1. Rashford
2. Lukaku
3. Pogba
4. De Gea
5. Maguire (if we get him)
6. Shaw
7. Kane (if we get him)
8. Sanchez
9. Matic
10. Bailly
That's a lot of current and future United players in the top 10. We undoubtedly have the best players in every position, and the best manager. We should realistically have the title wrapped up by November.
Where’s Jordan Hendiniho?
I'm bored of this now mate.
............
Like I give a $hit.
comment by Edbo (U17933)
posted 1 hour, 6 minutes ago
Pogba and Eriksen shouldn't be in the top ten. Kane should be shot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
fixed it for you.
comment by (Kash) I'm the Mane (U1108)
posted 1 hour, 44 minutes ago
Whats Lukaku like in big games in Fifa?
_______
Genuinely, his touch is terrible
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by Marco Roccati (U1734)
posted 1 hour, 55 minutes ago
1. Rashford
2. Lukaku
3. Pogba
4. De Gea
5. Maguire (if we get him)
6. Shaw
7. Kane (if we get him)
8. Sanchez
9. Matic
10. Bailly
That's a lot of current and future United players in the top 10. We undoubtedly have the best players in every position, and the best manager. We should realistically have the title wrapped up by November.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
cant argue with that
Kane aged 25
2009–Tottenham Hotspur 154 (110)
2015– England 32 (19)
Salah aged 26
2010–2012 El Mokawloon 38 (11)
2012–2014 Basel 47 (9)
2014–2016 Chelsea 13 (2)
2015 → Fiorentina (loan) 16 (6)
2015–2016 → Roma (loan) 34 (14)
2016–2017 Roma 31 (15)
2017– Liverpool 40 (34)
2011– Egypt 60 (37)
Really we’ll see whose career has the longevity barring injury!
186 (129) compared to 279 (128) hmmmmm..
U do realize Mo was a winger before Liverpool
comment by TobyJanKaneobi (U15068)
posted 1 hour, 16 minutes ago
Kane aged 25
2009–Tottenham Hotspur 154 (110)
2015– England 32 (19)
Salah aged 26
2010–2012 El Mokawloon 38 (11)
2012–2014 Basel 47 (9)
2014–2016 Chelsea 13 (2)
2015 → Fiorentina (loan) 16 (6)
2015–2016 → Roma (loan) 34 (14)
2016–2017 Roma 31 (15)
2017– Liverpool 40 (34)
2011– Egypt 60 (37)
Reallywe’ll see whose career has the longevity barring injury!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What is the argument here?
Seems fairly clear Kane will end up rivalling Shearer goal wise unless he gets injured.
Salah will have a few more good years now but he isn't on the level of say a Suarez
Auba & Ozil should easily be Top 5. Let alone Top 10.
Arsenal’s ratings are pretty crap. One of the many pitfalls of having a śhït season! Thought Auba would keep his rating from 18 at least though. Hope some of our youngest have good potential, they’ve been terrible on FIFA for a while. Which is probably reflective of reality, but hopefully likes of Smith-Rowe, Niles, Mavropanos, and Guendouzi have good potential
It's hard to make a list of top 10 and include all positions on the pitch.. it should be broken up into 4 categories...
GK, Defender, D.Midfielder, A.Mid, Winger/Striker
How can you compare and CB and a CF? You can't.
Top 5 for each position from left to right...
GK: DDG, Ederson, Lloris, A.Becker, Pickford/Cech.
Defenders: Alderweireld, Azpilicueta, Vertonghen, Kompany, Van Dijk. (Don't foam at the mouth Scousers)
Midfielders: Kanté, Fernandinho, Dembele, Gundogan, Keita.
A.Midfielders/Wingers: Hazard, David Silva, De Bruyne, Salah, Eriksen.
Strikers: Aguero, Kane, Firmino, Aubameyang, Vardy.
These are just facts.
Strikers
Instead of winger/Striker it made more sense to go with A.Mid/Winger and give strikers their own category.
Also I facked it up so yea go with that instead.
comment by #LiquidGenius (U20571)
posted 2 hours, 8 minutes ago
Auba & Ozil should easily be Top 5. Let alone Top 10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In what?
comment by KLS (U1695)
comment by #LiquidGenius (U20571)
Auba & Ozil should easily be Top 5. Let alone Top 10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In what?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lol - PL footballers
Ozil in top 10 midfielders who have little effect on a game.
comment by The garden of Eden (U12176)
posted 16 minutes ago
It's hard to make a list of top 10 and include all positions on the pitch.. it should be broken up into 4 categories...
GK, Defender, D.Midfielder, A.Mid, Winger/Striker
How can you compare and CB and a CF? You can't.
Top 5 for each position from left to right...
GK: DDG, Ederson, Lloris, A.Becker, Pickford/Cech.
Defenders: Alderweireld, Azpilicueta, Vertonghen, Kompany, Van Dijk. (Don't foam at the mouth Scousers)
Midfielders: Kanté, Fernandinho, Dembele, Gundogan, Keita.
A.Midfielders/Wingers: Hazard, David Silva, De Bruyne, Salah, Eriksen.
Strikers: Aguero, Kane, Firmino, Aubameyang, Vardy.
These are just facts.
Strikers
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Would say you’re not far wrong with this.
Goalkeepers should be rated separately and probably so should defenders. Just how is one supposed to compare De Gea to Kane and Aguero and say he's above them? Are his saves more important than their goals? How long is a piece of string?
Top 5 for each position from left to right...
GK: DDG, Ederson, Lloris, A.Becker, Pickford/Cech.
Defenders: Alderweireld, Azpilicueta, Vertonghen, Kompany, Van Dijk. (Don't foam at the mouth Scousers)
Midfielders: Kanté, Fernandinho, Dembele, Gundogan, Keita.
A.Midfielders/Wingers: Hazard, David Silva, De Bruyne, Salah, Eriksen.
Strikers: Aguero, Kane
—————————————————
Why is kieta already rated so highly,
Apart from 1 really good game this season and an average season Leipzig last year there is this huge media love in????
He may go on to be a really good player but can’t undestand the plaudits so far
Top 10 list seems pretty fair tbh
1. De Bruyne
2. Hazard
3. De Gea
4. Kante
5. Kane
6. Aguero
7. Silva
8. Salah
9. Pogba
10. Eriksen
Man City = 3 players
Tottenham = 2 players
Man Utd = 2 players
Chelsea = 2 players
Liverpool = 1 player
The big 5 represented pretty fairly.
For me:
1. no issue there. did great
2. no real issue. bit inconsistent over seasons so 2 is a bit high but who cares
3.de gea. yeah as top keeper but makes errors at times.
4. no issue. top top player
5. Kane. for his socring record of course but.. well..
6. aguero yeah, has to be in there
7. no issue here either
8. fair for only one season so far.
9.. how the hell is this guy on the list.
10. should be higher, he is actually spurs most vital player
1. no issue there. did great
2. no real issue. bit inconsistent over seasons so 2 is a bit high but who cares
Despite playing in a worse team, hazard is averaging a goal or assist every 1.56 games in the pl since 2016.
KDB is every 1.44.
Both rightly the top 2 for me.
Sign in if you want to comment
Premier League Top 10 (FIFA)
Page 2 of 3
posted on 13/9/18
1. Rashford
2. Lukaku
3. Pogba
4. De Gea
5. Maguire (if we get him)
6. Shaw
7. Kane (if we get him)
8. Sanchez
9. Matic
10. Bailly
That's a lot of current and future United players in the top 10. We undoubtedly have the best players in every position, and the best manager. We should realistically have the title wrapped up by November.
posted on 13/9/18
Where’s Jordan Hendiniho?
posted on 13/9/18
I'm bored of this now mate.
............
Like I give a $hit.
posted on 13/9/18
comment by Edbo (U17933)
posted 1 hour, 6 minutes ago
Pogba and Eriksen shouldn't be in the top ten. Kane should be shot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
fixed it for you.
posted on 13/9/18
comment by (Kash) I'm the Mane (U1108)
posted 1 hour, 44 minutes ago
Whats Lukaku like in big games in Fifa?
_______
Genuinely, his touch is terrible
posted on 13/9/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 13/9/18
comment by Marco Roccati (U1734)
posted 1 hour, 55 minutes ago
1. Rashford
2. Lukaku
3. Pogba
4. De Gea
5. Maguire (if we get him)
6. Shaw
7. Kane (if we get him)
8. Sanchez
9. Matic
10. Bailly
That's a lot of current and future United players in the top 10. We undoubtedly have the best players in every position, and the best manager. We should realistically have the title wrapped up by November.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
cant argue with that
posted on 13/9/18
Kane aged 25
2009–Tottenham Hotspur 154 (110)
2015– England 32 (19)
Salah aged 26
2010–2012 El Mokawloon 38 (11)
2012–2014 Basel 47 (9)
2014–2016 Chelsea 13 (2)
2015 → Fiorentina (loan) 16 (6)
2015–2016 → Roma (loan) 34 (14)
2016–2017 Roma 31 (15)
2017– Liverpool 40 (34)
2011– Egypt 60 (37)
Really we’ll see whose career has the longevity barring injury!
posted on 13/9/18
186 (129) compared to 279 (128) hmmmmm..
posted on 13/9/18
U do realize Mo was a winger before Liverpool
posted on 13/9/18
comment by TobyJanKaneobi (U15068)
posted 1 hour, 16 minutes ago
Kane aged 25
2009–Tottenham Hotspur 154 (110)
2015– England 32 (19)
Salah aged 26
2010–2012 El Mokawloon 38 (11)
2012–2014 Basel 47 (9)
2014–2016 Chelsea 13 (2)
2015 → Fiorentina (loan) 16 (6)
2015–2016 → Roma (loan) 34 (14)
2016–2017 Roma 31 (15)
2017– Liverpool 40 (34)
2011– Egypt 60 (37)
Reallywe’ll see whose career has the longevity barring injury!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What is the argument here?
Seems fairly clear Kane will end up rivalling Shearer goal wise unless he gets injured.
Salah will have a few more good years now but he isn't on the level of say a Suarez
posted on 13/9/18
Auba & Ozil should easily be Top 5. Let alone Top 10.
posted on 13/9/18
Arsenal’s ratings are pretty crap. One of the many pitfalls of having a śhït season! Thought Auba would keep his rating from 18 at least though. Hope some of our youngest have good potential, they’ve been terrible on FIFA for a while. Which is probably reflective of reality, but hopefully likes of Smith-Rowe, Niles, Mavropanos, and Guendouzi have good potential
posted on 13/9/18
It's hard to make a list of top 10 and include all positions on the pitch.. it should be broken up into 4 categories...
GK, Defender, D.Midfielder, A.Mid, Winger/Striker
How can you compare and CB and a CF? You can't.
Top 5 for each position from left to right...
GK: DDG, Ederson, Lloris, A.Becker, Pickford/Cech.
Defenders: Alderweireld, Azpilicueta, Vertonghen, Kompany, Van Dijk. (Don't foam at the mouth Scousers)
Midfielders: Kanté, Fernandinho, Dembele, Gundogan, Keita.
A.Midfielders/Wingers: Hazard, David Silva, De Bruyne, Salah, Eriksen.
Strikers: Aguero, Kane, Firmino, Aubameyang, Vardy.
These are just facts.
Strikers
posted on 13/9/18
Instead of winger/Striker it made more sense to go with A.Mid/Winger and give strikers their own category.
Also I facked it up so yea go with that instead.
posted on 13/9/18
comment by #LiquidGenius (U20571)
posted 2 hours, 8 minutes ago
Auba & Ozil should easily be Top 5. Let alone Top 10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In what?
posted on 13/9/18
comment by KLS (U1695)
comment by #LiquidGenius (U20571)
Auba & Ozil should easily be Top 5. Let alone Top 10.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In what?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Lol - PL footballers
posted on 13/9/18
Ozil in top 10 midfielders who have little effect on a game.
posted on 13/9/18
comment by The garden of Eden (U12176)
posted 16 minutes ago
It's hard to make a list of top 10 and include all positions on the pitch.. it should be broken up into 4 categories...
GK, Defender, D.Midfielder, A.Mid, Winger/Striker
How can you compare and CB and a CF? You can't.
Top 5 for each position from left to right...
GK: DDG, Ederson, Lloris, A.Becker, Pickford/Cech.
Defenders: Alderweireld, Azpilicueta, Vertonghen, Kompany, Van Dijk. (Don't foam at the mouth Scousers)
Midfielders: Kanté, Fernandinho, Dembele, Gundogan, Keita.
A.Midfielders/Wingers: Hazard, David Silva, De Bruyne, Salah, Eriksen.
Strikers: Aguero, Kane, Firmino, Aubameyang, Vardy.
These are just facts.
Strikers
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Would say you’re not far wrong with this.
posted on 13/9/18
Goalkeepers should be rated separately and probably so should defenders. Just how is one supposed to compare De Gea to Kane and Aguero and say he's above them? Are his saves more important than their goals? How long is a piece of string?
posted on 14/9/18
Top 5 for each position from left to right...
GK: DDG, Ederson, Lloris, A.Becker, Pickford/Cech.
Defenders: Alderweireld, Azpilicueta, Vertonghen, Kompany, Van Dijk. (Don't foam at the mouth Scousers)
Midfielders: Kanté, Fernandinho, Dembele, Gundogan, Keita.
A.Midfielders/Wingers: Hazard, David Silva, De Bruyne, Salah, Eriksen.
Strikers: Aguero, Kane
—————————————————
Why is kieta already rated so highly,
Apart from 1 really good game this season and an average season Leipzig last year there is this huge media love in????
He may go on to be a really good player but can’t undestand the plaudits so far
posted on 14/9/18
Top 10 list seems pretty fair tbh
posted on 14/9/18
1. De Bruyne
2. Hazard
3. De Gea
4. Kante
5. Kane
6. Aguero
7. Silva
8. Salah
9. Pogba
10. Eriksen
Man City = 3 players
Tottenham = 2 players
Man Utd = 2 players
Chelsea = 2 players
Liverpool = 1 player
The big 5 represented pretty fairly.
posted on 14/9/18
For me:
1. no issue there. did great
2. no real issue. bit inconsistent over seasons so 2 is a bit high but who cares
3.de gea. yeah as top keeper but makes errors at times.
4. no issue. top top player
5. Kane. for his socring record of course but.. well..
6. aguero yeah, has to be in there
7. no issue here either
8. fair for only one season so far.
9.. how the hell is this guy on the list.
10. should be higher, he is actually spurs most vital player
posted on 14/9/18
1. no issue there. did great
2. no real issue. bit inconsistent over seasons so 2 is a bit high but who cares
Despite playing in a worse team, hazard is averaging a goal or assist every 1.56 games in the pl since 2016.
KDB is every 1.44.
Both rightly the top 2 for me.
Page 2 of 3