Dont overcomplicate what is in fact, a very simple rule
He was offside and the goal shouldnt have counted.
SAF is a fool. he says tat torres could have gona snd scored insttead of falling down... why cant he say the same thing abt Ashley Young?
I NEVER COMMENT ON UNITED POST BUT TODAY YOUR MANAGER HAS LEFT ME FUMING
Maybe because Young couldnt have stayed on his feet considering he was hacked down
no his many other dives you fool
Fergie is a bit rich to talk about Torres staying on his feet because he actually encourages his players to dive, just for the sake of getting a penalty or a free kick & this information came from an ex-United player Jaap Stam. It just shows how classless Fergie & his United lot are because they love to manipulate things. ManU always the victim & never their fault. How is it fair to other clubs for ManU's CEO(David Gill) to be part of the FA board & he even gets promoted to vice-chairman of the FA. Who now stands for election & if he wins, he get's to join the UEFA board. This gets better & better for Man U. What do you get if you take the referee's, FA & spending power away from ManU? A relegated side.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
He wasnt hacked down. He was clipped, exactly the same as Torres. Clattenberg was inconsistent at best, but more like he wasnt inpartial puting it politely.BTW SAF should make sure the ppl on his payroll should refrain from using racist language ie MC
Tbh, I dont think a club who happens to have a player who dives, should be labelled a club that cheats
I dont accuse Liverpool of promoting divers jsut because they have that idiot Suarez. We have Young who goes down easy, Chelsea have their players, Arsenal have theirs...
Every club will have individuals who go down easily. Barca just so happens to have a full team of them
eddiemacB (U3631)
Look a bit closer to home before you criticize our employees. There was much more in the Young scenario than in Torres' watching the replays I'm struggling to see where he was clipped as he seemed quite fine after the challenge and then a second later he buckled and went down to the turf.
ERRRRRR SAF even said he fouled him. Same challenge, same foul different clattenberg outsome
Well back to the topic at hand, about offside. The rule is fine the way it is, Chicharito was offside end of discusion
ERRRRRR SAF even said he fouled him. Same challenge, same foul different clattenberg outsome
http://www.dailypost.co.uk/sport-news/man-utd-fc/2012/10/28/chelsea-2-manchester-united-3-fernando-torres-not-a-victim-says-sir-alex-ferguson-55578-32120082/
Not according to this link sunshine...you want to back up that statement with some proof?
SAF has said on sky sports therev was contaxt.......PR@@T
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11661/8203367/Sir-Alex-Ferguson-believes-Chelsea-s-first-red-card-was-the-catalyst-for-Manchester-United-s-win
Sky says basically the same thing...dig up a link that backs your point or we'll see who the PR@@T
A chelsea fan talking about a club spending money
At least the club spends its own money
Contact doesn't mean a foul, Torres dived IMO, and if you look at it from where the ref is its a huge dive.
Also look at the slow mo, you clearly see Torres step past Evans, see rio covering and decide to go down
To be fair, in Sir Alex's interview on MOTD he did say that there MAY have been contact but Torres went down too easily. Which is true. He also went down holding his knee when Evan's slightly clipped his shin.
Van persies original shot actually went a yard over the line so the offside goal is irrelevant.
ivanovic almost broke evra in half and got away with nothing and then he scythes down young on a 1on1 with the keeper chance, too right a red.
Torres should have been red for his first flying kick at Cleverley anyway so the tackle is irrelevant.
it feels amazing getting luck at Stamford bridge, looking at all the Chelsea fans crying weeeeey.
ohhhhh robin van persie ohhhh robin van persie.
we are championsof Europe we know who we are, shiet song shiet small mentality club weeyy
SAF should make sure the ppl on his payroll should refrain from using racist language ie MC
-------------
This is coming from a Chelsea fan?
Why wasn't Terry playing again?
United weren't capable of winning the match without assistance from the officials. And at the end of the day Chelsea are still top of the league, still European Champions and still playing the best football in the PL.
When we look back in may, yesterday's game was just a blip for us and a very dark day for the impartiality of referees in our game.
If that is what helps you sleep better at night. I think you would find that your team has not been playing it's best football for quite some time...Spurs and Shaktar springs to mind.
Sign in if you want to comment
Chicha's goal
Page 1 of 2
posted on 29/10/12
Dont overcomplicate what is in fact, a very simple rule
He was offside and the goal shouldnt have counted.
posted on 29/10/12
SAF is a fool. he says tat torres could have gona snd scored insttead of falling down... why cant he say the same thing abt Ashley Young?
I NEVER COMMENT ON UNITED POST BUT TODAY YOUR MANAGER HAS LEFT ME FUMING
posted on 29/10/12
Maybe because Young couldnt have stayed on his feet considering he was hacked down
posted on 29/10/12
no his many other dives you fool
posted on 29/10/12
Fergie is a bit rich to talk about Torres staying on his feet because he actually encourages his players to dive, just for the sake of getting a penalty or a free kick & this information came from an ex-United player Jaap Stam. It just shows how classless Fergie & his United lot are because they love to manipulate things. ManU always the victim & never their fault. How is it fair to other clubs for ManU's CEO(David Gill) to be part of the FA board & he even gets promoted to vice-chairman of the FA. Who now stands for election & if he wins, he get's to join the UEFA board. This gets better & better for Man U. What do you get if you take the referee's, FA & spending power away from ManU? A relegated side.
posted on 29/10/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 29/10/12
He wasnt hacked down. He was clipped, exactly the same as Torres. Clattenberg was inconsistent at best, but more like he wasnt inpartial puting it politely.BTW SAF should make sure the ppl on his payroll should refrain from using racist language ie MC
posted on 29/10/12
Tbh, I dont think a club who happens to have a player who dives, should be labelled a club that cheats
I dont accuse Liverpool of promoting divers jsut because they have that idiot Suarez. We have Young who goes down easy, Chelsea have their players, Arsenal have theirs...
Every club will have individuals who go down easily. Barca just so happens to have a full team of them
posted on 29/10/12
eddiemacB (U3631)
Look a bit closer to home before you criticize our employees. There was much more in the Young scenario than in Torres' watching the replays I'm struggling to see where he was clipped as he seemed quite fine after the challenge and then a second later he buckled and went down to the turf.
posted on 29/10/12
ERRRRRR SAF even said he fouled him. Same challenge, same foul different clattenberg outsome
posted on 29/10/12
Well back to the topic at hand, about offside. The rule is fine the way it is, Chicharito was offside end of discusion
posted on 29/10/12
ERRRRRR SAF even said he fouled him. Same challenge, same foul different clattenberg outsome
posted on 29/10/12
http://www.dailypost.co.uk/sport-news/man-utd-fc/2012/10/28/chelsea-2-manchester-united-3-fernando-torres-not-a-victim-says-sir-alex-ferguson-55578-32120082/
Not according to this link sunshine...you want to back up that statement with some proof?
posted on 29/10/12
cheater
posted on 29/10/12
SAF has said on sky sports therev was contaxt.......PR@@T
posted on 29/10/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 29/10/12
http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11661/8203367/Sir-Alex-Ferguson-believes-Chelsea-s-first-red-card-was-the-catalyst-for-Manchester-United-s-win
Sky says basically the same thing...dig up a link that backs your point or we'll see who the PR@@T
posted on 29/10/12
A chelsea fan talking about a club spending money
At least the club spends its own money
posted on 29/10/12
Contact doesn't mean a foul, Torres dived IMO, and if you look at it from where the ref is its a huge dive.
posted on 29/10/12
Also look at the slow mo, you clearly see Torres step past Evans, see rio covering and decide to go down
posted on 29/10/12
To be fair, in Sir Alex's interview on MOTD he did say that there MAY have been contact but Torres went down too easily. Which is true. He also went down holding his knee when Evan's slightly clipped his shin.
posted on 29/10/12
Van persies original shot actually went a yard over the line so the offside goal is irrelevant.
ivanovic almost broke evra in half and got away with nothing and then he scythes down young on a 1on1 with the keeper chance, too right a red.
Torres should have been red for his first flying kick at Cleverley anyway so the tackle is irrelevant.
it feels amazing getting luck at Stamford bridge, looking at all the Chelsea fans crying weeeeey.
ohhhhh robin van persie ohhhh robin van persie.
we are championsof Europe we know who we are, shiet song shiet small mentality club weeyy
posted on 29/10/12
SAF should make sure the ppl on his payroll should refrain from using racist language ie MC
-------------
This is coming from a Chelsea fan?
Why wasn't Terry playing again?
posted on 29/10/12
United weren't capable of winning the match without assistance from the officials. And at the end of the day Chelsea are still top of the league, still European Champions and still playing the best football in the PL.
When we look back in may, yesterday's game was just a blip for us and a very dark day for the impartiality of referees in our game.
posted on 29/10/12
If that is what helps you sleep better at night. I think you would find that your team has not been playing it's best football for quite some time...Spurs and Shaktar springs to mind.
Page 1 of 2