All in all

TOOR

United have had a fair bit go against them this season.

Today's decisions evened themselves out.

Although I cant wait until these decisions start evening up over the season.

___

Brilliant, you watch every united game I presume?
we are only top because of the refs

I'm talking about Liverpool. I don't care about United at the moment. When we get close to you then I'll start caring.

Greg


To be fair Hernandes goal against Chelsea was offside in another big game.

http://www.debatabledecisions.com/english-premier-league-tables

I thought Webb got everything spot on other than a couple of corners.

Good match, good reffing, If anyone deserved 3 points it would have been United but I think a draw would have been just as fair.

I'm in a good mood.

Seeing Sturridge come on and Suarez relieved of his unnatural role as centreforward was great. And Borini looked good.

Have to agree. Few silly decisions from Webb like free-kick to United when Valencia fouled Johnson first and a couple of corners. Unfortunate assistant decision or non-decision for their second but he'd have to have had some eyes to spot that.

The better team won. Full marks to the manager, making the decision to take Lucas off. Borini para ears hungry. Yes, 24 points behind the Mancs hurts, may it inspire the team to play better. JimmyTheRed

"erm, yes it was, Evra heads the ball forward onto Vidic who is standing in an offside position.

That's generally offside isn't it"

I've looked at the video and am now looking at a still photo.

He is clearly NOT offside.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-At6g7pLGw

At 0:35 you can draw a line the camera, Vidic, the ball and Evra. And at that angle, this mean he is on side. (If he was offside, at this angle, he would have to be in front of Evra.

If the camera was to move to the left many yards, you would see that Evra was in front.

Here's another at 0:49 seconds:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OnNDqr0I6-M

Clearly onside.

looks offside to me

tight though