U6305)
posted 49 seconds ago
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ah so you didn’t win the league then?
posted on 10/9/18
comment by Pride of the North (U6803)
comment by LQ (U6305)
posted 49 seconds ago
You can’t use last season so go back to the one before
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ah so you didn’t win the league then?
=======
posted on 10/9/18
No I’m talking about the form he showed that got city interested
Page 1 of 6
6