or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 14 comments are related to an article called:

Player ratings

Page 1 of 1

posted on 5/2/12

Luis slightly at fault for the third?
Slightly? Feck me sideways

posted on 5/2/12

Cech - 7

Ivan - 7.5
Cahill - 6.5
Luiz - 8
Bosingwa - 6

Meireles - 6.5
Essien - 7

Sturridge - 6
Mata - 7
Malouda - 5

Torres - 6.5

posted on 5/2/12

As a neutral.

Cech 6
Ivanovic 6
Luiz 5
Cahill 5
Bosingwa 6

Essien 5
Malouda 2
Mata 8
Meireles 6

Torres 7
Sturridge 7

posted on 5/2/12

I'm not sure it was Cahill who lost Hernandez. Luiz has to take the blame, but it is the first time these two havelayed together as a partnership, so it was always going to be tough for them.

Thought Cahill looks a really good signing actually.

posted on 5/2/12

why so harsh on Bosingwa

comment by CSTP (U1453)

posted on 5/2/12

Malouda was absolutely shocking all game

doesn't deserve more than 3
at most

posted on 5/2/12

I think torres' open goal miss against Man U haunts him and he tries to get into the easiest positions possible before shooting to be sure of himself

posted on 5/2/12

Cech - 7.5 - Made good saves

Ivanovic - 8 - who is ashely young ?
Luiz - 7.5 - Defended well for majority & attacked well
Cahill -6.8 - Not the worst debut
Bosignwa - 7 played good at lb

Essien - 7 - Nothing spectucalar good tacklign
Merieles - 7.5 - 1 of his best games
Malouda - 2 - glimpses
Mata - 8.5 - BOSS
Sturridge - 6.8- Great work for the first, bit selfish, AVB vexed at him for not tracking back and giving away the penalty.

Torres - 7 - Linked up well, Good touch and passing , Great assist, didn't take his only chance of the day.

posted on 5/2/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 5/2/12

Cech 7
Ivanovic 7.5 M.o.M
Cahill 6.5
Luiz 6.5
Bosingwa 6.5
Essien 7
Meireles 7
Sturridge 6
Mata 7.5
Malouda 4
Torres 6

posted on 5/2/12

You lot are far too generous with your ratings.

3-0 nil to chelsea after 50mins was the most flattering scoreline in PL history.

Mata was absolute pure CLASS for you I totally agree but the rest were mediocre for me.

We had a much better grip of the game in midfield and deserved at least a point from that match.

posted on 5/2/12

3-0 was flattering but Chelsea is not usually a team to throw away that kind of lead so we shot ourselves in foot here.
Other than Brana, Luiz and Essien I think rest were ok. Mata scored one and created one but on other few occasions he made poor decisions.

posted on 5/2/12

Agreed Mata was just poor first half and ok second

posted on 5/2/12

Ivan immense game today he gets 9 + MOTM from me.

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment