Probably change it as I wasn’t thinking

Tom Carroll - 1

Forster - 6
Porro - 7
Romero - 6
Dier - 5
Lenglet - 5
Perisic - 6
PEH - 5
Skipp - 5
Son - 6
Kane - 7
Richy - 7

Kulusevski - 6

Forster 7

Romero 4
Dier 3
Lenglet 6

Porro 5
Skipp 5
Hojbjerg 5
Perisic 5

Richarlison 5
Kane 6
Son 4

Danjuma 4
Kulusevksi 6
Davies 5
Tanganga N/A

Dier 2

The rest 6/7.

Forster 7

Romero 5
Dier 3
Lenglet 5

Porro 7
Skipp 5
Hojbjerg 5
Perisic 7

Richarlison 6
Kane 7
Son 6.5

Forster - 5
Porro - 4
Romero - 6
Dier - 1
Lenglet - 3
Perisic - 7
PEH - 4
Skipp - 4
Son - 6
Kane - 7
Richy - 4

Kulusevski - 5


Mason debut: 7 (good response after HT)

Kulu was good actually, will add him

Mason -

Forster 7

Romero 6.5
Dier 3
Lenglet 7

Porro 6.5
Højbjerg 4
Skipp 7.5
Perisic 6

Richarlison 5
Kane 7
Son 7

Kulusevski 7

I like Masons strategy of ‘Kanes really good at passing and Richy/Son really good at running behind - let’s do that’

Guys, don't know if you're aware but Dier is bogging. Good second half from you though, now please beat the scousers.

Guys, don't know if you're aware but Dier is bogging. Good second half from you though, now please beat the scousers.

If we weren't aware already we are now. Tanks

You’ve got Dier way too high Edin, he’s absolutely atrocious.

Other than that pretty much spot on

Forster - 6.7

Porro - 6.8
Romero - 6.7
Dier - 3.1
Lenglet - 6.5
Perisic - 6.9

PEH - 6.1
Skipp - 7.1

Son - 6.8
Kane - 7.4
Richy - 7.2

Kulu - 6.6

comment by LukaBrasi COYS (U22178)
posted 54 seconds ago
Forster - 6.7

Porro - 6.8
Romero - 6.7
Dier - 3.1
Lenglet - 6.5
Perisic - 6.9

PEH - 6.1
Skipp - 7.1

Son - 6.8
Kane - 7.4
Richy - 7.2

Kulu - 6.6
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I like your ratings! Think you're a little hard on Dier, perhaps because of the missed header?

comment by Del Boy (U22000)
posted 6 minutes ago
You’ve got Dier way too high Edin, he’s absolutely atrocious.

Other than that pretty much spot on
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Judgin by this thread I thought people rated Dier, silly me

Richy is absolutely stealing a living. I’m amazed how many of you fall for the “run abaaaaaat a bit” stuff. He’s bang average. 60 feckin’ million. Jesus!!!!!

He was probably our best player in the first half tbf

comment by JustCallMeTed (U21528)
posted 31 minutes ago
comment by LukaBrasi COYS (U22178)
posted 54 seconds ago
Forster - 6.7

Porro - 6.8
Romero - 6.7
Dier - 3.1
Lenglet - 6.5
Perisic - 6.9

PEH - 6.1
Skipp - 7.1

Son - 6.8
Kane - 7.4
Richy - 7.2

Kulu - 6.6
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I like your ratings! Think you're a little hard on Dier, perhaps because of the missed header?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And for Rashford's goal

Forster - 6.5

Porro - 6.5
Romero - 6
Dier - 4.5
Lenglet - 5.75
Perisic - 6.5

PEH - 5.75
Skipp - 6.5

Son - 7
Kane - 7.5
Richy - 6.25

Kulu - 5.5

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 7 hours, 11 minutes ago
Richy is absolutely stealing a living. I’m amazed how many of you fall for the “run abaaaaaat a bit” stuff. He’s bang average. 60 feckin’ million. Jesus!!!!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I thought he was OK, but he doesn't look like scoring anytime soon. Judge him next season when he gets more game time. I doubt he has had half a dozen starts this season in the Prem. Hard to judge him.

Ryan Mason 7.5 Couldn't really do much with the team or formation but made 4 subs which was refreshing.

Even though I was calling for Son to be subbed he was justified in the end by keeping him on.

I think when he brought Tanganga on he was happy with a point and knowing our defence we could have conceded late on so he banked it.

A good start for him.

Forster 7

Romero 6
Lenglet 6
Dier 4

Perisic 6
Porro 6.5
Skipp 7.5
PEH 6

Richy 7.5
Kane 8
Son 5