Get behind the team and players, and shut up, you moaning idiot. Things aren't clicking for him at the mo, but only a few months ago he was our stand out player. Show him some support and he might get back to playing the way most of us know he can. In Luke i trust!

now now children

Luke had a good season at centre half but he has always struggled and looked out of position at right back.

Do us a favour hoon, take your head out of your arsecrack

Kenkent is spot on. Hoons is also correct. Chambers is not a right back, but he is a decent centre back and deserved his PoY last season. Last season though our best CB was Wilson; this season (so far) it is Lynch. We do need a top class CB in my opinion. Someone who will dominate.

Chambers is only playing at RB because Gunter is the best candidate to play RM. SC could of course paly Moloney at RB but I think his policy at the moment is to stick with experience. When McCleary is fit he could play RM, Gunter could play RB, and Chambo and Wes would have to fight it out to play alongside Lynch.

I've been dismayed with Chambers since he became captain. His form has dipped and he's been spouting off about others when he should take some blame himself.

I had thought he and Wes were too similar and preffered him out of the two but have changed my mind since then.

I don't actually agree that he doesn't have the attributes or passion to be captain. However I do think Chambo needs to be dropped from the side for a spell. Simply because right back is NOT his position and Lynch is in better form at the moment. It seems he is being accommodated for recently simply because he is skipper and had a good season last year. This really is never a good idea.

it is sad to say but luke is off his game big time i don't think he should be captain the arm band should be given back to camp he has the passion and the drive to motavate the team even do i'm not a fan of giving the captaincy to a goalkeeper but i don't think anyone else on the team has the passion camp has just my opinion do

Agree with paddy, Chambo has never looked like creating the form he had last year. I think he has rose up the rank of players too quickly and has had the captain's armband thrust upon him. I think he needs a few years to settle down and try and first become the head of defence.
There is no question over whether Camp should be the captain or not as he knows how to organize the back 4 he has a lot of passion and he think he thrives off being captain as everyone looks to him which I think he likes.
Camp should be made captain fact! But we need a vice captain in midfield to keep the forwards attacking players motivated!

I*

"Fact"? I wouldn't say that. Camp, and keepers in general, are vocal, bossy and should be concentrating on organising the defence. I'm not in favour of someone in such a restricted position being captain - how is he going to influence the midfield and strikers short of a rollocking at half-time?

Also, as said the keeper should be helping organise the defence which for us this season has been a shambles! It's sad to say but we look short of captain material. Wes seems to focus on his own job which is fair enough, the other defenders have been woeful. There isn't a midfielder or striker guarenteed to start with the exception of maybe McGugan who I don't think is the right character. It could be worth a go though and may bring out some team ethic in his game? I wouldn't be so sure myself.

HARDTALK