or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 18 comments are related to an article called:

All-Time French Premier League XI

Page 1 of 1

posted on 26/6/12

Blanc? Le Boeuf?

comment by Teebs (U1060)

posted on 26/6/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 26/6/12

Where's Pierre Boulerongie?

posted on 26/6/12

Blanc over Gallas.

posted on 26/6/12

Makelele and Vieira > Petit.

Maybe Lebouf in that defence, is he better than Gallas?

Still a great team!

posted on 26/6/12

Anelka was a very good player. But unfortunately for him Henry and Cantona were two of the Premier League's greatest.

posted on 26/6/12

I chose Makelele just ahead of Petit, Petit was fantastic but Makelele really defined the holding midfield role, even though I hate Chelsea Makelele is one of my personal favourite midfielders.

I forgot Blanc he would get in ahead of Gallas.

comment by Teebs (U1060)

posted on 26/6/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 26/6/12

------------ Lama ------------------

Chimbonda ------- Squillaci ------- Cygan ------ Pamarot

Le Tallec ------- Cheyrou ------- Sinama-Pongolle ------- Obertan

-------- Marlet -------- Bellion


posted on 26/6/12

Urgh, I meant to put Sinama-Pongolle upfront in a 4-3-3...

My team is ruined!!

posted on 26/6/12

Petit

posted on 26/6/12

Good team from the OP.

Chuck in Saha and Blanc for Henry and Gallas and you've got yourself a deal.

posted on 26/6/12

Giroud is a minger

posted on 26/6/12

Super Steve Marlet

posted on 26/6/12

Swap Vieira, Makelele & Cantona for Garde, Grimandi & Samassi Abou and you're about right OP

posted on 26/6/12

I appreciate everyone has a right to their own opinion, but surely Gallas should get in ahead of Blanc.

Blanc was one of the best defenders of his generation, but he was 36 when he started playing in the Premiership. I think most would argue that his time in England was the nadir of his career.

Gallas, on the other hand, as much as I dislike his attitude, was one of the best defenders in the Premiership for nearly a decade.

I'd argue Koscielny has a better claim to a place than Blanc.

posted on 26/6/12

DaStu

Gallas is one of the best defenders I've seen play the game. In terms of PL years, Gallas should be ahead of Desailly too.

posted on 26/6/12

You're missing World Cup and European championship winners Youri Djorkaeff and Sylvain Wiltord!

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment