Forster wants to play for Celtic, another few years with us and he'll be 26/27 perfect time to go back to the EPL and prove how good he is
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
dave
what about when our club were messing him about last pre season?
I heard the £4m figure as well, far too low imho. I do hope we get him though.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Dave
he set a clean sheet record in his 1st season, the fact of the matter is people only started accepting him after he saved the pen against Hearts
You cant really blame ANY player for thinking twice about staying in scottish football at this particular time.The game up here is now at an all time low and will only get worse with the demise of the cheats!!The quality in our game is just not there!! The last hoops player I really enjoyed watching and rated was Nakamura!!!!
He's had two years to decide whether he wants to commit to playing up here. Having stalled since the season ended in the hope of a better offer from down South
==================================
Same could be said that we have had 2 years to offer him a contract.
12 months ago we looked elsewhere then got him back on loan, in January we put talks off until the end of the season.
Whats to say we haven't moved the goalposts again in some way?
I'd prefer him to stay as I can't see who else we could possibly get in of a decent quality.
I would allow a £6m release fee but that only kicks in after 2 years so we get 2 full seasons guarenteed before he has the option to leave should a club bid £6m.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
I doubt very much if he'd guarantee staying for two years.Our game is in a mess because of the Rangers situation, he may want to go earlier
==========================
Game was in a mess before the Rangers situation, hardly think that will sway his decision.
He will want to leave to play against the best players he can and to get England recognition.
At the moment he will be number 1 at Celtic, he wont be at EPL clubs - he will be seen as a cheap backup who will have to cease his chance if first choice keeper gets injured.
Hopefully we get CL football & he can prove himself to be a more than capable young keeper which will get him his move.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
He's a decent keeper, no more, no less IMO. There SHOULD be plenty of other options out there for £2m. Look at Swansea last season, signing Vorm (for £1m, I think?) ... standout keeper, and FAR better than Forster. Yes, they were heading for the Prem, but surely we can play the "stepping stone to the Prem" card again?
I've nothing against Forster trying to get the best deal for himself ... I'd do the same. Just not convinced he REALLY wants to be up here, and that's not a great starting point for any Celtic player IMO. As for his chances of England recognition? Aye, right. Hart is England No.1 for the next decade, barring injury, so I wouldn't be basing my career moves on that premise.
============================
I agree he is nowhere near Hart, and if Jack Butland continues he will be the one challenging Hart IMO but beyond that there are few keepers in England who actually want to play for England!!
He's a good keeper, very young for his position too and if you compare the last few games of the season to his first few when he first arrived you can see how much he has developed.
I am struggling to name somebody we could realistically afford to get to be honest who would be anywhere near Forsters level.
Boruc will be on a fair whack & is wanting to play at the top level...............Celtic & the SPL will be his fallback option if nothing comes up from Spain or England......then France, Holland.....etc.
Gordon is a liability. We may as well play Zaluska as he will play more games than Gordon.
Other than that your looking at a loan from an EPL side - Arsenal seem to have plenty of keepers, Fabianski perhaps? We scouted him when Boruc first hinted at moving.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Forster - Minimum Release Fee?
Page 1 of 1
posted on 27/6/12
Forster wants to play for Celtic, another few years with us and he'll be 26/27 perfect time to go back to the EPL and prove how good he is
posted on 27/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 27/6/12
dave
what about when our club were messing him about last pre season?
posted on 27/6/12
I heard the £4m figure as well, far too low imho. I do hope we get him though.
posted on 27/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 27/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 27/6/12
Dave
he set a clean sheet record in his 1st season, the fact of the matter is people only started accepting him after he saved the pen against Hearts
posted on 27/6/12
You cant really blame ANY player for thinking twice about staying in scottish football at this particular time.The game up here is now at an all time low and will only get worse with the demise of the cheats!!The quality in our game is just not there!! The last hoops player I really enjoyed watching and rated was Nakamura!!!!
posted on 27/6/12
He's had two years to decide whether he wants to commit to playing up here. Having stalled since the season ended in the hope of a better offer from down South
==================================
Same could be said that we have had 2 years to offer him a contract.
12 months ago we looked elsewhere then got him back on loan, in January we put talks off until the end of the season.
Whats to say we haven't moved the goalposts again in some way?
I'd prefer him to stay as I can't see who else we could possibly get in of a decent quality.
I would allow a £6m release fee but that only kicks in after 2 years so we get 2 full seasons guarenteed before he has the option to leave should a club bid £6m.
posted on 27/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 27/6/12
I doubt very much if he'd guarantee staying for two years.Our game is in a mess because of the Rangers situation, he may want to go earlier
==========================
Game was in a mess before the Rangers situation, hardly think that will sway his decision.
He will want to leave to play against the best players he can and to get England recognition.
At the moment he will be number 1 at Celtic, he wont be at EPL clubs - he will be seen as a cheap backup who will have to cease his chance if first choice keeper gets injured.
Hopefully we get CL football & he can prove himself to be a more than capable young keeper which will get him his move.
posted on 27/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 27/6/12
He's a decent keeper, no more, no less IMO. There SHOULD be plenty of other options out there for £2m. Look at Swansea last season, signing Vorm (for £1m, I think?) ... standout keeper, and FAR better than Forster. Yes, they were heading for the Prem, but surely we can play the "stepping stone to the Prem" card again?
I've nothing against Forster trying to get the best deal for himself ... I'd do the same. Just not convinced he REALLY wants to be up here, and that's not a great starting point for any Celtic player IMO. As for his chances of England recognition? Aye, right. Hart is England No.1 for the next decade, barring injury, so I wouldn't be basing my career moves on that premise.
============================
I agree he is nowhere near Hart, and if Jack Butland continues he will be the one challenging Hart IMO but beyond that there are few keepers in England who actually want to play for England!!
He's a good keeper, very young for his position too and if you compare the last few games of the season to his first few when he first arrived you can see how much he has developed.
I am struggling to name somebody we could realistically afford to get to be honest who would be anywhere near Forsters level.
Boruc will be on a fair whack & is wanting to play at the top level...............Celtic & the SPL will be his fallback option if nothing comes up from Spain or England......then France, Holland.....etc.
Gordon is a liability. We may as well play Zaluska as he will play more games than Gordon.
Other than that your looking at a loan from an EPL side - Arsenal seem to have plenty of keepers, Fabianski perhaps? We scouted him when Boruc first hinted at moving.
posted on 27/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 27/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 28/6/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Page 1 of 1