or to join or start a new Discussion

13 Comments
Article Rating 3 Stars

Gaitan and Garcia

Just saw redmancunia's tweet about these 2 almost certainly joining United this summer.

Can't say I'd be happy because I haven't seen them play so was wondering if anyone here has?

posted on 2/2/12

Out of the the 2 I would rather have Garcia, he looks pretty good, however Gaitan looks quite greedy.

posted on 2/2/12

cant understand this thing about gaiten, there must be so many better proper Centre mf's out there, BTW Pogba looked decent against stoke

comment by Hodgey (U1271)

posted on 2/2/12

Which Garcia is this? Raúl? Luis?!

posted on 2/2/12

Javi isnt it

posted on 2/2/12

Javi garcia is ok, all round midfielder, good positioning, a bit selfish in front of the box. Takes to many pops at goals.

Gaitain only hilites ive seen, looks like a poor mans silva with a good shot. Sadly he wont cost as small as sikva did.

comment by EM (U4638)

posted on 2/2/12

the guy isn't reliable, he's a Uni student with no football sources at all.

comment by EM (U4638)

posted on 2/2/12

^^ to the comment above, I have nothing against the guy, but he is just talking about rumours from other peoples rumours. As in he's getting information from rumour mills from journos and other countries. I know this because I actually know the person in question. Having said that I would welcome the move but it's all rubbish.

posted on 2/2/12

Was chatting to my Benfica mates before I heard about this.... the talk in the Portuguese press was that no deal had been done, but we have some kind of first refusal in place on Javi Garcia.

Not sure why, maybe influence from Queiroz or Mendes?

comment by RRK (U6141)

posted on 2/2/12

Captain Phil Jones (U4638)

I forgot to mention he got the info from someone else.

"Gonçalo Lopes, a journo for Diário de Notícias, says that both Javi Garcia and Nicolas Gaitan are almost certain to join #MUFC in summer."

comment by MMaaxx (U9506)

posted on 2/2/12

They're both really good, especially Garcia who is a hard tackling defensive midfielder with true technical ability like most Spanish midfielders these days. Very consistent. Don't know how the one comment about him being selfish etc came from, he is a true team player. He's also a bug guy so physically up for the premier too.

Gaitan is almost the opposite type of player but also really good and exciting. I'd rate both above carrick.

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 3 from 2 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available