Shi(t) I forgot Djemba-Djemba!

Edwards and Law would be in there. Beckham also should get an honourable mention.

OP

Bit of an odd formation, given that United has never played it.

In these kind of line ups I would always have Robbo ahead of Keano. Great player as Keane was, he was not as good as Robbo.

Robbo played in pretty poor United sides and literally carried us for years.

The only time Keano was needed to carry us, he blew his top and left.

Yeah I just couldn't decide between Rio and Stam to be honest and also I wanted to put Ronaldo, Beckham and Best in! Forgot to put Beckham in honorable mentions when I took him out the starting x1!

Schmeichel

Neville
McGrath
Edwards
Evra

Ronaldo
Robson (Capt)
Charlton
Best

Cantona
Law

That's quite good RedBlackandWhiteside

But I would go with this:

Schmeichel

Neville
McGrath
Edwards
Evra

Ronaldo
Robson (Capt)
Charlton
Best

Cantona
Law

RB@W

Much more balance to your team.

I would swap Ronaldo with Best and put Giggs on the left wing. Maybe swap Law with RVN.

thanks for the insight, Lady

Vidicshin
seriously, no Lawman?... agreed RVN was quality...
Are you rewarding Giggs for loyalty or talent over Ronnie?

Are you rewarding Giggs for loyalty or talent over Ronnie?

..................................

For balance.

Best is the greatest player I have ever seen, and his best position was right wing.

Giggs is the best left winger United has ever had.

Best is the greatest player I have ever seen, and his best position was right wing.
****

agreed again but Im trying to accommodate players in that team to get them all in. Like Edwards I have been told was an old style left half ...does that make him a modern day CB or a DMF? Best and Ronaldo would swap over come inside....as they both did when they played for United.

My dad would just say play a team of 11 Edwards.

He would have probably been good in goal.

Where's Gary Birtles,Paddy Roach and Ralph Milne?
They were my favourites

Where's Gary Birtles,Paddy Roach and Ralph Milne?
************
about as good as Paul Power they were

Paul power was ace you heathen

Webb

Wiley
Clattenburg
Winter
Poll

Halsey
Marriner
Attwell
D`urso

Foy
Dowd

Edwards was better than Stam, Rio and Vidic put together, just ask Sir Bobby

Cantona better than Denis Law? Wow it comes to something when even the holy trinity can't take the field together.

Are you rewarding Giggs for loyalty or talent over Ronnie?
##########################################

Would that be Giggs' loyalty to the club or his Missus?

Would that be Giggs' loyalty to the club or his Missus?

......................

Did you think that one up by yourself?

comment by Vidicschin (U3584) posted 2 minutes ago

Would that be Giggs' loyalty to the club or his Missus?

......................

Did you think that one up by yourself?
###################################

Only asking!

Wasn't trying to touch a nerve!

Only asking!

Wasn't trying to touch a nerve!

................

You did not touch a nerve. Don't you think it is a bit "old news" by now and you were being extremely childish?

i dont understand why everyone has Cantona in their united all time 11. Yes he was good but come on hes no where near dennis law or george best. He was only with us for 5 years and you lot put him in all time 11

comment by Vidicschin (U3584) posted 14 minutes ago

Only asking!

Wasn't trying to touch a nerve!

................

You did not touch a nerve. Don't you think it is a bit "old news" by now and you were being extremely childish?
######################################

Old news ?

Surely you realise all us Liverpool fans live in the past.

Fergie fledglings

instead of moaning at other peoples selections put a team up yourself

Is it your year next year?