or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 64 comments are related to an article called:

Manchester XI Vs London XI

Page 1 of 3

posted on 25/10/12

Manchester

posted on 25/10/12

What about Salford City?

comment by T-BAD (U11806)

posted on 25/10/12

-------------------------Hart----------------
Richards--Kompany--Evans--Clichy
---------------Carrick----Toure------------
Valencia-----------Rooney--------Aguero
------------------------RVP------------------

vs

-------------------------Torres-------------------
Hazard--------------Cazorla------------Mata
-----------------Arteta------Ramires----------
Cole----------Koscielny---Luiz--------Jenkinson
----------------------------Cech-------------------

A few positions I wasn't sure about, have a feeling London XI would win though for some reason.

posted on 25/10/12

Wilshere will be there

posted on 25/10/12

Defoe has to go up top as he is on form rather than Torres.

Plus I would have Bale over Hazard, Dembele over Ramires

posted on 25/10/12

comment by Ion BAG - Nah, I dunno either (U11806)
-----------------
Christ that's disappointing for london, they have 6 premier league teams and Jenkinson is the best right back?

posted on 25/10/12

David Silva surely has to be in the side.

posted on 25/10/12

I'd have Silva over Valencia in Ion BAG - Nah, I dunno either 's side

posted on 25/10/12

comment by Smack Jack The Cracker Man (U8747)
posted 5 minutes ago
Defoe has to go up top as he is on form rather than Torres.

Plus I would have Bale over Hazard, Dembele over Ramires





HeeHeeHee

posted on 25/10/12

Hart
Zabaleta Kompany Evans Clichy
Yaya Garcia
Valencia Silva Nani
RVP

Giroud/Podolski/Torres (take your pick)
Bale Cazorla Mata
Dembele Diaby
Cashley Koscielny Luiz Ivanovic
Cech

posted on 25/10/12

Hart
Richards Kompany Vidic Clichy
Toure Garcia
Silva Rooney Aguero
RVP

Podolski
Bale Mata Hazard
Diaby Dembele
Cole Vermalen Vertonghen Ivanovic
Cech / Lloris

posted on 25/10/12

You are a bit weak up front there, do you want to borrow tevez/aguero/dzeko as you have not included them.

posted on 25/10/12

I don't see how Vermaelen can make a London XI when he's the 3rd best centre back at Arsenal.

Also, you can't play Vertonghen and Vermaelen alongside each other at centre back, they're both left-footed which means there would be no balance.

posted on 25/10/12

This article will probably just turn into a slanging match, but anyway...

We including benches? I think whatever combo that is played the Manchester team would win because the 4 best strikers in the league play there.

posted on 25/10/12

Daz, do your XIs.

posted on 25/10/12

Manchester XI

Hart
Rafael Kompany Smalling Clichy
Toure Carrick
Silva Rooney Aguero
Van Persie

Wow, that is strong. That leaves the likes of Tevez, Nasri, Kagawa, Nani and Valencia on the bench.

London XI

Cech
Ivanovic Koscielny Vertonghen Cole
Arteta Dembele
Mata Cazorla Hazard
Torres

Give me team Manchester anyday.

posted on 25/10/12

To be fair though, doesn't every single thing on this site turn into a slanging match eventually :P

posted on 25/10/12

On form, Rafael is the best RB this season in the Manchester sides. Mine:

Hart
Rafael Kompany Evans Clichy
Carrick Yaya
Nani Rooney Silva
RVP

posted on 25/10/12

Infact, throw Berba up top for team London!

posted on 25/10/12

Zabaleta is by far the best RB in Manchester.

posted on 25/10/12

Has he even been playing games lately? It's been Richards the past few games, and Rafael has shone so far. Defensively and offensively he's been on point.

posted on 25/10/12

He always features. I think Mancini plays Richards against the more physical sides, Zabaleta is a far better player imo.

Rafael has never been on point defensively. The guy is a walking disaster.

posted on 25/10/12

To be fair, and I don't want a slanging match, but Rafael really has been great this season. I think he's the best in Manchester, although I agree that Zabaleta is also a very good right back. Richards is the weakest of the three, in my opinion.

posted on 25/10/12

Manchester:
Hart
Rafael Kompany Evans Clichy
Carrick Toure
Silva Tevez Aguero
RVP

De Gea, Vidic, Zabaleta (due to versatility), Scholes, Rooney, Nani, Valencia

London:

Cech
Sagna Koscielny Terry Cole
Sandro Dembele
Mata Cazorla Hazard
Torres

Lloris, Vertongan, Kaboul, Bale, Oscar, Podolski, Ramires, Adebayor

Real lack of quality strikers in London isn't there?

comment by Bruno (U1664)

posted on 25/10/12

Kamran Im guessing you still feel the same about
Hernandez

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment