or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 164 comments are related to an article called:

Rating top 4 teams

Page 2 of 7

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 52 seconds ago
Teams Robertson would not get into:

Real Madrid (Mendy, Marcelo)
Bayern Munich (Hernandez, Davies, Alaba)
PSG (Bernat)
Manchester United (Telles)
Tottenham (Reguilon)
Chelsea (Chilwell)
Everton (Digne)
Juventus (Sandro)
Barcelona (Alba)
----------------------------------------------------------------------


Too obvious this one.

posted on 16/11/20

Robertson is rubbish for Scotland though.

I think he's excellent at Liverpool but i'm not sure if he would be able to replicate it elsewhere.

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Inbefore (U20589)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by JustYourAverageFan (U21016)
posted 3 minutes ago
How have you put England's best side for the past 2 seasons below all of the other top 4 sides. Bit of biased there considering Mourinho's also has the best.

Robertson 7.
Henderson 6 but all of Spurs' midfield are 7.
Rodri and Gundogan 7.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sorry, should Rodri and Gundogan be lower or higher? And which of Tottenham's midfield should be lower? I think they all deserve 7.And I'm not prepared to argue with Liverpool fans over Ashley Marcelo Roberto Carlos Robertson. That would be a pointless argument.

If he left Liverpool, he'd end up at a team like Southampton or Leeds. I dunno know why Liverpool think Robertson is world class.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
because hes been performing at a world class level for years now, as the best lb currently in world football?

Simple really.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Robertson???

Alexander Arnold, I can maybe agree. Van Dijk, yeah no arguments. Salah, again no arguments, Same with Alisson. Mane maybe.

But Robertson??? Furrrk off, the guy is midtable level and you know it.

posted on 16/11/20

Robertson, wasn't this guy playing for Hull or someone before Liverpool bought him for like 5m?

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 25 seconds ago
Robertson, wasn't this guy playing for Hull or someone before Liverpool bought him for like 5m?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep, just shows anyone can become world class if they put the hard work in. A true football fairytale.

posted on 16/11/20

Mid table level, that's why he's been key in one of the World's most successful sides over the last 2/3 years. Yeah ok then Wahl. The fact Bernat, Telles and Digne are even on that list makes it a wind up.

Scotland play a completely different style of play to Liverpool for a start.

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 1 minute ago
Robertson, wasn't this guy playing for Hull or someone before Liverpool bought him for like 5m?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Must make him sheiiiite then.

Kane can't be a 10 because he's had loan deals at football league clubs like Millwall and Leyton Orient, so that must be his level.

posted on 16/11/20

I don't mind saying Van Dijk and Salah and Alisson are world class because they are. mane and Alexander Arnold, maybe as well. But Robertson is not that good. he's like Hendo and Fabinho, an OK player who does OK in the Liverpool system.

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Inbefore (U20589)
posted 42 seconds ago
Liverpool:
Alisson 9
Trent 9
Gomez 8
Van Dijk 10
Robertson 9
Thiago 9
Fabinho 8
Henderson 7
Mane 9
Firmino 7
Salah 9
total: 95/110

Man City:
Ederson 8
Walker 8
Dias 8
Laporte 8
Mendy 5
De Bruyne 10
Rodri 7
Gundogan 8
Sterling 9
Aguero 10
Bernardo 8
total: 89/110

Chelsea
Mendy 7
James 7
Zouma 6
Thiago Silva 7
Chilwell 7
Havertz 8
Kante 9
Mount 7
Pulisic 8
Werner 9
Ziyech 8
Total: 83/110

Tottenham:
Lloris 6
Doherty 6
Dier 6
Alderweireld 7
Reguilon 7
Hojbjerg 7
Ndombele 5
Lo Celso 6
Bale 7
Kane 10
Son 9
Total:76/110
----------------------------------------------------------------------
OK... let me get this straight

Gomez 8 Thiago Silva 7
Robertson 9 Reguilon 7 Chilwell 7
Firmino 7 Bale 7
Gomez 8 Laporte 8
Ndombele 5 (wtf is this rating)
Henderson 7 Rodri 7
Gomez 8 Laporte 8 (I know I've said this one already, but I need to repeat it, it's so ridiculous)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Laportes been injured for most of last season and this. Hes a top player would be 9 if he was in form playing more.

Same with Bale, whats he done recently?

Ndombele has been a flop even your lover Jose chucked him under a bus.

Regullion, early days looks promising. Chillwell 7 is fair rate him but long way to go to improve on it too early.

Rodri, hes no Fernandinho, put Fernandinho in there and prob get a point or 2 more. Dont rate Rodri that well dont think hes been that great. Solid enough player just not been working as well for city as Fernandinho.

Infact my ratings of Cities def are generous considering the last year or so. You can laugh at Liverpools def for this years 8 games but it was still the best last season def record was it not?

Silva has done next to fack all for Chelsea is ancient.

Again all things considered Gomez has been a contributing factor for the best def when hes been fit for the best part of the last 2 years. Hes 23 and still a lot of room for improvement too. Shame hes injury prone.

posted on 16/11/20

But Robertson??? Furrrk off, the guy is midtable level and you know it.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm honest about him and his struggles for Scotland. Tierney performs better on the left than Robertson does for his country.

That said in the PL there has been nobody near him in his position for 2/3 seasons. His form for Liverpool has been excellent. 25 assists in the last two full seasons from LB is incredible.

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Dr Sheldon Cooper (U1217)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - Psychic spies from China try to steal your minds elation (U1282)
posted 17 minutes ago
comment by Barefoot (U19770)
posted 21 minutes ago
Is Jose underachieving considering he has the best team?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Liverpool overachieving considering Klopp has the worst team.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Liverpool have achieved nothing this season
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Neither has anyone else but so what anyway? You didn't limit your article to this season. The first line is "top 4 teams in my opinion".

posted on 16/11/20

Chilwell has 15 assists in his whole career and Robertson got 25 in two seasons

posted on 16/11/20

It is absolutely absurd to say Gomez is an 8, Thiago Silva is a 7 and Laporte is an 8. I don't know how it's possible to think this.

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - Psychic spies from China try to steal your minds elation (U1282)
posted 42 minutes ago
comment by Barefoot (U19770)
posted 21 minutes ago
Is Jose underachieving considering he has the best team?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Liverpool overachieving considering Klopp has the worst team.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looking at how much the Liverpool squad cost versus Spurs team cost, I'd say Spurs are doing better

posted on 16/11/20

comment by HB Fash - Never doubted Stevie G as manager (U21935)
posted 3 minutes ago
Chilwell has 15 assists in his whole career and Robertson got 25 in two seasons
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Chilwell looks great for Chelsea so far.

posted on 16/11/20

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 16/11/20

comment by JustYourAverageFan (U21016)
posted 13 minutes ago
Gomez isn't as good as Laporte tbf. Rodri isn't that good, not sure why everybody thinks that he is because he isn't. Doesn't have anywhere near the same effect as what Fernandinho did at City and it's showing.

Robertson is by far and away the best LB on this list, that's not up for debate Wahl.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Reguilon is much better option than Robertson, that's not a debate - that's a fact

posted on 16/11/20

comment by morespurs (U15748)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - Psychic spies from China try to steal your minds elation (U1282)
posted 42 minutes ago
comment by Barefoot (U19770)
posted 21 minutes ago
Is Jose underachieving considering he has the best team?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Liverpool overachieving considering Klopp has the worst team.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looking at how much the Liverpool squad cost versus Spurs team cost, I'd say Spurs are doing better
----------------------------------------------------------------------
cost 69m more as it stands.

https://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/premier-league-transfers-full-cost-22884283

posted on 16/11/20

comment by morespurs (U15748)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by JustYourAverageFan (U21016)
posted 13 minutes ago
Gomez isn't as good as Laporte tbf. Rodri isn't that good, not sure why everybody thinks that he is because he isn't. Doesn't have anywhere near the same effect as what Fernandinho did at City and it's showing.

Robertson is by far and away the best LB on this list, that's not up for debate Wahl.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Reguilon is much better option than Robertson, that's not a debate - that's a fact
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You're also known by your own fans as a WUM for this reason as well.

posted on 16/11/20

comment by morespurs (U15748)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by JustYourAverageFan (U21016)
posted 13 minutes ago
Gomez isn't as good as Laporte tbf. Rodri isn't that good, not sure why everybody thinks that he is because he isn't. Doesn't have anywhere near the same effect as what Fernandinho did at City and it's showing.

Robertson is by far and away the best LB on this list, that's not up for debate Wahl.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Reguilon is much better option than Robertson, that's not a debate - that's a fact
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This confirms Robbo as the better player.

posted on 16/11/20

comment by Wahl Icht ; (U22469)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by HB Fash - Never doubted Stevie G as manager (U21935)
posted 3 minutes ago
Chilwell has 15 assists in his whole career and Robertson got 25 in two seasons
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Chilwell looks great for Chelsea so far.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He's achieved nothing.

posted on 16/11/20

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 16/11/20

comment by morespurs (U15748)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - Psychic spies from China try to steal your minds elation (U1282)
posted 42 minutes ago
comment by Barefoot (U19770)
posted 21 minutes ago
Is Jose underachieving considering he has the best team?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Liverpool overachieving considering Klopp has the worst team.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looking at how much the Liverpool squad cost versus Spurs team cost, I'd say Spurs are doing better
----------------------------------------------------------------------

The gap is less than 100m, Spurs have won nothing. How can they be doing better?

Liverpool have won the CL and PL. If spending was directly related to trophies then Spurs should at least have won the Carling cup or community shield at least.

posted on 16/11/20

Alisson 10
Trent 9
Gomez 7 if he's with Van Dijk, 5 if not
Van Dijk 9 would have been 10 last year but he's had a blip for his standards of late
Robertson 8
Thiago 9
Fabinho 9
Henderson 8
Mane 10
Firmino 8
Salah 9

Ederson 7
Walker 7
Dias 9 this one will raise eyebrows but he looks sensational to me and in my opinion will be a lead CB in this decade
Laporte 8
Ake 7
De Bruyne 10
Fernandinho 7
Foden 7
Sterling 9
Aguero 8 still very good but not the freak of nature he was
Mahrez 8

Mendy 7
James 8
Zouma 7 if he's with Silva, 5 if not
Thiago Silva 9
Chilwell 8
Havertz 7 atm probably 8 by the end
Kante 8 last season would have said 6 but he looks back to his best this time.
Mount 7
Pulisic 8
Werner 8
Ziyech 9

Lloris 8
Doherty 7
Dier 6
Sanchez 5
Reguilon 9 Crazy good, Spurs fans must be praying Real keep Zidane so he doesn't get recalled with the buy back clause.
Hojbjerg 7
Ndombele 7
Lo Celso 7
Lucas 7 yes I've put Lucas there as in my opinion he's a better player than 2020 Bale quite comfortably.
Kane 10
Son 10

posted on 16/11/20

comment by GTWI4T- some people deserve to get trolled (U6008)
posted 44 seconds ago
comment by Inbefore (U20589)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by morespurs (U15748)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - Psychic spies from China try to steal your minds elation (U1282)
posted 42 minutes ago
comment by Barefoot (U19770)
posted 21 minutes ago
Is Jose underachieving considering he has the best team?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Liverpool overachieving considering Klopp has the worst team.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looking at how much the Liverpool squad cost versus Spurs team cost, I'd say Spurs are doing better
----------------------------------------------------------------------
cost 69m more as it stands.

https://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/premier-league-transfers-full-cost-22884283
----------------------------------------------------------------------


----------------------------------------------------------------------
ikr and they have bale n vinicius on loan too. their squad prob cost more as it stands if you include bale n vinicius 100m costs

Page 2 of 7

Sign in if you want to comment