1. Jimenez
2. Bowen
3. Ighalo
4. Kane
5. Aguero
6. Rashford
7. Vardy
8. Jota
9. Samatta
10. Greenwood

Ings should be in there,

Kane should be clear in 2nd, unless injuries have permanently ruined him he's the only striker to have kept up with Aguero over the past 5 years.

I'd probably have Vardy above Auba. Rashford I like, but he has consistently done much better as a wide forward than as a no.9, so he should drop down at least 2 places, if not more.

Slim pickings outside the obvious 3 or 4

Auba has kept up with Aguero in a much worse team.

comment by Wahl Icht - Greatmanagerswinthetreble (U22332)
posted 4 minutes ago
Auba has kept up with Aguero in a much worse team.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
to be fair, at club level over the last 5 years, that is true.

i just think that aguero has that little extra touch of class - which partly explains his much better record internationally, at european level for city, and his record vs the big 6 in the PL - and even arsenal fans will admit that when he isn't scoring, PEA doesn't offer much to the team.

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

This is list is rubbish but Lacazette should be nowhere near the list.

1. Aguero
2. Kane
3. Auba
4. Rashford
5. Vardy
6. Firminho
7. Jesus
8. Jimenez
9. Ings
10. Giroud

i'd be wary of putting ings in on the back of this season alone. he's about to turn 28, has zero international goals, zero european goals, and this season is the first time he has scored more than 11 goals in the top flight (albeit he has twice as many PL goals this year as firmino).

1.Aguero
2.Auba
3.Rashford
4.Kane
5.Jimenez
6.Vardy
7.Firminio
8.Martial
9. Ings
10.Abraham

comment by Don Draper's dandruff (U20155)
posted 11 minutes ago
i'd be wary of putting ings in on the back of this season alone. he's about to turn 28, has zero international goals, zero european goals, and this season is the first time he has scored more than 11 goals in the top flight (albeit he has twice as many PL goals this year as firmino).
----------------------------------------------------------------------
On the other hand I’ve only recently appreciated just how good his record is this season. 19 goals and still 7 games to go - will probably end with early 20s goals.

It is a fantastic record and very very rare for a team finishing where Southampton will finish to have a striker with that record

How is Rashford 3rd, he's not even a striker.

1. Aguero
2. Aubameyang
3. Kane
4. Firmino (only because he's not a proper striker)
5. Jimenez
6. Vardy
7. Ings
8. Rashford
9. Jesus
10. Maupay

comment by Kunta Kante (U1641)
posted 10 minutes ago
comment by Don Draper's dandruff (U20155)
posted 11 minutes ago
i'd be wary of putting ings in on the back of this season alone. he's about to turn 28, has zero international goals, zero european goals, and this season is the first time he has scored more than 11 goals in the top flight (albeit he has twice as many PL goals this year as firmino).
----------------------------------------------------------------------
On the other hand I’ve only recently appreciated just how good his record is this season. 19 goals and still 7 games to go - will probably end with early 20s goals.

It is a fantastic record and very very rare for a team finishing where Southampton will finish to have a striker with that record
----------------------------------------------------------------------
i think when these debates come up i often (over)prioritise permanent class over temporary form - so for me anyone who has kane below 3rd, for instance, is just doing this wrong.

if i could be bothered to do a proper top 10, i might even find a place for alexis sanchez, that boy sure could score goals once upon a time.

Mo Salah, then everyone else wherever you like.
Could he make it 3 golden boots on the bounce? 🙂

comment by jlou1978 (U15376)
posted 5 minutes ago
Mo Salah, then everyone else wherever you like.
Could he make it 3 golden boots on the bounce? 🙂
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah totally agree Mo & mane top for me

comment by der kloppites Hi, wie geht es dir * (U13373)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by jlou1978 (U15376)
posted 5 minutes ago
Mo Salah, then everyone else wherever you like.
Could he make it 3 golden boots on the bounce? 🙂
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah totally agree Mo & mane top for me
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Indeed.
Joint Golden Boot winners from last season of course. 👍

Jlou having another meltdown at lfc not occupying top spot in an opinion poll 🤣

Jiminez > Vardy

giroud > abraham