or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 38 comments are related to an article called:

Question for Jose apologists

Page 1 of 2

posted on 8/3/20

To be fair, he was a good manager ten years ago.

posted on 8/3/20

apparently I keep hearing that he is a serial winner, what ever that means, about something that happened in history apparently

posted on 8/3/20

Fluked a champions League win at Porto in a game where they were battard , claimed himself the Messiah , got a job in London and just brought himself all the best players , Roman clicked on, sacked him went to Madrid and then back to London . Went to Utd spunked a fortune there bored everyone lost the plot and now his at a club that hates spending and has been found out again.

No doubt years ago when he could buy who ever he wanted he was successful, anyone in his situation would be , now it's an even playing field he can't complete.

posted on 8/3/20

comment by Edward Elizabeth Hitler. (U14393)
posted 11 minutes ago
Fluked a champions League win at Porto in a game where they were battard , claimed himself the Messiah , got a job in London and just brought himself all the best players , Roman clicked on, sacked him went to Madrid and then back to London . Went to Utd spunked a fortune there bored everyone lost the plot and now his at a club that hates spending and has been found out again.

No doubt years ago when he could buy who ever he wanted he was successful, anyone in his situation would be , now it's an even playing field he can't complete.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Jose's managerial career succinctly summarised here.

posted on 8/3/20

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Kano (U20144)

posted on 8/3/20

You're not going to get a reply from the cult of Mourinho OP. They'd rather deflect than answer the points put to them

posted on 8/3/20

The problem with Jose Mourinho is that his main concern at all times is always Jose Mourinho. His own reputation is always more important to him than that of the club or the players he is managing.

When things are going well it doesnt matter so much, but when he hits a sticky patch it means you get this version of him, where his only aim is to make sure that everyone is aware that what is happening is everyone's fault but his. And in doing so he almost always creates an absolutely toxic atmosphere around the club.

I do genuinely feel for you guys. I can honestly say I have never felt as emotionally detached from United as when Jose was our manager. Absolutely horrendous decision by whoever made it.

posted on 8/3/20

comment by -bloodred- (U1222)
posted 52 seconds ago
The problem with Jose Mourinho is that his main concern at all times is always Jose Mourinho. His own reputation is always more important to him than that of the club or the players he is managing.

When things are going well it doesnt matter so much, but when he hits a sticky patch it means you get this version of him, where his only aim is to make sure that everyone is aware that what is happening is everyone's fault but his. And in doing so he almost always creates an absolutely toxic atmosphere around the club.

I do genuinely feel for you guys. I can honestly say I have never felt as emotionally detached from United as when Jose was our manager. Absolutely horrendous decision by whoever made it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah it sucks , I used to love watching us , now it's like a nightmare.

posted on 8/3/20

comment by -bloodred- (U1222)
posted 1 minute ago
The problem with Jose Mourinho is that his main concern at all times is always Jose Mourinho. His own reputation is always more important to him than that of the club or the players he is managing.

When things are going well it doesnt matter so much, but when he hits a sticky patch it means you get this version of him, where his only aim is to make sure that everyone is aware that what is happening is everyone's fault but his. And in doing so he almost always creates an absolutely toxic atmosphere around the club.

I do genuinely feel for you guys. I can honestly say I have never felt as emotionally detached from United as when Jose was our manager. Absolutely horrendous decision by whoever made it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nice summary. The detachment is what gets me. Think I have been to 4 games since he joined. Honestly, no longer care whether we win or lose. The longer he is here the longer we're subjected to this insipid football and circus. Only thing left to hope for this season is he gets canned.

posted on 8/3/20

apparently so im told it will get better when he gets his own players in !!!

comment by Spurtle (U1608)

posted on 8/3/20

Apart from his spell at Real Madrid, in which any manager can improve their stats, his win percentage has been on a decline from job to job since his time at Porto. He's now experiencing the worst win rate in his career currently at Spurs. This will also be his 6th trophyless season in his last 8 seasons. Now we're getting public criticism of individuals, and excuses.

It's hard not to think he isn't past it when you follow his career path.

posted on 8/3/20

he was a top manager , but football has changed

very attack minded, high pressing teams , like those managed by Klopp and Nagelsmann

increased athleticism and the rule changes in football, all favour high tempo attacking football

Mou is out of sink with all this...the way he tries to protect one goal leads an example

the new Mou in world football, who seems able to play for narrow wins and defend leads is Simeone...but he has only done this with one club so far

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 8/3/20

Small squad

No depth

Injured players

Someone can’t be bothered

Jose tactically to blame

Levy not investing

Everyone gets both barrels

posted on 8/3/20

Not surprised that this hasn't gotten a response

posted on 8/3/20

Sandy's talking to Don about a response

posted on 8/3/20

comment by -bloodred- (U1222)
posted 1 hour, 19 minutes ago
The problem with Jose Mourinho is that his main concern at all times is always Jose Mourinho. His own reputation is always more important to him than that of the club or the players he is managing.

When things are going well it doesnt matter so much, but when he hits a sticky patch it means you get this version of him, where his only aim is to make sure that everyone is aware that what is happening is everyone's fault but his. And in doing so he almost always creates an absolutely toxic atmosphere around the club.

I do genuinely feel for you guys. I can honestly say I have never felt as emotionally detached from United as when Jose was our manager. Absolutely horrendous decision by whoever made it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I cant believe we have fans that defend this guy.

posted on 8/3/20

comment by Dave&Danny (U4428)
posted 14 minutes ago
Sandy's talking to Don about a response
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sandy filtered me because I criticised Jose.

posted on 8/3/20

Bergwijn, lo Celso, Lamela, Lucas, Ndombele and Dele - None of these are strikers and you fail to mention Kane, Son and Sissoko are injured.

You want him to play champagne football ? Come on cut him some slack. Goals are going to be hard to come by until one of Kane and Son are back.

I believe in him and he is still on a free pass until season. Won't get bored of saying it no matter how bad results are between now and the end of the season.

comment by Kano (U20144)

posted on 8/3/20

comment by LukaBrasi (U22178)
posted 1 minute ago
Bergwijn, lo Celso, Lamela, Lucas, Ndombele and Dele - None of these are strikers and you fail to mention Kane, Son and Sissoko are injured.

You want him to play champagne football ? Come on cut him some slack. Goals are going to be hard to come by until one of Kane and Son are back.

I believe in him and he is still on a free pass until season. Won't get bored of saying it no matter how bad results are between now and the end of the season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Morning Sandy

posted on 8/3/20

Oh and Lamps still has Giroud as well as Bat man, and Ole was backed and signed Igahlo. Also has Greenwood who is miles ahead of Parrot plus Martial.

posted on 8/3/20

comment by Kano (U20144)
posted 52 seconds ago
comment by LukaBrasi (U22178)
posted 1 minute ago
Bergwijn, lo Celso, Lamela, Lucas, Ndombele and Dele - None of these are strikers and you fail to mention Kane, Son and Sissoko are injured.

You want him to play champagne football ? Come on cut him some slack. Goals are going to be hard to come by until one of Kane and Son are back.

I believe in him and he is still on a free pass until season. Won't get bored of saying it no matter how bad results are between now and the end of the season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Morning Sandy
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Alright drama queen. Happy International Women's day to you and the rest of clan on here LOL

posted on 8/3/20

comment by LukaBrasi (U22178)
posted 2 minutes ago
Bergwijn, lo Celso, Lamela, Lucas, Ndombele and Dele - None of these are strikers and you fail to mention Kane, Son and Sissoko are injured.

You want him to play champagne football ? Come on cut him some slack. Goals are going to be hard to come by until one of Kane and Son are back.

I believe in him and he is still on a free pass until season. Won't get bored of saying it no matter how bad results are between now and the end of the season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Why does a lack of a striker mean we have to carry on playing long?

posted on 8/3/20

Dunno mate. Ask Jose but I have seen interviews of him saying he doesn't believe in possession based football. Got him a few trophies down the years hey?

posted on 8/3/20

And we don't play ling all the time but it is good to mix it up. Would you rather we played sidewayz z z z z?

posted on 8/3/20

comment by LukaBrasi (U22178)
posted 21 seconds ago
And we don't play ling all the time but it is good to mix it up. Would you rather we played sidewayz z z z z?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'd rather play good football.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment