1 Brad Jones - 6/6
2 Glen Johnson - 7/8
3 Sanchez Jose Enrique - 7/8
5 Daniel Agger - 8/8
6 Fabio Aurelio - 6/6
7 Luis Suarez - 8/9
8 Steven Gerrard - 9/9
9 Andy Carroll - 6/8
11 Rodriguez Maxi - 7/7
14 Jordan Henderson - 5/8
16 Sebastian Coates - 6/8
18 Dirk Kuyt - 7/7
19 Stewart Downing - 6/7
20 Jay Spearing - 6/7
21 Leiva Lucas - 8/9
22 Danny Wilson - 6/8
23 Jamie Carragher - 6/6
25 Jose Reina - 8/8
26 Charlie Adam - 6/7
31 Raheem Sterling - 5/8
32 Alexander Doni - 6/6
33 Jonjo Shelvey -6/8
34 Martin Kelly - 7/8
35 Conor Coady - 5/8
37 Martin Skrtel - 7/8
38 Jon Flanagan - 6/8
39 Craig Bellamy - 7/7
41 Martin Hansen - 5/6
47 Andre Wisdom - 5/6
49 Jack Robinson - 6/8
Jesus Fernandez Saez - 5/7

1 Brad Jones - 5/5
2 Glen Johnson -7/7
3 Sanchez Jose Enrique - 8/9
5 Daniel Agger - 8/9
6 Fabio Aurelio -6/6
7 Luis Suarez - 8/10 (finishing)
8 Steven Gerrard - 10/10
9 Andy Carroll - 7/9
11 Rodriguez Maxi - 7/7
14 Jordan Henderson - 7/8
16 Sebastian Coates - 7/9
18 Dirk Kuyt - 6/6
19 Stewart Downing - 7/7
20 Jay Spearing - 6/6
21 Leiva Lucas - 9/9
22 Danny Wilson - 6/8
23 Jamie Carragher - 8/8
25 Jose Reina - 9/9
26 Charlie Adam - 7/8
31 Raheem Sterling - 6/9
32 Alexander Doni - 6/6
33 Jonjo Shelvey - 6/6
34 Martin Kelly - 7/8
35 Conor Coady - ?
37 Martin Skrtel - 8/8
38 Jon Flanagan - 7/7
39 Craig Bellamy - 8/8
41 Martin Hansen - ?
47 Andre Wisdom - ?
49 Jack Robinson - 6/8
Jesus Fernandez Saez - ?

I think you are both being harsh on our defenders, they are all 25/26 years old i think and defenders usually hit their prime closer to 30 so their potential should be one or two higher.

I said jose 9 could be. I miss him.

I didn't go for any 10s as I thought it would be too controversial. Only thing I would majorly disagree with there is Carragher's 8.

27 agger and skrtel, still i think 29-31 is when most defenders play their best stuff.

I haven't watched him for a while. I guess you watch him every week so no more than me

I think that the defenders work well as a team but perhaps individually aren't close to world class. Probably 7.5s would be more appropriate.

1 Brad Jones -5/5
2 Glen Johnson -8/9
3 Sanchez Jose Enrique -8/9
5 Daniel Agger -9/9
6 Fabio Aurelio -7/7
7 Luis Suarez -9/10
8 Steven Gerrard -9/9
9 Andy Carroll -6/8
11 Rodriguez Maxi -7/7
14 Jordan Henderson -6/9
16 Sebastian Coates -6/9
18 Dirk Kuyt -7/7
19 Stewart Downing -8/8
20 Jay Spearing -6/6
21 Leiva Lucas -8/9
22 Danny Wilson -5/8
23 Jamie Carragher -7/7
25 Jose Reina -9/9
26 Charlie Adam -7/7
31 Raheem Sterling -5/8
32 Alexander Doni -7/7
33 Jonjo Shelvey -6/8
34 Martin Kelly -6/8
35 Conor Coady -5/8
37 Martin Skrtel -7/7
38 Jon Flanagan -6/7
39 Craig Bellamy -7/7
41 Martin Hansen -4/5
47 Andre Wisdom -5/8
49 Jack Robinson -6/9
Jesus Fernandez Saez -6/7

I will only comment on the ones I have seen enough.

2 Glen Johnson - 6
3 Sanchez Jose Enrique - 8
5 Daniel Agger - 7
6 Fabio Aurelio - 5
7 Luis Suarez -8.5
8 Steven Gerrard -8
9 Andy Carroll -3
11 Rodriguez Maxi -6
14 Jordan Henderson -5.5
18 Dirk Kuyt - 6
19 Stewart Downing - 6.5
21 Leiva Lucas - 7
23 Jamie Carragher -6
25 Jose Reina -8
26 Charlie Adam -6.5
37 Martin Skrtel -8
39 Craig Bellamy -7

1 Brad Jones - 5
2 Glen Johnson - 7
3 Sanchez Jose Enrique - 9
5 Daniel Agger - 7
6 Fabio Aurelio - 5
7 Luis Suarez - 8
8 Steven Gerrard - 8
9 Andy Carroll - 6
11 Rodriguez Maxi - 7
14 Jordan Henderson - 7
16 Sebastian Coates - 6
18 Dirk Kuyt - 7
19 Stewart Downing - 7
20 Jay Spearing - 6
21 Leiva Lucas - 9
22 Danny Wilson - 5
23 Jamie Carragher - 6
25 Jose Reina - 9
26 Charlie Adam - 7
31 Raheem Sterling - 5
32 Alexander Doni - 6
33 Jonjo Shelvey - 6
34 Martin Kelly - 7
35 Conor Coady - 5
37 Martin Skrtel - 8
38 Jon Flanagan - 5
39 Craig Bellamy - 7
41 Martin Hansen - 4
47 Andre Wisdom -5
49 Jack Robinson - 6
Jesus Fernandez Saez - 6

Kelly - 7, 9

Shelvey 6 / 9