or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 157 comments are related to an article called:

prem team of season

Page 1 of 7

posted on 25/3/12

Vorm
Walker Evans Kompany Enrique
Valencia Carrick Yaya Silva
Rooney RVP

For me, might just me being bias but hey, there you go

posted on 25/3/12

Özils team is spot on but I'll replace Vorm with Hart, he's the reason why City have the best defence in the league

posted on 25/3/12

hart

richards evans kompany enrique

cabaye yaya britton

rooney aguero

van persie

posted on 25/3/12

Krul
Richards Evans Kompany Enrique
Valencia Carrick Yaya Silva
Rooney RVP

posted on 25/3/12

Yeah hart is definitely worth a place. Wouldn't actually put Valencia in there. He's been awesome, no doubt. But he just hasn't played enough games to feature in a team of the season for me.

posted on 25/3/12

hart overrated
walker overrated

posted on 25/3/12

he has played 18 times, dont make excuses

posted on 25/3/12

Krul
Richards Colo Kompany Baines
Valencia Yaya Modric Silva
Ba RVP

posted on 25/3/12

how can ba be ahead of rooney, just because he was a free transfer doesnt make him better. rooney has got more goals and assists and is all round the better player than ba and rvp by far

posted on 25/3/12

Its a difficult one, Valencia and Carrick only been back in team since about Jan but have any others performed all season in there places. Probably agree with Evans as since the City mauling he has been excellent but can't make mind up on Rooney.

posted on 25/3/12

Vorm
Ivanovic Koscielny Evans BAE
Carrick Cabaye
Valencia Silva Mata
Van Persie

posted on 25/3/12

saint has lost his mind

ivanovic no where near richards and cabaye and mata are no where near the best in their respectable positions

posted on 25/3/12

Ba shouldn't be in the team at all, if he had cost £30mil he wouldn't be in the team so just because he was free doesn't make him better, if anything we should be praising Pardew for getting him for free.

posted on 25/3/12

I am a united fan. Not making excuses. Valencia has only played about half of our total minutes in the premier league this season (if that). Doesn't warrant a place in the team of the season, in spite of his brilliance, for me.

posted on 25/3/12

And yeah, Ba shouldn't be in there.

posted on 25/3/12

Mata been easily chelsea's best player but same position as Silva so probably a no. Are we now saying that just because spurs had a bad month none of their midfield should be included?

posted on 25/3/12

What has Ba's price got to do with anything? He's one of the top scorers in the premier league playing for a 'lesser side'. No idea how Evans is in most of the teams. How many games has he played?

posted on 25/3/12

comment by merrysupersteve (U1132)


im sorry but thats just stupid, he has played enough games to be in their.

posted on 25/3/12

Evans has been in the team since August and Carrick has played since November

posted on 25/3/12

evans has played 22 out of 29 so shut up and it doesnt matter as long as they have played at least 15 games

posted on 25/3/12

Nan Bread i aint scared of you bro

posted on 25/3/12

ivanovic no where near richards
___________________________

Ivanovic has been consistently great this season. Richards has been good this season and you could make a case of him being ahead of Ivanovic but no way has he been miles better like you've insinuated.

and cabaye and mata are no where near the best in their respectable positions
__________________________

Name me two players who have been far better than those two. Cabaye who has guided Newcastle to 6th place this season and Juan Mata who has the third highest assist this season in the PL.

posted on 25/3/12

couple of you have evans. mental. sure he has been better for you this year than the past but still. 10 cb's atleast better than him

posted on 25/3/12

why two then only one player needs to be miles better than him

posted on 25/3/12

Mats definitely worth a shout as well, it's hard deciding between him and Silva. I'd love Mata at United, he's quality

Page 1 of 7

Sign in if you want to comment