A fit Gordon is a berry good keeper but if Fiven hadn't have had a season on the bench at City he would likely have been cosidered top 3 keepers in the world. Hart wasn't better than him he's just younger with the potential to become on of the best keepers and he said hed leave if he was 2nd choice.

Given was arguably city's best player whistle first choice keeper

What about the Xbox

Wigan

Given = McGregor?

Mcgregor = Gordon

Given is a Celtic reject, difficult for me to see past that.

Gordon is an all round world class goalkeeper when he is fit. A lot of people argue McGreggor should keep the no.1 spot for Scotland, but while I rate McGreggor as a great shot stopper Gordon's on another level.

Mario Gomez
just a few more goals... he's class

xbox aswell

Im looking forward to SA online

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BX51EGt98XU

horrible

I can't believe some of you rate Gordon so well!
I think he is shocking! He makes so many mistakes. I mean every keeper makes a few mistakes but every game I watch him, he seems to make one. Ok, Sczsesney and De Gea are making a few recently but they are young and will mature and gain experience and stop making these. Gordon is like 27?
Maybe I underate him but I have never thought he was any good.

wigan

you wanna swap Given for Mcgregor?

And just to give my opinion...

1. Hart
2. Reina
3. Cech
4. Given
5. De Gea/Sczesney (maybe I am overating these 2 as they are young though)

I do like Jaaskelainen, Schwarzer, Begovic, Vorm and Krul though.

John Ruddy has proved to be a good keeper as well, not as good as that lot but still done very well so far for Norwich

Givens on loan and mcgregor is cra p i belive

where is brad on that list...

I drew with Basel.
Pretty disappointed with that to be honest.

no he isnt, but then you dont know much really...

McGregor is a very good keeper but he plays for rangers and I hate them

I'm not too big a fan of Friedel anymore either.
He's still good but I don't think he is much better than Gomes to be honest.

atm i think szczesny is better than de gea, but i can de gea being top class.

in the future i can see these two being two of the best in the world and there will be constant debates on whos better

ok... i dont know much then

I think harts a little over rated too he makes a fair few errors but city just score loads

IMO Reina Cech are the most consistently good keepers they have one bad game a year. Friedel and Given not too far off in terms of consistently if not equal and then hart just behind them too. I'd have hart above the latter for potential and the fact that when he plays to his best he's amazing

well you are saying McGregor is cruop..that shows it really

Courtois will be better than both Wilahere

jussi i rate because look at the shots he has to take every game and saves

mig is also good and young and westwood looks promising

I'm from Shrewsbury so I probably do overate Hart to be honest.
David Edwards is also the best CM in the Prem, Holt is the best ST and Tierney is the best LB too.