or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 11 comments are related to an article called:

Yesterday was a good day for us………..

Page 1 of 1

posted on 16/8/12

try paragraphs, i nearly fell asleep an 1/8th of a way down the first chunk

just a thought

posted on 16/8/12

---------------------De Gea-----------
Rafael----Ferdinand----Vidic-----Evra
--------------Carrick---Anderson----------
----Nani-----------Rooney------Kagawa---
-----------------------RVP-----------------------

Are you telling me that XI doesnt look strong? CM is the relative weakness yes, but it's hardly alot weaker than Ramires/Lamaprd/Merieles/Mikel now it is

posted on 16/8/12

Smalling Jones
I agree.

posted on 16/8/12

No paragraphs = I won't read it.

posted on 16/8/12

WAAAAH NO PARAGRAPHS

Get over it, it's not that difficult.

posted on 16/8/12

Looks alright smalling, Andersons, Rafael and Evra are all poor though. If i was Man U i'd go for this ( Still think you need a left back and right back though )

De Gea
Rafael Vidic Ferdinand Evra
------------------Carrick
Nani----------------------------------Valencia
------------------Kagawa

Rooney-------------------------Van Persie

posted on 16/8/12

Or Valencia at RB and then Young for Valencia

posted on 16/8/12

--------------De Gea
Smalling-Vidic-Ferdinand-Evra
----------Carrick--Scholes----------
Nani-------------------------Kagawa
---------------Rooney------------------
------------------RVP-------------------

If everyone was fit, that's what my strongest team would be.

Heard Valencia might be converted to RB, any truth in that?

posted on 16/8/12

Seen Valencia play at right back before his good there, better than Rafael.

Man U should buy Baines and a new CB someone like Hummels or Colocconi and there defence would be quality if vidic comes back as he was pre-injury.

De Gea
Valencia-Vidic-Colocconi/Hummels-Baines
------------------Carrick
Nani-----------------------------Valencia
------------------Kagawa
Rooney--------------------------- RVP

Would be a quality team

posted on 16/8/12

Definitely need someone to challenge Evra.

posted on 16/8/12

Smalling_Jones - Are you telling me that XI doesnt look strong? CM is the relative weakness yes, but it's hardly alot weaker than Ramires/Lamaprd/Merieles/Mikel now it is

-----------------------------------------------------------------------


It looks strong going forward , but defensively – no , not really. You are and will be scoring goals – that was never a question, regardless of rvp or not. It is not a question about you being in top 2/3 – it is a question about strengthening the team.

As you have pointed out ,CM is your weakness , and not relative – it is a weakness, as two colossus of defensive duties like Carrick and Anderson do not offer much of a protection to your defence( well, in short times they are actually available to play). Your defence is a relative weakness – as we will need time to see and assess Vidic after 1 year out of the game, same goes for your wingbacks and Peckham boy – but then that will not be that much of an issue as you will outscore most of teams.

What clearly got on red nose nerves last year - was being outmuscled by city midfield – and not you forwards.

As for Ramires and Lamps - any given time – over your dynamic duo! Which is quite irrelevant – as it looks like Oscar will be there…

BTW Oscar > bafta – just to clarify.

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment