or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 40 comments are related to an article called:

They can all go... Apart from Jack

Page 2 of 2

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 3/7/11

He played very very well that day, tottenham couldnt get near him, and on several occasions wilshere cut open your defence with his skill and passing.

----------

behave yourself lad.

comment by Eboue (U3815)

posted on 3/7/11

"behave yourself lad."

clearly you have no argument

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 3/7/11

my argument was put forward earlier on...... i am not going to change my mind because some random gooner happens to disagree with me.

posted on 3/7/11

To be fair, Wilshere is overrated. We have better talents in Ramsey and Miyaichi. He's still very good though. Adams was never Nesta, but he was still one of the very best.

comment by Eboue (U3815)

posted on 3/7/11

"my argument was put forward earlier on"

No, all you put forward was an opinion that you have nothing to back up with.

"We have better talents in Ramsey and Miyaichi"

Ramsey is not as good as wilshere, and miyaichi is nowhere even close to wilshere. Wilshere isnt overrated, he is overhyped because hes english, which means people talk about him more than they would if he was foreign, his ability however is not overrated. I dont like using links but this as far as im concerned is conclusive evidence that he is a top class talent

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JBMzrm2mV0I

Not a surprise the one person critisising in the videos comments is a spud

posted on 3/7/11

I was talking about talent. Ramsey has had a major setback but is by far the more promising midfielder. Miyaichi is extremely talented.

comment by Eboue (U3815)

posted on 3/7/11

I disagree, wilshere has far more talent in my opinion. Ramsey is a better goal scorer, but thats it. Wilsheres touch, passing, and skill is far superior. Miyaichi is not even as talented as wellington silva let alone wilshere

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 3/7/11

"my argument was put forward earlier on"

No, all you put forward was an opinion that you have nothing to back up with.

---------

ok i will try and make this as simple for you to understand as possible..... judging by your clear awkwardness/lack of intelligence this may not be easy.

I put forward my OPINION that wilshere is an overated player. i then backed up my opinion by saying that i have seen him play live twice (probably twice more than most on this forum who praise him not stop).

You chose to ignore the NLD last season, in which he was thoroughly outclassed, but fine, lets focus on the Bolton game, which you decided to pick. I said that I came away from the game thinking he was a dirty player who did nothing to stand out whatsoever.

So my ARGUMENT is, that I have seen nothing either live or on tv to show me that he is anything other than a good player, who is seriously overhyped. This ARGUMENT is the basis on which I drew my conclusion.. which happens to be my OPINION - that he is completely overhyped because he is young and English.

comment by Eboue (U3815)

posted on 3/7/11

Im sorry you took time and effort to make such a comprehensive comment, seeing as all it did was prove your limited understanding. I though you knew our disagreement was about you claiming wilshere did not play well against you for bolton, im not interested in your arguments about whether or not hes overrated, i disproved your assesment that wilshere had no influence in that game and you have no argument against it.

posted on 3/7/11

Wilshere's passing is certainly not up to Ramsey's standard. Ramsey is one of the few players who have Fabregas' vision. He is a better leader and his positional sense is fantastic.

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 3/7/11

i disproved your assesment that wilshere had no influence in that game and you have no argument against it.

----------

you didnt disprove anything. your opinion is different to mine. Whether or not someone plays well is subjective. There is no proof that can be given either way.

comment by Eboue (U3815)

posted on 3/7/11

Well at last your right about something, but at least i have some evidence to support my claim. As well as the linked article i gave, owen coyle also called him the best player on the pitch. It hardly seems he had no influence on the game

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 3/7/11

his own manager called him the best player on the pitch..... great evidence that.

comment by Eboue (U3815)

posted on 3/7/11

yeah, it does sound like the type of thing you'd say if your player had no influence on the game

my sarcasm > your sarcasm

posted on 3/7/11

Chronic_McPoof

One has only to watch Wilshere to know that he is going to be a great player.

You might have seen him have an off day, I have seen him tire late in games, but there is no doubting his footballing talent. It was the same with Cesc.

If you took your spud tinted glasses off for once you might be able to appreciate his talent, but then you just might not have any understanding of the game of football.

Page 2 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment