Top 10 welterweights

cheers man

Having the last word makes you right

When judging rankings, calling fights and so on, I couldn't care less about a fighter's personality. How charismatic or eye catching they are, or how annoying and arrogant, doesn't come in to it. It's all about experience, records, and results. That is where you and I differ, and is the source of your misunderstanding as to my reasoning for choosing Mayweather as number one at welterweight.

"I am not bothered about the Pac fight anymore"
============
are you kidding me? I think now more than ever would be perfect for it.. I give Pac and moneyweather maybe 12 more months to get it signed or never again. It would be epic..
. They've still got it also

stop talking out of your backside. I judge fighters based on what they do in the ring.

you probably try to do the same, but you're too much of a simpleton to come across as credible

Rober - I stopped caring about that fight a couple of years back. It won't happen now and even if it does, it wouldn't be anywhere as meaningful for either guy. Back when they both had so much momentum, especially Manny when he was on that streak coming up through the weights and brutalizing everyone, that's when it meant something. A win for either of them would have been career defining. It would have been the highest grossing fight in history. They both facked about, and now that window has passed.

Kam, no one cares about how well you understand boxing. What do you want a medal or something? For laying down your infinite boxing wisdom gleaned from a year spent in your bedroom, in your mum's house, vigorously watching boxing videos on youtube?

What would a Floyd/Manny fight actually show us now.

If Floyd wins, the Floyd fanboys scream that he beat the best Pac ever while the Manny fans state that Manny's a shell of his former self and it means nothing.

If Manny wins, exactly the same for each set of fans except Floyd fans shout to the Maidana fight and claim he's lost his legs.

While it still means something in terms of some people want to see it, to me it's a nothing fight that will do nothing to stop the arguments.

Calm down SLS, simply pointing out how flawed your logic is

Flawed how?

I've already explained that.

both may and pac are in VG condition rite now.... get er done