or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 1310 comments are related to an article called:

FA Premier League - Newcastle Utd

Page 25 of 53

posted on 4/6/12

Ronaldo?
------
Pretty much the same if I'm being honest, I probably overpaid to get him, and now I have him and messi on the same team, it would be a shame for me to not play 1 match with them both together

posted on 4/6/12

TBH, If I were you, I wouldn't let any of them leave, but I need a world class player. You shouldn't of given away Aguero + Silva + Chiellini, that was a mug, those plaers are worth £110m combined.
----------
They weren't players I needed though, the only one of those that would get into my team now is silva, so I was happy to sell them for Ronaldo and enough cash to get Lavezzi I think it was in

And frankly messi and Ronaldo are a cut above any other player in the world

I will offer you Thiago + Agger + Welbeck + Nani?

Or £48m cash?
----------
No thanks, I wouldn't play any of those 4 and miles off what I would consider

posted on 4/6/12

Thiago + Agger + Welbeck + Nani + Cavani + Walker?

OR

£82m cash?
------
Still a no, I'd only play cav out of those lot and i only need a few more players to get good cover in every position, so I dont need squad players

posted on 4/6/12

posted 55 seconds ago
I have to back out, your asking too much

£82m is £17m more than what you payed for Messi, but Never mind
--------
Best transfer I made, and I could get back a lot more than I paid for him, just wait until hodgey draws him up an injury

posted on 4/6/12

posted 19 seconds ago
If you ever Consider selling Messi, Give him over for £100m
-------
I wouldn't ever sell him for cash as the foreign options are getting slimmer and slimmer

posted on 4/6/12

Like I said before, I can't see a deal, the only guys that would get into my team are ozil, and you could make a case for Reus (but I'm looking to bring in a naturally right sided player at some point today) and cavani would be the replacement, and those 2 aren't enough

posted on 4/6/12

Ballotelli and Flanagan
For
Kronos and kelly

posted on 4/6/12

Sorry, Kroos is not for sale, just going out on loan to get valuable experience from Welshy's Dutch team. And Kelly is essential Back-up.
------
Fair enough, I saw your convo with welshy and should point out that you can't recall loans in the first 4 weeks

What would it take to prize Lavezzi away?
-------
I'd need a replacement + a good chunk of cash or a 2:2 deal where I improve on my starting xi elsewhere

posted on 4/6/12

posted 1 minute ago
Mascherano, Nani, Walker, Alaba, Cavani (4-4-2), Muller (4-4-2) would all walk into your team.
---------
Mascherano, not really, looks to have been converted to a cb, and I like my players to play consistently in their position, nanis not a player I rate, walker and alaba , and a 442 with Ronaldo on the wing would be too unbalanced, so no to cavani, and ade would play ahead of muller, who's not really a striker

BTW, Why do you want Kroos so much?
-------
I'm after a deeper playing playmaker in the Krooos or wilshere type so I can have a bit of versatility in my formation

posted on 4/6/12

Pfffttt, Muller >>>>>>>>>>Adebayor.

On Kroos, You should try your best to get Alonso, then your team would be unstoppable

posted on 4/6/12

Yeah he's really not, ade is a very good striker with a good scoring record last season, muller is better as a winger or a number 10 role

posted on 4/6/12

Well can't argue with you there, But I'd much rather have a quality, versatile, 22 year old, then a 27/28 year old misfit
-----------
Yeah but when I have messi, Ronaldo, Lavezzi, Nasri, ballotelli, Milner, as well as Hoilett and tello(before you say, i know they are both inferior) who are all versatile and play the same positions as muller, it's better for me to have a proven target man and lone striker who has a proven record of the lone striker role as my backup striker

posted on 4/6/12

posted on 4/6/12

Do you have an offer for Lavezzi as I'm about to go and want to tie up all the loose ends

posted on 4/6/12

Welbeck + Thiago?
------
Nah thanks then, no point losing a starter for a sub and a squad player

posted on 4/6/12

Leave it then

posted on 4/6/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 5/6/12

walker+welbeck
=
ivanovic+marin

enq

posted on 5/6/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Hodgey (U1271)

posted on 5/6/12

Mascherano + Walker
for
Riise + Busquets?

Busquets > Mascherano and you don't even need Walker anymore.

posted on 5/6/12

lavezzi, flanagan and ballotelli
for
walker, reus and wellbeck

posted on 5/6/12

How much cash would you want for Wellbeck?

comment by Hodgey (U1271)

posted on 5/6/12

How come? Busquets > Mascherano I'd say.

posted on 5/6/12

No thanks sorry. Would weaken my first XI, as I was interested in Wellbeck for backup.

And as I was just saying to Hodgey, want to keep Schwein

posted on 5/6/12

Could have possibly raised £8/9m but not £13m sorry.

Page 25 of 53

Sign in if you want to comment