I’m starting to think maybe we go for it and promote Hugill… just as another body to bring on in that position.
You never know, the lad might fly…
I'll give it an 8 so far.
More importantly I think we have a manager who is a 9.5. Bearing in mind that SAF is the 10.
Casemiro - world class destroyer to help protect the questionable defensive solidarity
Martinez - a tenacious ball playing CB
Eriksen - a creative spark capable of playing the style ETH expects
Malacia - a highly rated young LB, energetic up and down
Antony - another starter for Brazil, young who appears to have all the tools in his kitbag capable of going on to be a great on the right wing
———————
Cliché and lots of fancy adjectives
comment by Metro.⚽️ (U6770)
posted 57 seconds ago
Casemiro - world class destroyer to help protect the questionable defensive solidarity
Martinez - a tenacious ball playing CB
Eriksen - a creative spark capable of playing the style ETH expects
Malacia - a highly rated young LB, energetic up and down
Antony - another starter for Brazil, young who appears to have all the tools in his kitbag capable of going on to be a great on the right wing
———————
Cliché and lots of fancy adjectives
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Cliche is cliche for a reason
Maguire good or sh!t? But ignoring all the reasons why he's sh!t
All goes to shiiiiit once Varane starts missing 2 out of every 3 games and we have to sit deep to accommodate MacQuire.
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 1 minute ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So he's started for Brazil
If the business is over then it’s a 6/10 for me.
De Gea fine as no1 for another year if not ideal, can mix and match in midfield. Still get the feeling United will hand out daft extensions to players that aren’t good enough and then can’t be sold.
RB and CF still needed this window imo but seem to need to move AWB and Ronaldo on first
Would be a 10 if you could get two good players in those positions as replacements and milinkovic-Savic.
comment by The Post Nearly Man (U1270)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 1 minute ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So he's started for Brazil
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, my comment was on him being a 'starter' for Brazil not whether he has started. Would you like the difference explained to you or do we just draw a line under this one and agree that he's not a starter for Brazil?
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
On paper I'd give it a 7/10.
Some of the fees and the evident lack of forward planning would temper that rating if we were to consider those aspects of our business. And of course there's the caveat that we've not seen enough (or any, yet) of these players to make an assessment as to whether they are or will be good signings.
If we can shift Ronaldo & bringing in some CF cover I'd say that's a decent first innings under ETH, market-wise.
Over the next two windows we then need to unearth the next Luka Modric, the next Dani Alves and the next Ederson, all of which should be easy enough for our tip-top scouting & recruiting department.
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Researching? I knew he wasn't a starter for Brazil. Would you like me to just state he wasn't a starter or to provide the evidence for it.
Two weird responses to me correcting the OP so far. Any more?
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe he already knew the amount of starts each current right winger in the Brazil squad have got, off the top of his head.
Seriously though, it’s good to have some obsessive fact checkers on the site. Means I don’t have to look stuff uk myself and also means I don’t re quote something I’ve heard on here and get called out for it at work or in the pub!
6/10
Neglected too many crucial areas for me.
Antony isn’t a starter for Brazil, to be fair. Though I don’t think they really have that many given how much they seem to rotate.
Will be interesting to see what their squad looks like in Qatar. They’ve got lots of attacking options.
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Researching? I knew he wasn't a starter for Brazil. Would you like me to just state he wasn't a starter or to provide the evidence for it.
Two weird responses to me correcting the OP so far. Any more?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The chances of you knowing what you said off the top of your head are next to nil, so yes you went away and researched it so you could try to look smart on the United board, when in reality you look like a pathetic little man who’s never seen a woman topless
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 29 seconds ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe he already knew the amount of starts each current right winger in the Brazil squad have got, off the top of his head.
Seriously though, it’s good to have some obsessive fact checkers on the site. Means I don’t have to look stuff uk myself and also means I don’t re quote something I’ve heard on here and get called out for it at work or in the pub!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't know the exact number of starts but knew Raphinha had been the starter on the right over the past year and Antony had been coming off the bench around the 70 minute mark over that period. It had actually been a problem position for them for the previous few years, with Coutinho even playing there on occasion, as well as Everton, Gabriel Jesus, Gabriel Barbosa and is it Paqueta(sp?) from Lyon I think, amongst others.
Everytime I watched them play around that period I always thought they could do with a regular right winger which is why Raphinha being the starter there stuck in my mind.
Typical of this website you correct an incorrect statement and then have to explain yourself in how you obtained the correct information.
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Researching? I knew he wasn't a starter for Brazil. Would you like me to just state he wasn't a starter or to provide the evidence for it.
Two weird responses to me correcting the OP so far. Any more?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The chances of you knowing what you said off the top of your head are next to nil, so yes you went away and researched it so you could try to look smart on the United board, when in reality you look like a pathetic little man who’s never seen a woman topless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah OK. I have no time for imbeciles, so I'll give you a miss. The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 8 seconds ago
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 29 seconds ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe he already knew the amount of starts each current right winger in the Brazil squad have got, off the top of his head.
Seriously though, it’s good to have some obsessive fact checkers on the site. Means I don’t have to look stuff uk myself and also means I don’t re quote something I’ve heard on here and get called out for it at work or in the pub!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't know the exact number of starts but knew Raphinha had been the starter on the right over the past year and Antony had been coming off the bench around the 70 minute mark over that period. It had actually been a problem position for them for the previous few years, with Coutinho even playing there on occasion, as well as Everton, Gabriel Jesus, Gabriel Barbosa and is it Paqueta(sp?) from Lyon I think, amongst others.
Everytime I watched them play around that period I always thought they could do with a regular right winger which is why Raphinha being the starter there stuck in my mind.
Typical of this website you correct an incorrect statement and then have to explain yourself in how you obtained the correct information.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Overcompensating by basically typing out a match report
Bet you were the guy at school who corrected the teachers for making a mistake on the blackboard, and then rightly got beaten up at lunch
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
a pathetic little man who’s never seen a woman topless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Random or what?
The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
———
This was written by a Liverpool fan.
comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 22 seconds ago
The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
———
This was written by a Liverpool fan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, towards a defensive United fan who had a hissyfit when it was pointed out that something was incorrect. Which team I support has not bearing on that.
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 15 seconds ago
comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 22 seconds ago
The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
———
This was written by a Liverpool fan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, towards a defensive United fan who had a hissyfit when it was pointed out that something was incorrect. Which team I support has not bearing on that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Still hitting refresh every 60s and responding to comments though aren’t you
Poolmyfinger will be crying about people being racist next.
Bit of useless information and hopefully I don't have to show my workings out for this one to the defensive weasels of the site but just saw on BBC that West Ham have signed Paqueta who I spoke about before. Looked good for Brazil but I thought wasn't great on the right.
Sign in if you want to comment
So good or bad window?
Page 1 of 4
posted on 29/8/22
I’m starting to think maybe we go for it and promote Hugill… just as another body to bring on in that position.
You never know, the lad might fly…
posted on 29/8/22
I'll give it an 8 so far.
More importantly I think we have a manager who is a 9.5. Bearing in mind that SAF is the 10.
posted on 29/8/22
Casemiro - world class destroyer to help protect the questionable defensive solidarity
Martinez - a tenacious ball playing CB
Eriksen - a creative spark capable of playing the style ETH expects
Malacia - a highly rated young LB, energetic up and down
Antony - another starter for Brazil, young who appears to have all the tools in his kitbag capable of going on to be a great on the right wing
———————
Cliché and lots of fancy adjectives
posted on 29/8/22
comment by Metro.⚽️ (U6770)
posted 57 seconds ago
Casemiro - world class destroyer to help protect the questionable defensive solidarity
Martinez - a tenacious ball playing CB
Eriksen - a creative spark capable of playing the style ETH expects
Malacia - a highly rated young LB, energetic up and down
Antony - another starter for Brazil, young who appears to have all the tools in his kitbag capable of going on to be a great on the right wing
———————
Cliché and lots of fancy adjectives
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Cliche is cliche for a reason
posted on 29/8/22
Maguire good or sh!t? But ignoring all the reasons why he's sh!t
posted on 29/8/22
All goes to shiiiiit once Varane starts missing 2 out of every 3 games and we have to sit deep to accommodate MacQuire.
posted on 29/8/22
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 1 minute ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So he's started for Brazil
posted on 29/8/22
If the business is over then it’s a 6/10 for me.
De Gea fine as no1 for another year if not ideal, can mix and match in midfield. Still get the feeling United will hand out daft extensions to players that aren’t good enough and then can’t be sold.
RB and CF still needed this window imo but seem to need to move AWB and Ronaldo on first
Would be a 10 if you could get two good players in those positions as replacements and milinkovic-Savic.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by The Post Nearly Man (U1270)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 1 minute ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So he's started for Brazil
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, my comment was on him being a 'starter' for Brazil not whether he has started. Would you like the difference explained to you or do we just draw a line under this one and agree that he's not a starter for Brazil?
posted on 29/8/22
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
posted on 29/8/22
On paper I'd give it a 7/10.
Some of the fees and the evident lack of forward planning would temper that rating if we were to consider those aspects of our business. And of course there's the caveat that we've not seen enough (or any, yet) of these players to make an assessment as to whether they are or will be good signings.
If we can shift Ronaldo & bringing in some CF cover I'd say that's a decent first innings under ETH, market-wise.
Over the next two windows we then need to unearth the next Luka Modric, the next Dani Alves and the next Ederson, all of which should be easy enough for our tip-top scouting & recruiting department.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Researching? I knew he wasn't a starter for Brazil. Would you like me to just state he wasn't a starter or to provide the evidence for it.
Two weird responses to me correcting the OP so far. Any more?
posted on 29/8/22
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe he already knew the amount of starts each current right winger in the Brazil squad have got, off the top of his head.
Seriously though, it’s good to have some obsessive fact checkers on the site. Means I don’t have to look stuff uk myself and also means I don’t re quote something I’ve heard on here and get called out for it at work or in the pub!
posted on 29/8/22
6/10
Neglected too many crucial areas for me.
Antony isn’t a starter for Brazil, to be fair. Though I don’t think they really have that many given how much they seem to rotate.
Will be interesting to see what their squad looks like in Qatar. They’ve got lots of attacking options.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Researching? I knew he wasn't a starter for Brazil. Would you like me to just state he wasn't a starter or to provide the evidence for it.
Two weird responses to me correcting the OP so far. Any more?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The chances of you knowing what you said off the top of your head are next to nil, so yes you went away and researched it so you could try to look smart on the United board, when in reality you look like a pathetic little man who’s never seen a woman topless
posted on 29/8/22
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 29 seconds ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe he already knew the amount of starts each current right winger in the Brazil squad have got, off the top of his head.
Seriously though, it’s good to have some obsessive fact checkers on the site. Means I don’t have to look stuff uk myself and also means I don’t re quote something I’ve heard on here and get called out for it at work or in the pub!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't know the exact number of starts but knew Raphinha had been the starter on the right over the past year and Antony had been coming off the bench around the 70 minute mark over that period. It had actually been a problem position for them for the previous few years, with Coutinho even playing there on occasion, as well as Everton, Gabriel Jesus, Gabriel Barbosa and is it Paqueta(sp?) from Lyon I think, amongst others.
Everytime I watched them play around that period I always thought they could do with a regular right winger which is why Raphinha being the starter there stuck in my mind.
Typical of this website you correct an incorrect statement and then have to explain yourself in how you obtained the correct information.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Researching? I knew he wasn't a starter for Brazil. Would you like me to just state he wasn't a starter or to provide the evidence for it.
Two weird responses to me correcting the OP so far. Any more?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The chances of you knowing what you said off the top of your head are next to nil, so yes you went away and researched it so you could try to look smart on the United board, when in reality you look like a pathetic little man who’s never seen a woman topless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah OK. I have no time for imbeciles, so I'll give you a miss. The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 8 seconds ago
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 29 seconds ago
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 6 minutes ago
Not that it detracts away from your transfer window rating but calling Antony a starter for Brazil? He's played nine games, only two of them starts when Raphinha was injured who whilst only playing nine also has actually been the starter for Brazil on the right for the past year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Imagine being a Liverpool fan and researching the international appearances of the new united signing
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe he already knew the amount of starts each current right winger in the Brazil squad have got, off the top of his head.
Seriously though, it’s good to have some obsessive fact checkers on the site. Means I don’t have to look stuff uk myself and also means I don’t re quote something I’ve heard on here and get called out for it at work or in the pub!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't know the exact number of starts but knew Raphinha had been the starter on the right over the past year and Antony had been coming off the bench around the 70 minute mark over that period. It had actually been a problem position for them for the previous few years, with Coutinho even playing there on occasion, as well as Everton, Gabriel Jesus, Gabriel Barbosa and is it Paqueta(sp?) from Lyon I think, amongst others.
Everytime I watched them play around that period I always thought they could do with a regular right winger which is why Raphinha being the starter there stuck in my mind.
Typical of this website you correct an incorrect statement and then have to explain yourself in how you obtained the correct information.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Overcompensating by basically typing out a match report
Bet you were the guy at school who corrected the teachers for making a mistake on the blackboard, and then rightly got beaten up at lunch
posted on 29/8/22
comment by vidicthelegend VIVA LA REVOLUTION (U8735)
posted 1 minute ago
a pathetic little man who’s never seen a woman topless
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Random or what?
posted on 29/8/22
The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
———
This was written by a Liverpool fan.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 22 seconds ago
The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
———
This was written by a Liverpool fan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, towards a defensive United fan who had a hissyfit when it was pointed out that something was incorrect. Which team I support has not bearing on that.
posted on 29/8/22
comment by There'sOnlyOneRed's (U1721)
posted 15 seconds ago
comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 22 seconds ago
The defensiveness of some little weasels on this site is unbelievable.
———
This was written by a Liverpool fan.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes, towards a defensive United fan who had a hissyfit when it was pointed out that something was incorrect. Which team I support has not bearing on that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Still hitting refresh every 60s and responding to comments though aren’t you
posted on 29/8/22
Poolmyfinger will be crying about people being racist next.
posted on 29/8/22
Bit of useless information and hopefully I don't have to show my workings out for this one to the defensive weasels of the site but just saw on BBC that West Ham have signed Paqueta who I spoke about before. Looked good for Brazil but I thought wasn't great on the right.
Page 1 of 4