Cheeky SAF nudges Carrick during Interview

He's better than Anderson and djembax2

They should build a statue of Carrick at OT.

http://www1.skysports.com/watch/video/sports/football/9774598/sir-alex-pays-tribute-to-mackay
SAF tribute to Mackay.

Robb

Considering Phil Neville and Butt were here for similar or less really shows how good Carrick has been. An the trophies we won when he's been her eclipse that of any other era. Amazing.

VC - I'd say Keane and Scholes ahead. But I'd say he's on par with Ince. Loved Ince as well. More than Keane when both were at the club. But Keane really flourished once Ince left. Another Fergie Jedi-masterstroke getting rid of Ince Hughes and Kanchelskis. Keeping that net spend down.

The others you mentioned VC I simply haven't seen enough of them. However I've heard many people champion Charlton, of course, and Robson. Saw a few matches with Robbo, but not enough really; and I was a kid. And I know Crerand won the 2 big trophies with us.

Were Muhren and McIlroy better than mighty MC?

I always found Nicky Butt very underrated

Carrick is a club great and he's one of the players I've always believed in.

I remember defending him so much on the old 606 it almost became the only subject I posted about.

What I love about Carrick is that at his worst he's one of the best holding players you could wish for from a defensive perspective.

At his best you can add that he has a great passing range and picks out brilliant forward passes.

Shinji

Carricks game is very similar to Muhrens, and to be fair we got him in his later years. But Arnold was still just that class above.

Sammy Mccllroy was one of our most under rated players form that era. Probably because he had to live under the shadow of another certain Northern Irishman.

Ah got you. I'll have to search out some Muhren clips.

I do remember watching a video of a very young McIlroy scoring some goals. but I think you've hit the nail with the GB comment

vidicschin you must be at least in your 30's if not 40's.

comment by Posh Mufc Great Hafi Not Arrogant Just Better (U6578)
posted 1 hour, 25 minutes ago
vidicschin you must be at least in your 30's if not 40's.
----------------------------------------------------------------------