or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 430532 comments are related to an article called:

Fan's Barclays Premiership Season 16

Page 17037 of 17222

comment by Welshy (U1348)

posted on 1/11/23

I have a dark art for injuries 🙈

posted on 1/11/23

You do indeed

posted on 1/11/23

Those injuries give me food for thought, for de Jong replacement and Fan’s injuries

posted on 1/11/23

Yeah I might play Ashley Phillips

posted on 1/11/23

Romero Colwill or Torres I’d imagine

posted on 1/11/23

Probably

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

Taken a punt on Gabri Veiga for the same reason Fan took a punt on Ruben Neves, because Newcastle might be signing him on loan in January from the Saudis

posted on 2/11/23

they will be linked with everyone

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

Only those two so far though. Tonali replacements.

posted on 2/11/23

McTominay, Fred, Amadou Onana

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

Fred

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

Although I thought you meant specifically players in the Saudi league

posted on 2/11/23

ah no just in general, McTominay would be a good signing for any club below top 4 in the PL imo, dont know why Utd dont use him more

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

Depends if it's Scotland's McTominay or Man U's McTominay

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

Just saw Bayern lost in the German Cup last night to a 3rd tier side!

The Harry Kane curse is real...

posted on 2/11/23



Newcastle would get Scotlands version

posted on 2/11/23

Is it worth signing them given they’ll only be on loan from Saudi though… unlikely to have any sale value

posted on 2/11/23

cant see them being in Saudi long tbh

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 41 minutes ago
Is it worth signing them given they’ll only be on loan from Saudi though… unlikely to have any sale value
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They wont lose their TM valuation so there's no risk in that regard, and if they're playing in the PL (or any strong league) then their ratings in here would reflect that I feel.

And then they could well get another move in the summer based on that

comment by Marky (U19443)

posted on 2/11/23

Using Neves and Veiga as examples, they haven't become bad players just because they moved to Saudi Arabia, but they can't be rated as highly as they were before because they aren't playing against as good opposition.

Even a loan move in January to a big league fixes that issue

posted on 2/11/23

comment by Marky (U19443)
posted 5 hours, 21 minutes ago
Using Neves and Veiga as examples, they haven't become bad players just because they moved to Saudi Arabia, but they can't be rated as highly as they were before because they aren't playing against as good opposition.

Even a loan move in January to a big league fixes that issue
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Agree with that for the time they spend elsewhere they’ll be rated, but can’t imagine anyone wanting for other than TM value is my point

As much chance of them moving in the summer as any other player in Saudi

posted on 2/11/23

I’ll get my money back if he doesn’t move so not losing anything

posted on 2/11/23

Agreed. Good move I think

Would he start if he was at Newcastle?

posted on 2/11/23

Slot in beside Bruno I’d imagine with one other

posted on 2/11/23

Is Joelinton not the 3rd player

Page 17037 of 17222

Sign in if you want to comment