Neither. I would poach Big Sam from West Ham
May I add. Workmate being neutral. Well a Leeds fan anyway.
Rafa, without doubt, he has the proven track record.
Or Steve Kean or AVB? I hear they'll both be available soon.......
Neither. I would poach Big Sam from West Ham
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Big sam is a good manager, but certainly not the sort of manager we should go for,
Benitez for me i think Harry has a tendency to leave clubs in a bit of trouble.
If i could pick one manager out of the list i would chose Capello... i think he would be a great club manager in the Prem.
"he has the proven track record."
Of what? Over achieving and finishing 2nd in the league?
Utterly usless in the league otherwise for years he was there, he had Carragher, Gerrard and Torres all in their prime! Should of achieved more with the money he spent!
Redknapp would be my choice! Benitez is overated.
Benitez without a doubt....he wanted:
D Silva
D Alves
D Villa
K Aguero
imagine if he had fenways money before city and their sheiks.
Rednapp has a history of leaving clubs with massive debt when he has finished.
Benitez without any shadow of a doubt.
Its only the London media brainwashing that see's anyone even consider Redknapp a better manager.
He is about 15 years older, has achieved next to nothing in comparsion and will be going to jail in January anyway.
comment by We Play The Tippy Tappy Football (U8233)
posted 23 minutes ago
Neither. I would poach Big Sam from West Ham
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Big sam is a good manager, but certainly not the sort of manager we should go for,
Are you serious?
Fat Sam shouldnt be allowed anywhere near the home dressing room of our great club
comment by NoNameNoFace (U5606)
posted 36 minutes ago
"he has the proven track record."
Of what? Over achieving and finishing 2nd in the league?
Utterly usless in the league otherwise for years he was there, he had Carragher, Gerrard and Torres all in their prime! Should of achieved more with the money he spent!
Redknapp would be my choice! Benitez is overated.
-----------
What has Redknap achieved? Rafa won la liga, champs league and FAcup.
Your points just confirm that Benitez is the better manager.
Utterly usless in the league otherwise for years he was there, he had Carragher, Gerrard and Torres all in their prime! Should of achieved more with the money he spent!
Redknapp would be my choice! Benitez is overated.
------------
Exactly 100% proving my point. All this 'loveable 'Arry, what a manager!' business in the papers all the time. What exactly has Mr Sky Sports Rent-a-Quote actually ever acheived that could show him to be a better manager than Benitez?
What has Redknap won, in his whole career as a manager?
Is that it?
Dont see how anybody can claim Redknap is a better manager than Benitez.
Simples!!! Neither. JimmyTheRed
Daveunited!
Redknapp>>>>>>>Benitez
-----------------------------------------------------------
Yeah that's evident by all those trophies he has over Rafa, Champions League, Uefa Cup, FA Cup, 2 La Liga titles and World Club Cup. It's quite an impressive haul 'Arry has got......Oh wait, no it's Benitez that has the full trophy cabinet.
I would love Rafa to come back one day. Anyway Harry is going down faster than one of Rooneys lady callers, so he will not be available.
what nutter would honestly have 'arry over Benitez?
Easily Rafa, his taxes are in order
Surprised none of the Spurs fans joined in this... Errr... Debate
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Benitez Vs Redknapp
Page 1 of 1
posted on 30/11/11
Neither. I would poach Big Sam from West Ham
posted on 30/11/11
May I add. Workmate being neutral. Well a Leeds fan anyway.
posted on 30/11/11
Rafa, without doubt, he has the proven track record.
posted on 30/11/11
Or Steve Kean or AVB? I hear they'll both be available soon.......
posted on 30/11/11
Neither. I would poach Big Sam from West Ham
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Big sam is a good manager, but certainly not the sort of manager we should go for,
Benitez for me i think Harry has a tendency to leave clubs in a bit of trouble.
If i could pick one manager out of the list i would chose Capello... i think he would be a great club manager in the Prem.
posted on 30/11/11
"he has the proven track record."
Of what? Over achieving and finishing 2nd in the league?
Utterly usless in the league otherwise for years he was there, he had Carragher, Gerrard and Torres all in their prime! Should of achieved more with the money he spent!
Redknapp would be my choice! Benitez is overated.
posted on 30/11/11
Benitez without a doubt....he wanted:
D Silva
D Alves
D Villa
K Aguero
imagine if he had fenways money before city and their sheiks.
Rednapp has a history of leaving clubs with massive debt when he has finished.
posted on 30/11/11
Benitez without any shadow of a doubt.
Its only the London media brainwashing that see's anyone even consider Redknapp a better manager.
He is about 15 years older, has achieved next to nothing in comparsion and will be going to jail in January anyway.
posted on 30/11/11
comment by We Play The Tippy Tappy Football (U8233)
posted 23 minutes ago
Neither. I would poach Big Sam from West Ham
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Big sam is a good manager, but certainly not the sort of manager we should go for,
Are you serious?
posted on 30/11/11
Fat Sam shouldnt be allowed anywhere near the home dressing room of our great club
posted on 30/11/11
Woy.
posted on 30/11/11
Redknapp>>>>>>>Benitez
posted on 30/11/11
comment by NoNameNoFace (U5606)
posted 36 minutes ago
"he has the proven track record."
Of what? Over achieving and finishing 2nd in the league?
Utterly usless in the league otherwise for years he was there, he had Carragher, Gerrard and Torres all in their prime! Should of achieved more with the money he spent!
Redknapp would be my choice! Benitez is overated.
-----------
What has Redknap achieved? Rafa won la liga, champs league and FAcup.
Your points just confirm that Benitez is the better manager.
posted on 30/11/11
Utterly usless in the league otherwise for years he was there, he had Carragher, Gerrard and Torres all in their prime! Should of achieved more with the money he spent!
Redknapp would be my choice! Benitez is overated.
------------
Exactly 100% proving my point. All this 'loveable 'Arry, what a manager!' business in the papers all the time. What exactly has Mr Sky Sports Rent-a-Quote actually ever acheived that could show him to be a better manager than Benitez?
posted on 30/11/11
What has Redknap won, in his whole career as a manager?
posted on 30/11/11
the Fa Cup
posted on 30/11/11
Is that it?
Dont see how anybody can claim Redknap is a better manager than Benitez.
posted on 30/11/11
Simples!!! Neither. JimmyTheRed
posted on 30/11/11
Daveunited!
Redknapp>>>>>>>Benitez
-----------------------------------------------------------
Yeah that's evident by all those trophies he has over Rafa, Champions League, Uefa Cup, FA Cup, 2 La Liga titles and World Club Cup. It's quite an impressive haul 'Arry has got......Oh wait, no it's Benitez that has the full trophy cabinet.
posted on 30/11/11
I would love Rafa to come back one day. Anyway Harry is going down faster than one of Rooneys lady callers, so he will not be available.
posted on 30/11/11
what nutter would honestly have 'arry over Benitez?
posted on 30/11/11
Easily Rafa, his taxes are in order
posted on 30/11/11
Surprised none of the Spurs fans joined in this... Errr... Debate
Page 1 of 1