or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 65 comments are related to an article called:

Would we accept Scholes & £20m for Modric

Page 1 of 3

posted on 16/5/12

Scholes leave United for Spurs? Okay then

posted on 16/5/12

Yes! A player that's played for one club his whole footballing life. Retired, then come back out of retirement and agree's to play on for 12 months more. Is really going to agree to be packed off 200 miles away at the age of 36/37!

Great article!

posted on 16/5/12

Scholes doesn't get a lot of red cards. And he'll never leave United. Only Fergie could convince him to keep playing.

posted on 16/5/12

no no no no no no no no no no

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 16/5/12

scholes? lol.


still a good player but hes about to retire in a year

posted on 16/5/12

Yes! A player that's played for one club his whole footballing life. Retired, then come back out of retirement and agree's to play on for 12 months more. Is really going to agree to be packed off 200 miles away at the age of 36/37!
----------------------------------------------------------------

posted on 16/5/12

Was only asking for your thoughts lads. Is the current Scholes good enough to do a shift in midfield for us (or too good for us still)? He scores and shoots on target much more than Modric, and still manages to pull the midfield strings. It could give us a big lot of cash to spend on a striker which is what we desperatelyneed along with a centre back (or two...)

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 16/5/12

spurm have you been smoking some mrijuana?

posted on 16/5/12

I still think Scholes who came out of retirement is a better player than Fat Frank

posted on 16/5/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 16/5/12

No not smoking, but since Luka's head seems to have been turned again and could force his way out, I wouldn't want to sell him to a Top 6 team without getting some sort of like for like player back. I know Scholes only ahs a year left, but he could assist us next season as well as getting a 20m striker in. If we can find the next Croatian Modric or the next best thing through our scouting, I would consider taking Scholes and cashing in on a player who doesn't want to play for us and scores 3 a season

posted on 16/5/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 16/5/12

first off, as superb as scholes is why would we want a 38 year old? don't we have enough old crocks in our team. Even if this deal was ever going to be realistic ( which it is not) then it would be more like 50 million plus Scholes. We rejected the c havs 40 million offer so now Modric is worth 50 million

posted on 16/5/12

I still think Scholes who came out of retirement is a better player than Fat Frank
--------------------------------------

He's still better than Modric as well.

posted on 16/5/12

Maybe I have had too much


comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 16/5/12

spurm own up lad. if you are not smoking you have been getting boozy.

posted on 16/5/12

Even if this deal was ever going to be realistic ( which it is not) then it would be more like 50 million plus Scholes. We rejected the c havs 40 million offer so now Modric is worth 50 million
---------------------------------------

posted on 16/5/12

Ok, Scholes & 35million and I would personally drive Luka to Old Trafford. I know Scholes is old, but do we really want another pre-season and start of season last last one where Luka's head was all over the place and affecting the whole squad? A decent 38 year old in midfield is better than a turned head who refuses to play or an expensive bench warmer......

posted on 16/5/12

HA HA, I was at hospital yesterday and they took a lot of my blood.....maybe that is why I am thinking rubbish today?

posted on 16/5/12

your having a laugh.. scholes is 37

posted on 16/5/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 16/5/12

posted on 16/5/12

Even if this deal was ever going to be realistic ( which it is not) then it would be more like 50 million plus Scholes. We rejected the c havs 40 million offer so now Modric is worth 50 million
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
With comments like that,you should have your own show with Pudsey

Modric = 25m absolute max!

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 16/5/12

mthierry what a mug you are

posted on 16/5/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment