Ox probably shouldn't be there.
RVP should easily win the senior award.
Aguero for young player.
comment by JohnJensensGoal (U6334)
posted 1 minute ago
"where is Valencia"
Spain.
----------------------------------
Ginge, that Joke was done on an earlier post. Late again!
"Can someone tell me why the Ox is there? Don't get me wrong, very exciting prospect but he's hardly started alot of games has he? And why isn't Evans or Carrick there? This is crap"
He's there because Gary Neville loves him. Same with Bale and Walker.
I think anybody with a single functioning brain cell will decided RVP should win the senior award
So you're expecting him to get 100% of the votes then?
I dn't like the fact they consider age 24 for young player some players playing since age of 17-18 in first team for top clubs....6 years of experience and still called young pathetic..that age limit should be 21
"So you're expecting him to get 100% of the votes then?"
You are assuming that I think all footballers have functioning brain cells.
IMO It should be:
Player of the year: Van Persie, Aguero, Mata, Carrick, Koscielny, Kompany
Young player of the year: Krul, Walker, Szczesny, Bale, Hoillett, Mclean
I've never taken the PFA's seriously since Giggs won the award. Or Bale winning last season. Just a host a star-struck lower league players voting their favourite players on FIFA.
FECKING OXLADE-CHAIMBERLAIN??? This is why the voting shouldn't be done in January.
He's there because Gary Neville loves him. Same with Bale and Walker.
Hows that when Neville's 2 cbs of the year Colo and Kompany aren't anywhere near the list?
Rooney & Bale should be nowhere near that list.
What about Carroll?
And Young Player of the Year shouldn't be awarded to anyone over 21.
"Hows that when Neville's 2 cbs of the year Colo and Kompany aren't anywhere near the list?"
Tbh I didn't even know that but G.Nev creams himself over AOC, Bale and Walker all the time and the people watching the games he analyses or commentates on start agreeing with him.
By the way I am not having a go at G.Nev, I'm just saying that to the players, his opinion in football is a very important one. It is the same thing that won Rooney the PFA Player of the Year award over Drogba in 09/10 despite the latter being far better. Andy Gray creaming himself whenever the ball came in contact with Rooney's head won him at least 50% of votes alone.
Batmanu
I think it's not only football, it's done like that in all walks of life. No many people bother to think before voting
My lists:
Ba, Silva, Carrick, RVP, Kompany, Mata.
Allen, McLean, Krul, Chesney, Walker, Sturridge.
RVP
Aguero
And for flops of the year:
Downing
Taarabt
OX is in as he is English, pure and simple...i love the kid and being a gooner love the fact he is on the list, but it is stupid due to his limited game time...somone mentioned Demba was not good since African nations...if thats the reason why are Spurs players in the list? they have been relegation form since the new year.
RVP
Aguero
And for flops of the year:
Downing
Taarabt
Surely Carroll and Torres also make that list
Sturridge: 24 apps, 10 goals
Welbeck: 28 apps, 8 goals.
Welbeck makes the short-list.
if thats the reason why are Spurs players in the list? they have been relegation form since the new year.
-------------
Because you can still play well and be on a team that is otherwise poor.
Look at RVP at Arsenal.
Andy Gray creaming
himself whenever the ball came
in contact with Rooney's head
won him at least 50% of votes
alone.
---------
I still chuckle whenever I remember that season. Drogba scored more, assisted FAR more and fired his team to a domestic double. It wasn't just the fact Rooney won the awards but the fact it was a landslide and virtually unanimous.
The media were absurd about Rooney that season and actually put him on the same pedestal with Messi and ahead of Ronaldo mid-season because of a series of headers and tap-ins and the whole country were brainwashed by the rabid hype. It was just incredible.
Sign in if you want to comment
PFA Player or the Year Shortlist
Page 3 of 6
6
posted on 16/4/12
Ox probably shouldn't be there.
RVP should easily win the senior award.
Aguero for young player.
posted on 16/4/12
comment by JohnJensensGoal (U6334)
posted 1 minute ago
"where is Valencia"
Spain.
----------------------------------
Ginge, that Joke was done on an earlier post. Late again!
posted on 16/4/12
"Can someone tell me why the Ox is there? Don't get me wrong, very exciting prospect but he's hardly started alot of games has he? And why isn't Evans or Carrick there? This is crap"
He's there because Gary Neville loves him. Same with Bale and Walker.
posted on 16/4/12
I think anybody with a single functioning brain cell will decided RVP should win the senior award
So you're expecting him to get 100% of the votes then?
posted on 16/4/12
I dn't like the fact they consider age 24 for young player some players playing since age of 17-18 in first team for top clubs....6 years of experience and still called young pathetic..that age limit should be 21
posted on 16/4/12
RVP
Sergio
posted on 16/4/12
"So you're expecting him to get 100% of the votes then?"
You are assuming that I think all footballers have functioning brain cells.
posted on 16/4/12
IMO It should be:
Player of the year: Van Persie, Aguero, Mata, Carrick, Koscielny, Kompany
Young player of the year: Krul, Walker, Szczesny, Bale, Hoillett, Mclean
posted on 16/4/12
I've never taken the PFA's seriously since Giggs won the award. Or Bale winning last season. Just a host a star-struck lower league players voting their favourite players on FIFA.
posted on 16/4/12
FECKING OXLADE-CHAIMBERLAIN??? This is why the voting shouldn't be done in January.
posted on 16/4/12
Parker
posted on 16/4/12
He's there because Gary Neville loves him. Same with Bale and Walker.
Hows that when Neville's 2 cbs of the year Colo and Kompany aren't anywhere near the list?
posted on 16/4/12
Rooney & Bale should be nowhere near that list.
What about Carroll?
posted on 16/4/12
Kompany????????
posted on 16/4/12
And Young Player of the Year shouldn't be awarded to anyone over 21.
posted on 16/4/12
"Hows that when Neville's 2 cbs of the year Colo and Kompany aren't anywhere near the list?"
Tbh I didn't even know that but G.Nev creams himself over AOC, Bale and Walker all the time and the people watching the games he analyses or commentates on start agreeing with him.
By the way I am not having a go at G.Nev, I'm just saying that to the players, his opinion in football is a very important one. It is the same thing that won Rooney the PFA Player of the Year award over Drogba in 09/10 despite the latter being far better. Andy Gray creaming himself whenever the ball came in contact with Rooney's head won him at least 50% of votes alone.
posted on 16/4/12
Batmanu
I think it's not only football, it's done like that in all walks of life. No many people bother to think before voting
posted on 16/4/12
RVP
Aguero
posted on 16/4/12
My lists:
Ba, Silva, Carrick, RVP, Kompany, Mata.
Allen, McLean, Krul, Chesney, Walker, Sturridge.
posted on 16/4/12
RVP
Aguero
And for flops of the year:
Downing
Taarabt
posted on 16/4/12
OX is in as he is English, pure and simple...i love the kid and being a gooner love the fact he is on the list, but it is stupid due to his limited game time...somone mentioned Demba was not good since African nations...if thats the reason why are Spurs players in the list? they have been relegation form since the new year.
posted on 16/4/12
RVP
Aguero
And for flops of the year:
Downing
Taarabt
Surely Carroll and Torres also make that list
posted on 16/4/12
Sturridge: 24 apps, 10 goals
Welbeck: 28 apps, 8 goals.
Welbeck makes the short-list.
posted on 16/4/12
if thats the reason why are Spurs players in the list? they have been relegation form since the new year.
-------------
Because you can still play well and be on a team that is otherwise poor.
Look at RVP at Arsenal.
posted on 16/4/12
Andy Gray creaming
himself whenever the ball came
in contact with Rooney's head
won him at least 50% of votes
alone.
---------
I still chuckle whenever I remember that season. Drogba scored more, assisted FAR more and fired his team to a domestic double. It wasn't just the fact Rooney won the awards but the fact it was a landslide and virtually unanimous.
The media were absurd about Rooney that season and actually put him on the same pedestal with Messi and ahead of Ronaldo mid-season because of a series of headers and tap-ins and the whole country were brainwashed by the rabid hype. It was just incredible.
Page 3 of 6
6