or to join or start a new Discussion

16 Comments
Article Rating 5 Stars

We can replace him

Robin Van Persie was a fantastic striker for us, the best in the league in my opinion. He had a good goal record even before this season, and of course he was our saviour many times last season with his ability to produce a goal out of nothing, see Liverpool away and Everton at home for more. There are very few strikers on the planet who have the quality to put away that kind of chance, no matter the quality of the pass from Song.

We can't replace Van Persie's technical ability either. In my opinion Van Persie is 2nd only to Ibrahimovic technically out of all the strikers in European football.

BUT - RvP isn't the brilliant, untouchable finisher some people think he is. He misses plenty of chances, and often at crucial moments. Yes he has the quality to score goals no-one else can, but in Giroud and Podolski we have two proven quality finishers who together can equal or even surpass RvP's goal tally last season. Giroud may not have the touch and control of RvP, but he is an excellent poacher with better goalscoring instinct and far more aerial ability than Robin. Podolski meanwhile adds more pace and dynamism than the Dutchman, and has a similarly lethal left foot.

We can also replace his leadership - Van Persie was a decent captain who helped us pull through a difficult period - but he was hardly a great one. Like Cesc, he led by example, and the other players looked up to him, but the best captains are the ones that continue to cajole the best from the players around them while they themselves aren't on form, and I get the impression that RvP isn't a natural leader in the same way as Vermaelen. Also his attitude, on reflection, took quite a steep nose-dive at the end of the season. His work-rate deteriorated, and a captain should lead by example off as well as on the ball, he didn't do that.

The article by his close friend, representing the problem facing RvP, stated that Ramsey and Gervinho were not good enough, and this was probably somehow implied by Van Persie. Whether you agree with him or not, it is not for a captain to decide which players are worthy of him or not, and it was at that moment when I think his demeanour changed from being flushed with confidence due to his excellent form to downright arrogance, proved today as he showed that he thinks he is bigger than the club.

I say accept anything around 20 million, we won't get anymore thanks to Robin's thoughtful and sensitive gesture to the fans, telling the whole world that he wants to leave putting us in a horrendous position. Then we should go out and splash it on a top CAM, as well as doing our utmost to keep Theo. I would go for the Brazilian Hernanes of Lazio. Given better service and work rate from the central midfielders I'm confident that we can improve on last season's goal tally even without RvP.

Finally another upside I can see is that we won't have a star player anymore, no-one who can become arrogant and buy into the 'one-man team' bs, no-one who has the demeanour of carrying the team on his shoulders, no-one who wants out. We can start with a fresh slate, 11 hungry, good quality players who will give their all, a more cohesive unit with goals spread around the team and a stronger bench to boot.

So, Farewell Robin, thanks for everything, and good riddance.

posted on 4/7/12

We surely MUST now invest in a top striker - our squad is weaker than last year if RVP goes. Even if he stays, how good will he be?

RVP and Benny out, Podolski and Giroud in.

RVP has thrown the situation into the light at last, and Wenger and Gazidis cannot get away with any excuses now - if we fail to stregthen then we know they are not ambitious.

comment by 8bit (U2653)

posted on 4/7/12

great article Mert

posted on 4/7/12

If RvP stays then he's on the bench as 2nd choice behind Giroud, simple as that. However with all that's been said, with him not telling Wenger or the club before making the statement, with him lying in the statement about Gazidis being on holiday, I can't see how he can stay at the club. Wenger isn't Mancini, he doesn't stand for his players disrespecting him or club, he cares too much about it.

posted on 4/7/12

And yes, If RvP does go, I think we need to sign another striker, but not necessarily a 25 million job, just a good back-up, unless a world-class striker is made available to us e.g. Higuain. If he goes to City then I think we should try to get Dzeko in return.

posted on 4/7/12

with him lying in the statement about Gazidis being on holiday
-----------------------------------

what? How do you know this?! Perhaps Gazidis' henchman is lying.

Whatever, the accusation clearly gives away a distaste for Gazidis which is felt also by many fans. He is as slippery as they come - not to be trusted.

posted on 4/7/12

RVP will definitely be sold imo. Imagine how much pressure there would be on him if he ever put on an Arsenal shirt again. Every misplaced pass, bad touch, missed opportunity etc will pee the fans off.

posted on 4/7/12

So disappointed in him. I was almost 100% sure he would stay.

posted on 4/7/12

what? How do you know this?! Perhaps Gazidis' henchman is lying.

Whatever, the accusation clearly gives away a distaste for Gazidis which is felt also by many fans. He is as slippery as they come - not to be trusted.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

It's been widely reported. Also I'm not sure this is Gazidis' fault, if RvP has any qualms about ambition, then he should go to Stan Kroenke or Wenger, depending on who doesn't want to spend. All Gazidis does is negotiate.

posted on 4/7/12

RVP will definitely be sold imo. Imagine how much pressure there would be on him if he ever put on an Arsenal shirt again. Every misplaced pass, bad touch, missed opportunity etc will pee the fans off.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

It would be like that at first, but if he started to do well, then the fans might forgive, him, just like United fans forgave Rooney; we have enough fickle plastics to achieve a similar effect.

Still think we should definitely cash in though.

posted on 4/7/12

RVP will definitely be sold imo. Imagine how much pressure there would be on him if he ever put on an Arsenal shirt again. Every misplaced pass, bad touch, missed opportunity etc will pee the fans off.

So disappointed in him. I was almost 100% sure he would stay.

Kamran Agree and think too that we have to sell him now. I am also disappointed and never thought he would leave because of family and loyality reasons. But you know life will go on. Thank god the transfer period leaves us enough time to rebuild our club.

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 5 from 3 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available