or to join or start a new Discussion

11 Comments
Article Rating 5 Stars

Carragher needs to retire!

As soon as i realised agger wasnt in the starting line up i had a bad feeling any defensive errors or conceeded goals would be down to carragher.

carragher is such a liability these days. ever since the stoke defeat where a poor player like walters gave him a torrid time, i knew it was game over for him.

yesterday's conceeded goals were really bread & butter for any half decent centre back. POOR man marking escpecially for the first goal. should have won that game easily!

carragher is a legend but, im afraid to say we need to buy 1 more centre back and he needs to move on.

posted on 4/3/12

Coates,Wilson and Kelly are all CB's, you not see any of them good enough to step up?

I think we should have more confidence in them than we have shown, perfect time to bring them through, but we have loaned out Wilson which is a shame.

comment by Marslfc (U8595)

posted on 4/3/12

im not convinced by wilson and the one or two times i saw kelly at centre back, he was awful. maybe we should have signed cahill ...

posted on 4/3/12

Agreed, I thought it would have been mentioned on "Match of the Day", but it wasn't.

comment by TomD (U13392)

posted on 4/3/12

I've said it for a while now - he no longer has the pace.
He spends half his time wrestling the attackers coz he can't keep up with them.
He was the main culprit in yesterdays defeat and he should step down while we can still find good memories about him.
Kenny has been brave putting him on the bench but like LFC!!! says, when I saw him with the captains armband on I thought we were going to have a tough game.
It's too tough a league to carry him and at his age he's not going to improve as time goes by.

posted on 4/3/12

What an immense player Hyypiä was, when he left Carra was in deep trouble, legend but, imo Coates is already better. He's a Copa winner and Uruguay international, he just needs to get a run of games, he's steel

posted on 4/3/12

Truetored......Hyypia

wow this man was top class

posted on 4/3/12

On reflection, and we are all wiser after the event, it was a mistake for JamieC to play, especially against a consistently top club like Arsenal. I fully agree that Coates should be given his chance, I still rate Wilson, and Flannaghan inspires. JamieC? Not even on the bench again, ever. JimmyTheRed

posted on 4/3/12

Fully agree OP, although it pains me to say it, love Carra but he just isn't up to it anymore. Oh and Cahill is a liability!!

posted on 4/3/12

Comment Deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 5/3/12

Someone needs to let Carra know that the fat lady is singing............i don't think he will go willingly, i believe that he will be greedy and try to squeeze another 1 year contract, he wont think for the good of the club...........wait and see.

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 5 from 8 votes

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available