Brad - 8
Gallas - 6
Kaboul - 9 BLOCKED EVERYTHING
Walker - 7
BAE - 6 - Sloppy play all round from Benny
VDV - 7.5
Modric - 8
Parker - 7
Bale - 9
Sandro - 7
Ade - 7.5
Gallas - 6
Kaboul - 9
----
RRP have you hit your head?
reverse those two and you are closer to the truth...
actually to be fair Kaboul did make some awesome blocks towards the end that i have forgotten about .. i will up it to 7.5
Kaboul was far superior to Gallas yesterday even though he had a solid game overall...Kaboul got forward and defended brilliantly, cant ask more really
Brad - 8
Gallas - 6.5
Kaboul - 8
Walker - 7
BAE - 6
VDV - 8
Modric - 8
Parker - 6.5
Bale - 9
Sandro - 7
Ade - 7.5
edin is another one watching the game with his eyes closed
honestly lads i am not being funny but gallas was majestic yesterday... he ran the show at the back....
kaboul probably got headlines cos of his spectacular blocks... but he really did go walkabout a lot ! more than usual....
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
You see how out of place Gallas was at one point? Cant remember who but if the Swansea player went down it would have been a pen.
Also there was another point where, yes he made an impressive last gasp tackle, but still was at fault for not playing the line.
Kabouls blocks were very good, he saved at least 2 goals I reckon. Yes he did ruin the back 4 shape a bit, but so did billy.
You see how out of place Gallas was at one point? Cant remember who but if the Swansea player went down it would have been a pen.
-----
i remember this well. it was at the other end to me so didnt have the best view... however i remember saying at the time.. that thank god that was gallas chasing back not kaboul.. if it was kaboul he would 100% have tripped him up or charged into the back of him lol
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Gallas had his arms allover the feller and if anything the Swansea kid was naive (and noble) not to go down.
Fair enough if you were there Chronic....you see more of the work not shown by cameras so I'll bow to your superior knowledge. I guess Kaboul seemed more involved for us tele viewers yesterday.
-------
galv.. i promise you, whilst kaboul played well.. imo he was out of position so often that if swansea had been a more direct team, instead of happy to knock it around in midfield, then they would have been in quite a few times....
overall though at the moment kaboul and gallas is undoubtedly our best partnership.
ledley
Kaboul was at fault for our goal IMO. Just like when Ashley Young scored, it took him far too long to react and close him down!
Lennon should get a 10 An assist, 100% pass completion, 100% successful dribbles
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Brad 8 - for the save alone
=====================
I dont think he deserves an 8 for just one save. Isn't "saving" his job?
He did enough to put it onto the post, but i think most keepers would have got that.
Fridel = 7.
chicken and friedel are not buddies
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Brad - 8
Gallas - 7.5
Kaboul - 7.5
Walker - 7
BAE - 7
VDV - 8
Modric - 7
Parker - 6
Bale - 7.5
Sandro - 7
Ade - 8
Not buying this bale hype yes he was good mainly near the end when they was tiring though!
Lennon gets a mention to for his assist can't wait until he learns to cross though as everyone seems to say he can't yet!
Chronic,
Friedel is fine, as long as we dont allow him to have much to do.
I dont think we realise how good our defence actually is. How many times has he had to keep us in a game this season?
The only stand-out game was Fulham away. Although i'll give him credit for that, i think most of them saves were more luck than judgement.
I hate to say it, but i'd rather Robert Green than Friedel. And if West Ham dont go up, he's a free agent too. Coincidence? ...who knows?
I hate to say it, but i'd rather Robert Green than Friedel.
---
Chicken our defence ain't that good and friedel has made some outstanding saves this season and to say Robert green is better is just silly!
honestly lads i am not being funny but gallas was majestic yesterday... he ran the show at the back....
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Even tho he was totally mugged once and came so near to giving away a penalty it was unreal ?
as i have said earlier... i was sat completely the opposite end for that...so was far away... and it didnt look as bad as it apparantly was from him..... have not seen a replay...
have not seen a replay
----------------------------------------------
Take my advice, dont watch a replay if you do you will have to knock Gallas's mark down to about 6.5.
Lets be honest about both him and King, they are past it, their legs have gone.
Yes they will do ok in certain games nad their experience will make them look good players at times against average teams. Unfortunately as the woolwich and chelsea away games proved both of them under pressure are simply not good enough anymore.
Such a shame as well Ledley is one step away from being a god at WHL
Sign in if you want to comment
Ratings for yesterday
Page 1 of 3
posted on 2/4/12
Brad - 8
Gallas - 6
Kaboul - 9 BLOCKED EVERYTHING
Walker - 7
BAE - 6 - Sloppy play all round from Benny
VDV - 7.5
Modric - 8
Parker - 7
Bale - 9
Sandro - 7
Ade - 7.5
posted on 2/4/12
Gallas - 6
Kaboul - 9
----
RRP have you hit your head?
reverse those two and you are closer to the truth...
actually to be fair Kaboul did make some awesome blocks towards the end that i have forgotten about .. i will up it to 7.5
posted on 2/4/12
Kaboul was far superior to Gallas yesterday even though he had a solid game overall...Kaboul got forward and defended brilliantly, cant ask more really
posted on 2/4/12
Brad - 8
Gallas - 6.5
Kaboul - 8
Walker - 7
BAE - 6
VDV - 8
Modric - 8
Parker - 6.5
Bale - 9
Sandro - 7
Ade - 7.5
posted on 2/4/12
edin is another one watching the game with his eyes closed
honestly lads i am not being funny but gallas was majestic yesterday... he ran the show at the back....
kaboul probably got headlines cos of his spectacular blocks... but he really did go walkabout a lot ! more than usual....
posted on 2/4/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/4/12
You see how out of place Gallas was at one point? Cant remember who but if the Swansea player went down it would have been a pen.
Also there was another point where, yes he made an impressive last gasp tackle, but still was at fault for not playing the line.
Kabouls blocks were very good, he saved at least 2 goals I reckon. Yes he did ruin the back 4 shape a bit, but so did billy.
posted on 2/4/12
You see how out of place Gallas was at one point? Cant remember who but if the Swansea player went down it would have been a pen.
-----
i remember this well. it was at the other end to me so didnt have the best view... however i remember saying at the time.. that thank god that was gallas chasing back not kaboul.. if it was kaboul he would 100% have tripped him up or charged into the back of him lol
posted on 2/4/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/4/12
Gallas had his arms allover the feller and if anything the Swansea kid was naive (and noble) not to go down.
posted on 2/4/12
Fair enough if you were there Chronic....you see more of the work not shown by cameras so I'll bow to your superior knowledge. I guess Kaboul seemed more involved for us tele viewers yesterday.
-------
galv.. i promise you, whilst kaboul played well.. imo he was out of position so often that if swansea had been a more direct team, instead of happy to knock it around in midfield, then they would have been in quite a few times....
overall though at the moment kaboul and gallas is undoubtedly our best partnership.
ledley
posted on 2/4/12
Kaboul was at fault for our goal IMO. Just like when Ashley Young scored, it took him far too long to react and close him down!
Lennon should get a 10 An assist, 100% pass completion, 100% successful dribbles
posted on 2/4/12
azza
posted on 2/4/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/4/12
Brad 8 - for the save alone
=====================
I dont think he deserves an 8 for just one save. Isn't "saving" his job?
He did enough to put it onto the post, but i think most keepers would have got that.
Fridel = 7.
posted on 2/4/12
chicken and friedel are not buddies
posted on 2/4/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/4/12
Brad - 8
Gallas - 7.5
Kaboul - 7.5
Walker - 7
BAE - 7
VDV - 8
Modric - 7
Parker - 6
Bale - 7.5
Sandro - 7
Ade - 8
Not buying this bale hype yes he was good mainly near the end when they was tiring though!
Lennon gets a mention to for his assist can't wait until he learns to cross though as everyone seems to say he can't yet!
posted on 2/4/12
azza
posted on 2/4/12
Chronic,
Friedel is fine, as long as we dont allow him to have much to do.
I dont think we realise how good our defence actually is. How many times has he had to keep us in a game this season?
The only stand-out game was Fulham away. Although i'll give him credit for that, i think most of them saves were more luck than judgement.
I hate to say it, but i'd rather Robert Green than Friedel. And if West Ham dont go up, he's a free agent too. Coincidence? ...who knows?
posted on 2/4/12
I hate to say it, but i'd rather Robert Green than Friedel.
---
posted on 2/4/12
Chicken our defence ain't that good and friedel has made some outstanding saves this season and to say Robert green is better is just silly!
posted on 2/4/12
honestly lads i am not being funny but gallas was majestic yesterday... he ran the show at the back....
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Even tho he was totally mugged once and came so near to giving away a penalty it was unreal ?
posted on 2/4/12
as i have said earlier... i was sat completely the opposite end for that...so was far away... and it didnt look as bad as it apparantly was from him..... have not seen a replay...
posted on 2/4/12
have not seen a replay
----------------------------------------------
Take my advice, dont watch a replay if you do you will have to knock Gallas's mark down to about 6.5.
Lets be honest about both him and King, they are past it, their legs have gone.
Yes they will do ok in certain games nad their experience will make them look good players at times against average teams. Unfortunately as the woolwich and chelsea away games proved both of them under pressure are simply not good enough anymore.
Such a shame as well Ledley is one step away from being a god at WHL
Page 1 of 3