Rate ETHs signings out of 10

I’d give them all a 10

comment by Sir William of Prunier (U22256)
posted 17 seconds ago
you first.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Ahhh. Tha ks, but he didn't sign me.

Onana - 1 (currently)
Martinez - 7 (better than average but not elite)
Malacia - 4 (average young player)
Casemiro - 7 (made United a lot better at first, faded)
Mount - 3 (not performed yet)
Amrabat - 6 (I think he will be useful)
Antony - 3 (One dimensional and a wife beater)
Hojlund - 8 (Impressive start)

Onana is no more than a 1. Shocking signing so far.
Antony 1

So far

Onana - 2. Offering very little in the build up and a disaster at being a keeper. David Raya was available for cheaper.

Martinez - 7.5. Very good for most of last season. Hopefully the injury hasn’t ruined him.

Malacia - 5. Cheap, squad player. Probably not good enough despite initial promise.

Casemiro - 6. Improved us last season despite being slightly overrated at times imo. Paying that money and those wages for a 30 year old was crazy though. Madrid knew what they were doing.

Mount - 5. Not great but far from our worst player this season.

Amrabat - 7. He’s looked good/decent in the 3 games so far.

Antony - 6. Not as bad as some try to make out but underwhelming for his fee.

Hojlund - 8. Has impressed. Should have went to PSG or waited for another move for his own sake.

Onana is probably the worst keeper I've seen at United.

Casimero, Martinez & Amrabat. Lucky to have them.

Mount: waste of 50 odd mil regardless.

Antony, half a trick pony. 5hit effin player.

Malacia's one I like the look of. Gotta work on his end product.

Rasmus, is looking promising.

I feel for Eth cos I'm sure he simply says who he wants and the terrible negotiations means United pay way over market, creating expectation on the player and boss.

If Antony cowt the 40-50mill other teams were quoted and performed hot n cold it isn't as much if a problem. Buy him for stupid money and people question the bosses decision. Kinda harsh. Now do that on 9/10 signings and boom....a poison chalice.

comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 32 minutes ago
So far

Onana - 2. Offering very little in the build up and a disaster at being a keeper. David Raya was available for cheaper.

Martinez - 7.5. Very good for most of last season. Hopefully the injury hasn’t ruined him.

Malacia - 5. Cheap, squad player. Probably not good enough despite initial promise.

Casemiro - 6. Improved us last season despite being slightly overrated at times imo. Paying that money and those wages for a 30 year old was crazy though. Madrid knew what they were doing.

Mount - 5. Not great but far from our worst player this season.

Amrabat - 7. He’s looked good/decent in the 3 games so far.

Antony - 6. Not as bad as some try to make out but underwhelming for his fee.

Hojlund - 8. Has impressed. Should have went to PSG or waited for another move for his own sake.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Raya was the one I wanted at the time. Though I did think Onana would be better than he has been, he couldn't really have been much worse

* Onana - No real idea yet, but coco was was a defensive units nightmare for 10 years. If he is worse than Barthez and coco then I don't want the club to waste so many years replacing him like it did with those two.

* Martinez - hugely over-rated by those that don't understand what defending entails, yet he is still currently only one of three that can be considered in that position - and the other two never get a look in anyway ...

* Malacia - still too early, but i wouldn't have chosen him to come to this club in the first place. Shaw is 3 times the defender he is

* Casemiro - here for the pension fund. He was okay mincing about in an inferior league, clueless in this one. He knows it as well

* Mount - I've always admired his contribution. Good chance he'll be a significant and important player to a good squad. Unfortunately we may not get the chance to see that before he gets fed up waiting for that to happen, gives up and goes elsewhere. A real missed opportunity

* Amrabat - who know at this stage

* Antony - ditto

* Hjojlund - I've seen a lot of (too many) "false dawns" but his credentials are good

In 10 years which player has joined us and become a superstar? None.