The only one i don't agree with is Porro vs White.

It's not a match up they way you've done it but a Saliba & VDV combo would be hard to better.

From a Liverpool fan if i was to pick my 11 from both.

Vicario
Porro Saliba VDV Udogie
Odegard Rice Maddison
Saka Solanke Son

Damn, how have spurs come out 6 to 5? I guess maddison wouldnt make it if the mf is too attacking. VDV over Gabriel was tough, Gabriel is so reliable but VDV is a better player with a higher ceiling imo. So was Vicario over Raya. Could argue for White over Porro defensively but ive said as soon as i saw Porro he was a baller, brilliant watch cant leave him out. Im fully happy with the rest.

7-4 even jasus

A fair comparison, DJ, though I'd say obviously strongest 11s Arsenal probably have 7-4 ish.

I'd rather have Maddison than Havertz as an attacking mid, and Havertz over Solanke as a striker but appreciate your doing it based on the likely lineups at the weekend

i guess i picked on players i pref if i was to do it on consistency/form/reliability it'd swing Arsenals favour massively witth probably only Son and Udogie getting in. Esp considering somehow 4 of my back 5 are Spurs, Arsenal prob had the best def record in recent years and spurs are a shambles at times

Ive picked it purely on my pref not considering formations/managers/tactics/form/consistency etc and it shows.

though I'd say obviously strongest 11s Arsenal probably have 7-4 ish.
=======
Yeah, Rice and Odegaard walk in, and then it is a discussion of Havertz vs Solanke.
By the time of the Emirates fixture left back may be more of a discussion, if either Timber or Calafiori establish themselves.

the spine of arsenal, saliba rice odegaard and saka, make every combined 11 in the league probs. .

Raya

White
VdV
Saliba
Udogie

Rice
Odegaard
Maddison

Saka
Havertz
Son



7-4 exactly! With Solanke and Timber probably the ones who still need to prove themselves.

comment by Chris H (U15205)
posted 3 minutes ago
Raya

White
VdV
Saliba
Udogie

Rice
Odegaard
Maddison

Saka
Havertz
Son



7-4 exactly! With Solanke and Timber probably the ones who still need to prove themselves.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
DJ didnt include Ode cause injury doubts but hes not been ruled out for the NLD yet.

Just mind games by Arteta

He is definitely out

if all fit

Raya
Porro Saliba Gabriel Udogie
Odegaard Rice Maddison
Saka Havertz Son

currently available

Raya
Porro Saliba Gabriel Udogie
Havertz Bentancur Maddison
Saka Son Kulusevski


not including players who havent proved anything for either club yet

i forgot about Bentancur tbf hes a good watch

comment by Chris H (U15205)
posted 20 minutes ago
Raya

White
VdV
Saliba
Udogie

Rice
Odegaard
Maddison

Saka
Havertz
Son



7-4 exactly! With Solanke and Timber probably the ones who still need to prove themselves.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
in a theoretical neutral team for balance i reckon be better off with Porro as an attacking full back with the arsenal cb pairing, Gabriel better in the air than both the spurs two put together

also CBs at full back is woke nonsense

dont care that the two best teams in the league play natural centre backs at full back

Gabriel M is way better than Romero.

Romero is way too overrated in general.

Raya
Porro Romero Saliba Udogie
Sarr Bissouma Maddison
Saka Havertz Son

Gabriel over Romero every day of the week, every week of the month, every month of the year, every year of the decade, every decade of the century etc

"but I don't think anyone would leave Son out of this team whoever he is against."

Can think of one scenario where you wouldn't want him playing, thinking back to when 10 of the 11 Spurs players showed up against Man City but his lack of sporting ethics resulted in him jogging around refusing to play.

Still would of lost 2-1

Nice to know you’re over it though

Pretty fair tbh

comment by Phenom (U20037)
posted 1 hour, 47 minutes ago
Still would of lost 2-1

Nice to know you’re over it though
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You don't know what the result would have been had you been playing with 11 for 90 minutes instead of 10.

Son's a cheating I despised him for his cheating and diving to win penalties against us even before he demonstrated his total lack of professionalism and sporting ethics against City last season.

comment by You Can't Buy Class ¯\_/^v^\_/¯ (U12019)
posted 3 hours, 11 minutes ago
comment by Phenom (U20037)
posted 1 hour, 47 minutes ago
Still would of lost 2-1

Nice to know you’re over it though
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You don't know what the result would have been had you been playing with 11 for 90 minutes instead of 10.

Son's a cheatingI despised him for his cheating and diving to win penalties against us even before he demonstrated his total lack of professionalism and sporting ethics against City last season.
--------

Whining crybaby Arteta mode, activated.

comment by Devonshirespur (U6316)
posted 1 hour, 55 minutes ago
comment by You Can't Buy Class ¯\_/^v^\_/¯ (U12019)
posted 3 hours, 11 minutes ago
comment by Phenom (U20037)
posted 1 hour, 47 minutes ago
Still would of lost 2-1

Nice to know you’re over it though
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You don't know what the result would have been had you been playing with 11 for 90 minutes instead of 10.

Son's a cheatingI despised him for his cheating and diving to win penalties against us even before he demonstrated his total lack of professionalism and sporting ethics against City last season.
--------

Whining crybaby Arteta mode, activated.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nice attempt to deflect away from the truth.

Combined 11 with everyone fit:

Raya
White Gabriel Saliba Udogie
Rice Maddison Odegaard
Saka Solanke Son

Some of the most retaaaaaarded lineups on here.