Pick a team 2005/2011

i disagree, strauss is the better captain, based on his results.

cook
vaughan
trott
pietersen (05)
bell (11)
prior
flintoff
bresnan/broad
swann
jones
anderson

Strauss,
Cook,
Trott,
KP,
Bell,
Prior,
Taylor,
Bresnan,
Broad,
Swann,
Andersen.

How anyone can go without Bresnan is beyond me. 9 games 9 wins. Outstanding bowling average in 23 and batting average of 40. Top player and can still get better.

I totally agree kash, they all seem to be preferring to stick in that clown Flintoff.

My greatest cricketing prediction ever was that England would be the best test team in the world once he was finished, and I said that when he had about 4 years to play, so had to be very patient, and HEY PRESTO???

Coincidence? I don't think so.
Bresnan is already a much better player than him. Bresnan has a World Cup winners medal in his pocket. Bresnan wins everytime he plays. He is a serious cricketer who probably won't fall off a pedalo, drunk as a lord DURING THE WORLD CUP CRICKET FINALS. Some of us fans care, you see.

presumably the guy who picked taylor was joking ?

Trescothick
Strauss
Trott
Vaughan(c)
Pietersen
Flintoff
Prior
Broad
Swann
Jones
Anderson
Aquilani yah?

PickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickelsPickels




Yah.

Don't agree with those who pick Vaughan as captain but still pick Strauss instead of Cook.

If the captaincy is stripped-out of the equation Tresco / Cook is better than Strauss / Tresco.

Tresco can be attacking, Cook is the 'rock'.

Also without Cook many of the batting line-ups mentioned above have only Trott as a 'defensive' batsmen. In the good times they would be delicious to watch, but there may be too many collapses for comfort as well.

Assuming all in their 'prime' I'd go for

Tresco
Cook
Trott
KP
Bell
Prior
Flintoff
Broad
Swann
Anderson
Jones

trescothic
Vaughn capt.
trott
KP
Bell
Flintoff
Prior
Harmison
hoggard
Swann
anderson